Extended Condensed Ultraphosphate Frameworks with Monovalent Ions Combine Lithium Mobility with High Computed Electrochemical Stability

Guopeng Han, Andrij Vasylenko, Alex R. Neale, Benjamin B. Duff, Ruiyong Chen, Matthew S. Dyer, Yun Dang, Luke M. Daniels, Marco Zanella, Craig M. Robertson, Laurence J. Kershaw Cook, Anna‐Lena Hansen, Michael Knapp, Laurence J. Hardwick, Frédéric Blanc, John B. Claridge, Matthew J. RosseinskyJournal of the American Chemical Society 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces two new lithium ultraphosphate materials, Li₃P₅O₁₄ and Li₄P₆O₁₇, which exhibit promising properties for solid-state lithium-ion batteries. Li₃P₅O₁₄, in particular, demonstrates high ionic conductivity and excellent electrochemical stability, making it a potential candidate for next-generation battery electrolytes or cathode coatings.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The quest for safer and more energy-dense batteries hinges on the development of advanced solid-state electrolytes (SSEs). While phosphates are earth-abundant and generally stable, existing crystalline lithium phosphates often suffer from low ionic conductivity or limited electrochemical stability. This limits their practical application in high-performance batteries. Specifically, the authors highlight a gap in the understanding and exploration of extended ultraphosphate anions with lithium, which could offer unique structural features for improved ion transport and stability. They aim to synthesize and characterize new lithium ultraphosphates to address this gap and explore their potential as battery materials.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of synthesis and characterization techniques:

  • Solid-state synthesis: High-temperature reactions in evacuated silica tubes were used to synthesize Li₃P₅O₁₄ and Li₄P₆O₁₇.
  • X-ray Diffraction (XRD): Both powder XRD (for phase purity assessment and Rietveld refinement) and single-crystal XRD (for detailed structural determination) were crucial for understanding the atomic arrangements.
  • Impedance Spectroscopy (AC and DC): This was used to measure the ionic and electronic conductivity of Li₃P₅O₁₄, providing insights into ion transport mechanisms and activation energies.
  • Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) Spectroscopy: Solid-state ¹Li NMR was employed to study the dynamics of lithium ion mobility within the material, particularly at varying temperatures.
  • Electrochemical Testing: Galvanostatic plating/stripping experiments in symmetric Li|Li₃P₅O₁₄|Li cells were conducted to assess the stability of the Li₃P₅O₁₄|Li interface.
  • Computational Methods: Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations were used to predict the thermodynamic stability and electrochemical stability windows of the synthesized materials. Bond valence sum (BVS) mapping was utilized to visualize and understand potential lithium migration pathways.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on the synthesis and characterization of novel materials, rather than training or evaluating models on existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Novel Ultraphosphate Structures: The discovery of Li₃P₅O₁₄ and Li₄P₆O₁₇ represents the first reports of extended ultraphosphate anions with lithium, expanding the known structural diversity in this class of materials.
  • Structure-Property Relationship: The complex, layered structure of Li₃P₅O₁₄, featuring 12-membered rings and 3D interconnected pathways, is directly linked to its enhanced ionic conductivity.
  • Balancing Conductivity and Stability: Li₃P₅O₁₄ demonstrates that high ionic conductivity can be achieved even with a lower Li/P ratio, challenging the notion that high Li content is always necessary for good conductivity. Crucially, this high conductivity is coupled with exceptional electrochemical stability.
  • Computational Prediction Power: DFT calculations accurately predicted the thermodynamic stability of the new materials and provided valuable insights into their electrochemical windows, guiding experimental efforts.
  • Potential for Cathode Coatings: The combination of high ionic conductivity and excellent oxidative stability makes Li₃P₅O₁₄ a promising candidate for cathode coatings in lithium-ion batteries, potentially mitigating interfacial issues.

