Extended Zero-Gradient-Sum Approach for Constrained Distributed Optimization With Free Initialization

Xinli Shi, Xinghuo Yu, Guanghui Wen, Xiangping XuIEEE Trans. SMC: Systems 2025 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces an "Extended Zero-Gradient-Sum" (EZGS) approach for distributed optimization problems where agents can start with any initial state. The method uses a novel continuous-time algorithm that can achieve various convergence speeds (exponential, finite-time, fixed-time, and prescribed-time) and effectively handles both equality and inequality constraints, outperforming existing methods in simulations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Distributed optimization (DO) is crucial for coordinating multiple agents (like robots or sensors) to collectively solve a problem. Existing DO algorithms often struggle with two main challenges: (1) they require agents to start from specific initial states (often local optima), and (2) they can be complex to implement, especially when dealing with constraints (like resource limits or physical boundaries). This paper tackles these issues by proposing a new algorithm that allows agents to start anywhere and still find the optimal solution, while also offering flexible convergence speeds and robust constraint handling.

Methods

The core of the paper is the Extended Zero-Gradient-Sum (EZGS) approach. It builds upon a Newton-based continuous-time algorithm (CTA) designed for general constrained optimization.

Here's a breakdown of the key methodological contributions:

  • Newton-based CTA for General Optimization: They first develop a CTA that can solve optimization problems with equality constraints. This algorithm is designed to be versatile, capable of achieving different convergence rates (exponential, finite-time, fixed-time, and prescribed-time).
  • Log-Barrier for Inequality Constraints: To handle inequality constraints, they employ a standard technique: the log-barrier method. This transforms inequality constraints into a penalty term in the objective function, making the problem smoother and easier to handle with the CTA.
  • EZGS for Distributed Optimization: The Newton-based CTA is then adapted for distributed settings. A key innovation is the introduction of an "auxiliary dynamics" within each agent's algorithm. This auxiliary part ensures that even if agents start with arbitrary initial states, the overall system eventually satisfies the "Zero-Gradient-Sum" property, which is essential for distributed consensus.
  • Flexible Convergence Rates: The EZGS framework is designed to achieve various convergence behaviors by tuning the parameters and functions within the agents' algorithms. This includes:
  • Finite-Time (FT): Reaching the solution in a finite, but not pre-assigned, time.
  • Fixed-Time (FxT): Reaching the solution in a finite time that is independent of initial conditions but may depend on system parameters.
  • Prescribed-Time (PT): Reaching the solution within a pre-assigned time, offering precise control over convergence speed.
  • Continuous and Bounded Dynamics: For the PT convergence, the authors specifically show that their algorithm's internal dynamics remain continuous and bounded, which is crucial for practical implementation.
  • Heterogeneous Protocols: For FT and FxT convergence, the proposed nonlinear consensus protocols allow for "heterogeneous power coefficients," meaning agents can have different tuning parameters, making the system more adaptable.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and numerical simulations rather than training on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Free Initialization is Key: The ability for agents to start from any initial state (not just local optima) is a significant practical advantage, simplifying deployment and reducing pre-computation requirements.
  • Unified Framework for Convergence Rates: The EZGS approach provides a single algorithmic framework that can be adapted to achieve exponential, finite-time, fixed-time, and prescribed-time convergence by simply changing the agent-level functions. This offers a powerful toolkit for tailoring performance.
  • Prescribed-Time in One Stage: Achieving prescribed-time convergence in a single stage (without cascading sub-problems) is a notable theoretical achievement, simplifying the algorithm's structure.
  • Balancing Computation and Communication: While the Newton-based approach involves matrix inversions (higher computation per agent), it potentially reduces communication overhead compared to methods that require transmitting more information (like global gradients).

Key Results

  • Theoretical Guarantees: The paper provides rigorous mathematical proofs for the convergence properties (EXP, FT, FxT, PT) of the proposed EZGS algorithms under various assumptions.
  • Constraint Handling: The method is shown to effectively handle both equality and inequality constraints in a distributed manner.
  • Numerical Validation: Simulations demonstrate that the EZGS algorithms, particularly the FT, FxT, and PT variants, converge faster and more reliably than existing methods (like PDGD and FT-PDGD) for the tested scenarios.
  • Prescribed-Time Performance: For the PT EZGS, simulations show convergence to the optimal solution within the pre-assigned time, as predicted by the theory.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: The use of matrix inversions in the Newton-based CTA can increase the computational burden on individual agents compared to simpler gradient-based methods.
  • Time-Varying Graphs: The current work primarily focuses on static network topologies. Extending the EZGS approach to handle time-varying communication graphs is suggested as future work.
  • Discretization: The paper presents continuous-time algorithms. Developing discrete-time versions that retain the desirable convergence properties would be a valuable next step for practical implementation on digital systems.
  • Generalization: While the paper addresses general constraints, further exploration of more complex constraint types or scenarios could be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article proposes an extended zero-gradient-sum (EZGS) approach for solving constrained distributed optimization with free initialization and desired convergence properties. A Newton-based continuous-time algorithm is first designed for general constrained optimization, which is adapted to handle inequality constraints by using log-barrier penalty functions. Then, a general class of EZGS dynamics is developed to address equation-constrained distributed optimization, where an auxiliary dynamics is introduced to ensure the final ZGS property from any initialization. It is demonstrated that for typical consensus protocols and auxiliary dynamics, the proposed EZGS dynamics can achieve the performance with exponential/finite/fixed/prescribed-time (PT) convergence. Particularly, the nonlinear consensus protocols for finite-time EZGS algorithms allow for heterogeneous power coefficients. Significantly, the proposed PT EZGS dynamics is continuous, uniformly bounded, and capable of reaching the optimal solution in a single stage. Furthermore, the barrier method is employed to handle the inequality constraints effectively. Finally, the efficiency and performance of the proposed algorithms are validated through numerical examples, highlighting their superiority over existing methods. In particular, by selecting appropriate protocols, the proposed EZGS dynamics can achieve desired convergence performance.
BibTeX
@article{shi2025extended,
  author = {Xinli Shi and Xinghuo Yu and Guanghui Wen and Xiangping Xu},
  title = {{Extended Zero-Gradient-Sum Approach for Constrained Distributed Optimization With Free Initialization}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Syst. Man Cybern. Syst.},
  year = {2025},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=aNClRfB5yt},
}
Figure