Extended field-of-view ultrathin microendoscopes for high-resolution two-photon imaging with minimal invasiveness

Andrea Antonini, Andrea Sattin, Monica Moroni, Serena Bovetti, C Moretti, Francesca Succol, Angelo Forli, Dania Vecchia, Vijayakumar P. Rajamanickam, Andrea Bertoncini, Stefano Panzeri, Carlo Liberale, Tommaso FellineLife 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a new type of ultrathin microendoscope that significantly improves the field-of-view (FOV) and spatial resolution for deep brain imaging. By incorporating custom-designed aspheric microlenses, these "eFOV-microendoscopes" overcome optical aberrations, leading to clearer and more precise recordings of neuronal activity in awake animals, crucial for understanding complex brain functions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Deep brain imaging is essential for understanding how neural circuits function, but it's technically challenging. Current two-photon microscopy techniques often struggle with limited field-of-view (FOV) and uneven spatial resolution, especially when using ultrathin probes (≤500 µm) necessary for minimizing tissue damage. These limitations hinder the ability to capture the activity of large neuronal populations and accurately assess their correlated activity, which is fundamental for understanding neural coding and brain dynamics. Existing solutions often require complex modifications to the optical setup or are limited by manufacturing challenges for miniaturized optics.

Methods

The core innovation is the development of "extended field-of-view" (eFOV) microendoscopes. This was achieved by:

  • 3D-Microprinting of Aspheric Microlenses: Using two-photon lithography (TPL), custom aspheric microlenses were fabricated. These lenses are designed to correct optical aberrations inherent in gradient index (GRIN) rod lenses, which are commonly used in microendoscopes.
  • Integration with GRIN Lenses: The microfabricated aspheric lenses were integrated with existing ultrathin GRIN rod lenses. This integration was designed to be straightforward, requiring no modifications to standard two-photon microscopy setups.
  • Optical Simulations: Ray-trace simulations were used to design and optimize the aspheric lenses, predicting their impact on the point-spread function (PSF), Strehl ratio, and effective FOV.
  • Experimental Validation: The fabricated microendoscopes were characterized using fluorescent beads and thin fluorescent layers to measure spatial resolution and FOV. Functional imaging experiments were conducted in awake, head-fixed mice using genetically encoded calcium indicators (GCaMP6s/7f).
  • Data Analysis: Advanced analysis techniques, including automated segmentation algorithms (CalmAn), information theoretic analysis, and non-negative matrix factorization (NMF), were employed to assess signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), pairwise correlations, and the encoding of behavioral states.

Datasets

  • Synthetic Calcium Imaging Data: Generated to quantitatively compare the performance of corrected and uncorrected microendoscopes in terms of ROI detection, SNR, and pairwise correlation evaluation. This synthetic data was based on known anatomical and functional parameters of the VPM nucleus and biophysical properties of calcium indicators.
  • Experimental Data from Awake Mice: Collected from VPM neurons in awake, head-fixed mice expressing GCaMP6s/7f. This data was used to validate the simulation results and demonstrate the practical utility of the eFOV-microendoscopes for studying neuronal population dynamics and behavioral state encoding.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Aberration Correction is Key for Miniaturized Deep Brain Imaging: The study strongly emphasizes that correcting optical aberrations is crucial for achieving high-resolution, wide-field imaging with ultrathin probes, rather than just increasing probe size.
  • 3D-Printed Optics Enable Practical Solutions: The use of 3D microprinting for fabricating aspheric lenses provides a flexible and accessible method for creating custom optical elements for miniaturized devices.
  • Extended FOV Translates to Better Neuroscience: The improved FOV and resolution directly lead to more accurate measurements of neuronal activity, including higher SNR and more reliable assessment of correlated neuronal activity, which are critical for understanding population codes.
  • Preservation of Neural Connectivity: The ultrathin nature of the microendoscopes, even with integrated optics, was shown to preserve crucial neural pathways, a significant advantage over larger probes.
  • Cell-Specific Encoding Revealed: The enhanced imaging capabilities allowed for the detailed mapping of how individual neurons and subnetworks encode behavioral states, revealing a complex interplay of information at both cellular and population levels.

Key Results

  • Extended FOV: eFOV-microendoscopes demonstrated a 3.2-9.4 fold larger effective FOV compared to uncorrected probes, defined by a spatial resolution threshold.
  • Improved Spatial Resolution: The corrected lenses led to more homogeneous spatial resolution across the FOV, with axial resolution remaining smaller and more similar to the center.
  • Higher SNR: Both simulated and experimental data showed a significant increase in average SNR of calcium signals in corrected microendoscopes.
  • More Accurate Pairwise Correlation: The eFOV-microendoscopes enabled a more precise evaluation of pairwise correlations, reducing artificial increases in correlation strength observed at the FOV periphery with uncorrected probes.
  • Behavioral State Encoding: The technology allowed for the demonstration of cell-specific encoding of whisking-dependent information in distributed VPM subnetworks, revealing both informative neurons and functional ensembles.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Field Curvature: The corrected endoscopes exhibited a curved FOV, which might impact imaging in brain regions with strong axial organization (e.g., hippocampus). However, this effect was considered minimal for regions with homogeneous cell density.
  • Chromatic Aberrations: While the study focused on correcting spherical aberrations, chromatic aberrations were not fully addressed, though simulations suggested they might be manageable for femtosecond lasers.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest extending this approach to GRIN lenses of different lengths and diameters, developing corrective lenses for 3D imaging of larger volumes, and exploring new fabrication materials to address chromatic aberrations. They also envision applications beyond neuroscience, such as in tissue diagnostics.

Summary updated

Abstract

Imaging neuronal activity with high and homogeneous spatial resolution across the field-of-view (FOV) and limited invasiveness in deep brain regions is fundamental for the progress of neuroscience, yet is a major technical challenge. We achieved this goal by correcting optical aberrations in gradient index lens-based ultrathin (≤500 µm) microendoscopes using aspheric microlenses generated through 3D-microprinting. Corrected microendoscopes had extended FOV (<i>eFOV</i>) with homogeneous spatial resolution for two-photon fluorescence imaging and required no modification of the optical set-up. Synthetic calcium imaging data showed that, compared to uncorrected endoscopes, <i>eFOV</i>-microendoscopes led to improved signal-to-noise ratio and more precise evaluation of correlated neuronal activity. We experimentally validated these predictions in awake head-fixed mice. Moreover, using <i>eFOV-</i>microendoscopes we demonstrated cell-specific encoding of behavioral state-dependent information in distributed functional subnetworks in a primary somatosensory thalamic nucleus. <i>eFOV-</i>microendoscopes are, therefore, small-cross-section ready-to-use tools for deep two-photon functional imaging with unprecedentedly high and homogeneous spatial resolution.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{antonini2020extended,
  author = {Andrea Antonini and Andrea Sattin and Monica Moroni and Serena Bovetti and C Moretti and Francesca Succol and Angelo Forli and Dania Vecchia and Vijayakumar P. Rajamanickam and Andrea Bertoncini and Stefano Panzeri and Carlo Liberale and Tommaso Fellin},
  title = {{Extended field-of-view ultrathin microendoscopes for high-resolution two-photon imaging with minimal invasiveness}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.58882},
}
Figure