Expression of the Arabidopsis redox-related LEA protein, SAG21 is regulated by ERF, NAC and WRKY transcription factors

Kelly V. Evans, Elspeth Ransom, Swapna Nayakoti, Ben Wilding, Faezah Mohd Salleh, Irena Gržina, Lieselotte Erber, Carmen Tse, Claire Hill, Krzysztof Polański, Alistair Holland, Sherien Bukhat, Robert J. Herbert, Barend H. J. de Graaf, Katherine Denby, Vicky Buchanan‐Wollaston, Hilary J. RogersScientific 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uncovers a complex regulatory network controlling the expression of SAG21, a plant protein involved in stress responses. By employing yeast-1-hybrid screens and mutant analysis, researchers identified key transcription factors from the ERF, NAC, and WRKY families that bind to the SAG21 promoter and influence its expression under various stress conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Plants constantly face a barrage of environmental challenges, from fluctuating temperatures and water availability to pathogen attacks. To survive, they orchestrate intricate molecular responses, often involving the precise regulation of gene expression. The SAG21 protein, a late embryogenesis abundant (LEA) protein found in Arabidopsis thaliana, is known to be involved in stress tolerance and is mitochondrially located, potentially playing a role in regulating translation. However, the precise mechanisms governing its expression, particularly the transcription factors that control it, remained largely unknown. This paper aims to unravel this complex regulatory network by identifying and functionally validating transcription factors that bind to the SAG21 promoter and influence its expression in response to different environmental cues.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach to identify and validate transcription factor (TF) regulators of SAG21:

  • Bioinformatic Analysis: They used the PlantPAN3.0 database to predict potential TF binding sites (cis-elements) within the SAG21 promoter region and to identify TFs that co-express with SAG21 or have known binding interactions through ChIP data.
  • Yeast-1-Hybrid (Y1H) Screens: This was the core experimental technique. They screened large libraries of Arabidopsis TFs against fragments of the SAG21 promoter (1685 bp upstream of the start codon) to identify TFs that physically bind to these regions. They performed screens with a pooled library of ~1500 TFs, followed by more targeted screens for NAC and WRKY families.
  • Site-Directed Mutagenesis: To confirm the functional importance of predicted binding sites (specifically W-boxes for WRKY and NAC recognition sequences), they mutated these elements within the promoter fragments and re-tested their binding in Y1H assays.
  • Protoplast Co-expression Assays: To assess the functional impact of TF binding in a plant cell context, they co-transformed Arabidopsis leaf protoplasts with a SAG21 promoter-driven GUS reporter construct and expression constructs for candidate TFs. GUS activity served as a proxy for SAG21 expression.
  • Mutant Analysis: They analyzed SAG21 expression in knockout or over-expressor lines of identified TFs (ERF1, ANAC71, WRKY63, WRKY15, and ANAC042) under various stress conditions (ethylene, H2O2, wounding, dehydration, oligogalacturonide elicitors) to determine the in planta functional relevance of these TFs.
  • Real-time qPCR: Used to quantify SAG21 gene expression levels in different genetic backgrounds and under various treatments.
  • hCSI Modelling: Hierarchical Causal Structure Inference was used to build potential regulatory networks upstream of SAG21 based on microarray data under different stress conditions.

Datasets

  • PlantPAN3.0 Database: Used for bioinformatic prediction of TF binding sites and co-expression analysis.
  • ChIP Databases: Utilized for identifying known TF binding interactions.
  • Microarray Datasets (PRESTA project): Used for hCSI modelling of regulatory networks under various stress conditions (leaf senescence, Botrytis cinerea infection, Pseudomonas syringae infection, high light treatment).
  • Arabidopsis thaliana genomic DNA and cDNA: Used for PCR amplification and verification of gene models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SAG21 is a Hub of Complex Regulation: The study reveals that SAG21 expression isn't controlled by a single TF but rather a sophisticated network involving multiple families, highlighting its importance in plant stress responses.
  • ERF, NAC, and WRKY Families are Key Players: These three transcription factor families emerge as major regulators, with specific members showing distinct roles depending on the stress.
  • Stress-Specific Regulation: The same TF can have different effects on SAG21 expression depending on the specific stress. For example, ERF1 appears to activate SAG21 in response to ethylene but might act as a repressor in its absence.
  • Cryptic Binding Sites Exist: The research suggests that some TFs bind to the SAG21 promoter through less conserved or "cryptic" sites, making their identification challenging with standard bioinformatic tools. This was particularly evident for NAC TFs.
  • Functional Validation is Crucial: While Y1H screens identify potential binders, co-expression assays and mutant analysis are essential to confirm functional roles and understand the nuances of TF activity in planta.
  • WRKY63's Dual Role: WRKY63 (also known as ABO3) shows activation of SAG21 in protoplasts but appears to act as a repressor under non-stress and dehydration conditions in planta, indicating context-dependent functions.

