Expressions for Stress Concentration Factors for T-Joints of Hollow and Concrete-Filled Square Cross-Sections for In-Plane Axial and Bending Loads

Liyong Gao, Lei Jiang, Xingzheng Wang, Sheng Gao, Hongxu Cui, Jun S. Liu, Hekuan ZhouSymmetry 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents new design formulas for stress concentration factors (SCFs) in concrete-filled square hollow section (CFSHS) T-joints, crucial for the fatigue life of truss bridges. By using finite element analysis and validating with experimental data, the researchers developed equations that account for key geometric parameters, offering a more accurate way to predict fatigue failure in these increasingly common structural elements.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Truss bridges often utilize square hollow section (SHS) joints, and increasingly, these are being filled with concrete (CFSHS) to enhance their structural performance and fatigue life. However, a critical aspect for ensuring the longevity of these structures is understanding stress concentrations, particularly at the joints where fatigue cracks typically initiate. While research exists for empty SHS joints and some concrete-filled circular hollow section (CHS) joints, there's a notable lack of comprehensive design formulas for SCFs in SHS-CFSHS T-joints under various loading conditions. This gap makes it challenging for engineers to accurately assess fatigue risk and design these joints effectively. This paper aims to fill this void by providing robust, empirically-derived formulas for SCFs in SHS-CFSHS T-joints.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Finite Element Analysis (FEA): They developed detailed 3D FE models of SHS-CFSHS T-joints using ABAQUS. These models incorporated realistic material properties for steel and concrete, and carefully considered weld geometries as specified by Chinese standards. To ensure accuracy, they used 20-node solid elements and refined the mesh in critical areas around the weld junctions.
  • Validation: The FE models were rigorously validated against experimental data from four empty SHS T-joints previously tested by Chiew et al. This step was crucial to confirm the models' ability to accurately capture SCFs.
  • Parametric Study: A comprehensive parametric study was conducted by varying three key non-dimensional geometric parameters:
  • $\beta$ (brace-to-chord width ratio)

    • $2\gamma$ (chord width-to-wall thickness ratio)
    • $\tau$ (brace-to-chord wall thickness ratio) These parameters were explored across a range of values relevant to practical applications and existing design codes.
  • Multiple Regression Analysis: The extensive FEA results were then used to derive new parametric formulas for SCFs using multiple regression analysis. These formulas are presented in the form of equations that relate SCFs to the geometric parameters and the applied load cases.

Datasets

The paper utilized experimental data from four empty SHS T-joints previously published by Chiew et al. (2007) for model validation. No new datasets were introduced; instead, the study generated a large dataset of SCF values through FEA for the parametric study.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Concrete Infill's Beneficial Effect: The most significant finding is that concrete infill in SHS chords generally reduces SCFs compared to empty SHS joints, particularly under loads applied to the brace. This is attributed to the concrete's ability to restrict chord face deformation, a primary driver of stress concentration.
  • Load Dependency: The impact of concrete infill varies significantly with the load case. While it reduces SCFs for brace loading, it can increase them for loads applied to the chord. This highlights the importance of considering specific load scenarios.
  • Geometric Parameter Sensitivity: The study revealed that different geometric parameters have varying influences on SCFs. For instance, the width-to-wall thickness ratio of the chord ($2\gamma$) plays a crucial role in bending scenarios, with thicker chords exhibiting higher SCFs at specific locations.
  • Hot Spot Location Specificity: The research confirms that SCFs are not uniform across the joint. Specific locations (lines B and C for thick-walled chords under brace bending, and lines C and D for chord loading) are consistently more critical and require closer attention in design.
  • Thin vs. Thick-Walled Chords: A distinction was made between thin-walled ($2\gamma < 16.0$) and thick-walled ($2\gamma = 25.0$) chords. For thin-walled chords under brace bending, SCFs need to be checked at all lines, whereas for thick-walled chords, lines B and C are the primary concern.