Key Results

  • Li₃P₅O₁₄:
    • Highest ionic conductivity among reported ternary Li-P-O phases: 8.5(5) × 10⁻⁷ S cm⁻¹ at room temperature.
  • Lowest activation energy for ionic conduction: 0.43(7) eV.
  • Predicted to be stable up to 4.8 V vs. Li/Li⁺, significantly higher than commercial LiPON and other solid electrolytes.
  • Demonstrated stable Li plating/stripping behavior over 100 hours at room temperature.
  • Li₄P₆O₁₇:
    • Features a new type of loop-branched ultraphosphate chain.
  • Also predicted to have high thermodynamic stability against oxidation.
  • General: Both new ultraphosphates are thermodynamically stable according to DFT calculations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Li₄P₆O₁₇ Synthesis: The paper notes that pure bulk samples of Li₄P₆O₁₇ were difficult to synthesize, with Li₃P₅O₁₄ and LiPO₃ often forming as majority phases. Further work is needed to optimize its synthesis.
  • Li₃P₅O₁₄|Li Interface: While plating/stripping tests showed kinetic stability, the interfacial resistivity between Li₃P₅O₁₄ and Li metal was found to be high, suggesting the formation of a passivation layer. This could lead to large overpotentials. The authors suggest that higher temperatures might improve contact but also noted that higher temperatures can accelerate decomposition reactions at the interface.
  • Cathode Integration: While Li₃P₅O₁₄ shows promise as a cathode coating, its performance in a full battery cell with a cathode material needs to be experimentally verified.
  • Defect Chemistry: The authors suggest that controlling defect chemistry through substitution in these new ultraphosphate structures is a promising avenue for further optimization of transport and stability properties.
  • NMR Activation Energy: The activation energy derived from NMR (0.6 eV) is an estimate and should be treated with caution due to the complexity of the Li sites and the simplified model used.

Summary updated

Abstract

Extended anionic frameworks based on condensation of polyhedral main group non-metal anions offer a wide range of structure types. Despite the widespread chemistry and earth abundance of phosphates and silicates, there are no reports of extended ultraphosphate anions with lithium. We describe the lithium ultraphosphates Li<sub>3</sub>P<sub>5</sub>O<sub>14</sub> and Li<sub>4</sub>P<sub>6</sub>O<sub>17</sub> based on extended layers and chains of phosphate, respectively. Li<sub>3</sub>P<sub>5</sub>O<sub>14</sub> presents a complex structure containing infinite ultraphosphate layers with 12-membered rings that are stacked alternately with lithium polyhedral layers. Two distinct vacant tetrahedral sites were identified at the end of two distinct finite Li<sub>6</sub>O<sub>16</sub><sup>26-</sup> chains. Li<sub>4</sub>P<sub>6</sub>O<sub>17</sub> features a new type of loop-branched chain defined by six PO<sub>4</sub><sup>3-</sup> tetrahedra. The ionic conductivities and electrochemical properties of Li<sub>3</sub>P<sub>5</sub>O<sub>14</sub> were examined by impedance spectroscopy combined with DC polarization, NMR spectroscopy, and galvanostatic plating/stripping measurements. The structure of Li<sub>3</sub>P<sub>5</sub>O<sub>14</sub> enables three-dimensional lithium migration that affords the highest ionic conductivity (8.5(5) × 10<sup>-7</sup> S cm<sup>-1</sup> at room temperature for bulk), comparable to that of commercialized LiPON glass thin film electrolytes, and lowest activation energy (0.43(7) eV) among all reported ternary Li-P-O phases. Both new lithium ultraphosphates are predicted to have high thermodynamic stability against oxidation, especially Li<sub>3</sub>P<sub>5</sub>O<sub>14</sub>, which is predicted to be stable to 4.8 V, significantly higher than that of LiPON and other solid electrolytes. The condensed phosphate units defining these ultraphosphate structures offer a new route to optimize the interplay of conductivity and electrochemical stability required, for example, in cathode coatings for lithium ion batteries.
BibTeX
@article{han2021extended,
  author = {Guopeng Han and Andrij Vasylenko and Alex R. Neale and Benjamin B. Duff and Ruiyong Chen and Matthew S. Dyer and Yun Dang and Luke M. Daniels and Marco Zanella and Craig M. Robertson and Laurence J. Kershaw Cook and Anna‐Lena Hansen and Michael Knapp and Laurence J. Hardwick and Frédéric Blanc and John B. Claridge and Matthew J. Rosseinsky},
  title = {{Extended Condensed Ultraphosphate Frameworks with Monovalent Ions Combine Lithium Mobility with High Computed Electrochemical Stability}},
  journal = {Journal of the American Chemical Society},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1021/jacs.1c07874},
}
Figure