Abstract
Well aligned carbon nanotubes (CNTs) are highly desirable for various studies and applications. Template-assisted chemical vapor deposition has been widely used. However, post growth surface cleaning to remove the junk carbon on sample surface and expose CNTs still relies on either capital intensive facilities or 'hard to control' processes. In the letter, we report a mechanical polishing method to remove the amorphous carbon layer. Compared to other conventional surface cleaning methods, mechanical polishing is relatively straightforward, much easier to scale up and does not require expensive instruments. Combined with a wet-etching step, highly ordered CNT arrays were reliably obtained. Scanning electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy were employed to investigate the surface morphology and roughness and to optimize the processing conditions.
Introduction
Template-assisted Catalytic Chemical Vapor Deposition (CCVD) is a premier method for growing highly ordered, vertically aligned carbon nanotube (CNT) arrays. By growing nanotubes inside the pores of an Anodized Aluminum Oxide (AAO) template, researchers can precisely control the diameter and density of the resulting "nano-forest." However, a significant challenge remains: the process leaves a layer of amorphous "junk" carbon on the surface, which caps the nanotubes and prevents them from being used in applications like sensors, field emitters, or electronic devices.
Existing solutions are often problematic. Air oxidation is difficult to control and can damage the CNTs, while Reactive Ion Etching (RIE) is precise but requires expensive equipment and can take up to five hours per sample. This study introduces a simple, low-cost, two-step method using mechanical polishing and wet etching to overcome these barriers.
Experimental Methods
The proposed post-growth treatment consists of two primary steps: mechanical polishing followed by selective wet etching.
- Mechanical Polishing: The as-grown sample is polished for one minute at 144 rpm. To optimize surface quality, the researchers evaluated three different alumina polishing particle sizes: 1µm, 300nm, and 50nm.
- Wet Etching: Following polishing, the sample is submerged in a 0.01M NaOH solution for 20 minutes. This step selectively dissolves a portion of the alumina template, "uncovering" the nanotubes to a uniform height.
Characterization and Data Analysis
The effectiveness of the cleaning process was verified using Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM). SEM was used to visualize surface morphology and pore distribution, while AFM provided quantitative measurements of surface roughness. ImageJ software was employed to analyze SEM micrographs and extract quantitative pore size distributions.
Key Results and Discussion
The study revealed that polishing particle size is critical for achieving a smooth surface. While 1µm particles resulted in a relatively high surface roughness (16.4nm RMS), 50nm particles yielded an RMS roughness of just 2.1nm—a result comparable to high-end RIE methods but achieved in a fraction of the time.
The mechanical polishing step effectively "breaks the seal" of the chemically inert amorphous carbon layer, allowing the subsequent wet etching step to work uniformly. AFM results confirmed that CNTs were exposed to a consistent height of approximately 50nm across the sample. This uniformity is vital for device integration and consistent performance in field emission applications.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
This two-step method offers a faster, more accessible alternative to traditional cleanroom-based techniques. By replacing five hours of RIE with just one minute of mechanical polishing, the throughput for high-quality CNT array fabrication is significantly increased. Future work will focus on scaling this process for industrial applications and investigating the electrical contact resistance of the exposed nanotubes for device integration.
Summary updated