Key Results

  • 33 Transcription Factors Identified: A total of 33 TFs from nine different families were identified as binding to the SAG21 promoter using Y1H screens.
  • ERF, WRKY, and NAC Families Prominent: These families were particularly well-represented among the identified TFs.
  • ERF1 and Ethylene: SAG21 upregulation by ethylene was abolished in the erf1 mutant, indicating ERF1's role in mediating this response.
  • ANAC71 and Wounding: Wound-induced SAG21 expression was abolished in anac71 mutants, highlighting ANAC71's importance in wound response.
  • WRKY63 and Pathogen Response: SAG21 upregulation by oligogalacturonide elicitors was partially dependent on WRKY63, suggesting its role in pathogen responses.
  • WRKY63 Activates SAG21 in Protoplasts: Co-expression of WRKY63 with a SAG21 promoter-GUS reporter in protoplasts led to a significant increase in GUS expression.
  • ANAC042 and ROS: Increased SAG21 expression in response to H2O2 was enhanced in anac042 mutants, suggesting ANAC042 might act as a negative regulator of SAG21 in response to ROS.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Y1H Limitations: The authors acknowledge that Y1H screens can miss interactions due to issues with TF processing in yeast or the presence of autoactivation by promoter fragments.
  • Protoplast Assay Limitations: Protoplast assays represent only leaf mesophyll cells and may not fully capture the regulatory network in other tissues or under specific stress conditions.
  • Cryptic Binding Sites: The identification of binding sites for NAC TFs without canonical motifs suggests that further research is needed to fully characterize these interactions.
  • Further Validation Needed: While three TFs (ERF1, ANAC071, WRKY63) had their roles functionally confirmed, the paper suggests that further verification is needed for other identified TFs like WRKY15 and ANAC042.
  • Comprehensive Promoter Analysis: The authors propose that future work should involve detailed analysis of the SAG21 promoter to identify crucial cis-elements and a more comprehensive investigation of SAG21 expression under various developmental stages and stress combinations. This will help to fully disentangle the complex regulatory network.

Summary updated

Abstract

SAG21/LEA5 is an unusual late embryogenesis abundant protein in Arabidopsis thaliana, that is primarily mitochondrially located and may be important in regulating translation in both chloroplasts and mitochondria. SAG21 expression is regulated by a plethora of abiotic and biotic stresses and plant growth regulators indicating a complex regulatory network. To identify key transcription factors regulating SAG21 expression, yeast-1-hybrid screens were used to identify transcription factors that bind the 1685 bp upstream of the SAG21 translational start site. Thirty-three transcription factors from nine different families bound to the SAG21 promoter, including members of the ERF, WRKY and NAC families. Key binding sites for both NAC and WRKY transcription factors were tested through site directed mutagenesis indicating the presence of cryptic binding sites for both these transcription factor families. Co-expression in protoplasts confirmed the activation of SAG21 by WRKY63/ABO3, and SAG21 upregulation elicited by oligogalacturonide elicitors was partially dependent on WRKY63, indicating its role in SAG21 pathogen responses. SAG21 upregulation by ethylene was abolished in the erf1 mutant, while wound-induced SAG21 expression was abolished in anac71 mutants, indicating SAG21 expression can be regulated by several distinct transcription factors depending on the stress condition.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{evans2024expression,
  author = {Kelly V. Evans and Elspeth Ransom and Swapna Nayakoti and Ben Wilding and Faezah Mohd Salleh and Irena Gržina and Lieselotte Erber and Carmen Tse and Claire Hill and Krzysztof Polański and Alistair Holland and Sherien Bukhat and Robert J. Herbert and Barend H. J. de Graaf and Katherine Denby and Vicky Buchanan‐Wollaston and Hilary J. Rogers},
  title = {{Expression of the Arabidopsis redox-related LEA protein, SAG21 is regulated by ERF, NAC and WRKY transcription factors}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-58161-0},
}
Figure