Key Results

  • New SCF Formulas: The paper successfully derived and presented new parametric equations for SCFs in SHS-CFSHS T-joints for four basic load cases: axial force in the brace, in-plane bending in the brace, axial force in the chord, and in-plane bending in the chord.
  • Validation Accuracy: The FE models demonstrated good agreement with experimental data, with the ratio of FEA SCFs to experimental SCFs ranging from 1.000 to 1.104.
  • Formula Accuracy: The proposed formulas showed good accuracy when compared to the FEA results, with mean ratios of SCFProposed/SCFFE generally close to 1.0 (e.g., 1.01 for in-plane bending in the brace, 1.00 for axial force in the chord).
  • SCF Reduction: SHS-CFSHS joints showed significant reductions in SCFs compared to empty SHS joints: 10-26% for axial force in the brace and 14-31% for in-plane bending in the brace.
  • SCF Increase: Conversely, SHS-CFSHS joints exhibited an increase in SCFs for chord loading, with up to a 50% increase at line C for axial force in the chord.
  • Parameter Ranges: The derived formulas are valid for the following parameter ranges: $0.35 \le \beta \le 1.0$; $12.5 \le 2\gamma < 25.0$; and $0.25 < \tau \le 1.0$.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Debonding: The authors acknowledge that the debonding between the concrete infill and the steel tube was not considered in this study. This phenomenon can significantly influence the behavior of CFST structures and should be addressed in future research.
  • Out-of-Plane Loading: The study focused on in-plane loading conditions. Investigating SCFs under out-of-plane bending and torsional loads would provide a more complete picture.
  • Other Joint Types: While T-joints were studied, extending this research to other common joint configurations like K-joints or X-joints would be beneficial.
  • Material Nonlinearity: While the study focused on linear elastic analysis, real-world structures can experience material nonlinearity, especially under extreme loads. Future work could explore the impact of nonlinear material behavior.

Summary updated

Abstract

In recent years, square hollow section (SHS) joints with concrete-filled square hollow section (CFSHS) chords have increasingly been used in truss bridges where the fatigue life reliability is a critical issue. In this paper, a finite element analysis was performed to investigate the SCFs in SHS-CFSHS T-joints under in-plane bending in the brace, axial force in the chord and in-plane bending in the chord. The finite element models were developed and validated with experimental results. Then a parametric study was conducted with a reasonable range of three key non-dimensional parameters, i.e., β (width ratio between brace and chord), 2γ (width–to–wall thickness ratio of the chord) and τ (wall thickness ratio between brace and chord). Consequently, the stress concentration factor formulae for the fatigue design of SHS-CFSHS T-joints were proposed through multiple regression analysis. For in-plane bending in the brace, the maximum stress concentration factors were found at lines B and C for thick-walled chords (2γ = 25.0), while the stress concentration factors at all the lines need to be checked for thin-walled chords (2γ &lt; 16.0). Under axial force in the chord and in-plane bending in the chord, only stress concentration factors at lines C and D needed to be considered. A comparison of stress concentration factors between SHS-SHS and SHS-CFSHS joints showed reductions of 10~26% and 14~31% in stress concentration factors in SHS-CFSHS joints under axial force in the brace and in-plane bending in the brace, respectively. In addition, it showed a general increase in stress concentration factors in SHS-CFSHS joints under axial force and in-plane bending in the chord. This reduction is attributed to the reduction in chord face deformation benefiting from the in-filled concrete. Meanwhile, the stress concentration factors caused by loads in the chord are much lower than those caused by loads in the brace. This work complements earlier studies on SHS-CFSHS T-joints under axial force.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gao2024expressions,
  author = {Liyong Gao and Lei Jiang and Xingzheng Wang and Sheng Gao and Hongxu Cui and Jun S. Liu and Hekuan Zhou},
  title = {{Expressions for Stress Concentration Factors for T-Joints of Hollow and Concrete-Filled Square Cross-Sections for In-Plane Axial and Bending Loads}},
  booktitle = {Symmetry},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/sym16081082},
}
Figure