Extended dissipaton equation of motion for electronic open quantum systems: Application to the Kondo impurity model

Yu Su, Zi‐Hao Chen, Yao Wang, Zheng Xiao, Rui–Xue Xu, YiJing YanarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have developed an extended dissipaton equation of motion (ext-DEOM) that, for the first time, handles quadratic system-bath interactions in fermionic open quantum systems. This theoretical breakthrough allows for the precise simulation of the Kondo resonance, a hallmark of strong electron correlation, which previously eluded standard hierarchical equation methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of quantum physics, "impurity systems"—where a small quantum system (like an atom or a quantum dot) interacts with a large environment (like a metal's conduction electrons)—are fundamental to understanding materials and quantum devices.

Two primary models describe these:

  1. The Anderson Model: Features linear coupling (electrons hopping in and out). This is well-handled by existing methods like the Hierarchical Equations of Motion (HEOM).
  2. The Kondo Model: Features quadratic coupling (the impurity's spin interacts with the environment's total spin).

The challenge is that standard HEOM and its second-quantized cousin, the Dissipaton Equation of Motion (DEOM), were designed for linear interactions. Because the Kondo model involves two-particle (quadratic) interactions between the system and the bath, it creates a mathematical "bottleneck" that standard tools couldn't pass. This paper aims to bridge that gap.

Methods

The authors introduce the ext-DEOM framework. The core "magic" lies in how they treat the environment (the "bath").

  • Dissipaton Algebra: Instead of treating the bath as a vague continuum, they use "dissipatons"—statistical quasi-particles that represent the Gaussian influence of the environment.
  • Generalized Wick’s Theorems (GWT): To handle the quadratic terms, the authors derived a second-order version of Wick’s theorem (GWT-2). This allows them to evaluate the complex three-way interactions between the impurity and the bath operators without losing the underlying physics of many-body correlations.
  • Numerical Implementation: They applied this to the Kondo impurity model, calculating the spin spectral function $A(\omega)$ across various temperatures.

Datasets

As a theoretical physics paper, it does not use external "big data" sets. Instead, it uses the Kondo Impurity Model as its primary benchmark. The results are validated against:

  • Perturbative results: Used for high-temperature checks.
  • Friedel Sum Rule: A theoretical identity used to verify the accuracy of the spectral density at zero frequency and zero temperature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Linearity: The most significant insight is that the dissipaton framework is flexible enough to accommodate non-linear (quadratic) couplings if the underlying algebra is extended correctly.
  • Capturing the "Kondo Peak": At low temperatures, conduction electrons "screen" the impurity spin, creating a sharp peak in the spectral density at the Fermi level. The ext-DEOM successfully captures this emergence, which is a non-perturbative phenomenon.
  • Failure of Perturbation: The paper highlights that while perturbative methods work at high temperatures, they fail spectacularly at low temperatures (producing "spurious peaks"). The ext-DEOM remains robust where these simpler models break down.

Key Results

  • Temperature Dependence: The simulations clearly show the Kondo resonance sharpening as the temperature ($T$) drops. Specifically, they tested values from $\beta W = 1$ to $1000$ (where $\beta$ is inverse temperature and $W$ is bandwidth).
  • Friedel Sum Rule Consistency: The model's results at $\omega = 0$ for very low temperatures approached the theoretical value of 1 (in units of $W$), confirming the method's exactness in the steady-state limit.
  • Convergence: The authors demonstrated that the DEOM calculations converge at a "truncation tier" of $n=6$, proving the method is computationally feasible for these complex systems.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: The authors honestly acknowledge that DEOM faces a "huge computational effort" at extremely low temperatures compared to specialized tools like the Numerical Renormalization Group (NRG).
  • Scaling: While this paper proves the concept for a single impurity, scaling this to lattice models or more complex multi-impurity systems remains a challenge for future research.
  • Real-time Dynamics: The current work focuses heavily on the steady-state spectral function; future work could further explore transient, non-equilibrium dynamics in these quadratic systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we present an extended dissipaton equation of motion for studying the dynamics of electronic impurity systems. Compared with the original theoretical formalism, the quadratic couplings are introduced into the Hamiltonian accounting for the interaction between the impurity and its surrounding environment. By exploiting the quadratic fermionic dissipaton algebra, the proposed extended dissipaton equation of motion offers a powerful tool for studying the dynamical behaviors of electronic impurity systems, particularly in situations where nonequilibrium and strongly correlated effects play significant roles. Numerical demonstrations are carried out to investigate the temperature dependence of the Kondo resonance in the Kondo impurity model.
BibTeX
@misc{su2023extended,
  author = {Yu Su and Zi‐Hao Chen and Yao Wang and Zheng Xiao and Rui–Xue Xu and YiJing Yan},
  title = {{Extended dissipaton equation of motion for electronic open quantum systems: Application to the Kondo impurity model}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2304.08259},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2304.08259},
}

Loading related content...

Figure