TL;DR
This study investigates the factors influencing the adoption of electric bicycle-sharing systems (EBSSs) by extending the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM). It reveals that perceived pleasure and reliability positively impact user attitudes, while perceived cost negatively affects them. Notably, perceived environmental value has a limited direct impact on user intention, suggesting a need for targeted marketing strategies.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The proliferation of private vehicles has led to significant environmental and congestion issues in urban areas. Bike-sharing systems, particularly electric bicycle-sharing systems (EBSSs), have emerged as a promising solution for last-mile connectivity and sustainable urban transport. However, despite their growing popularity, there's a lack of empirical research understanding the specific factors driving user acceptance of EBSSs, especially compared to traditional bike-sharing systems. This paper aims to fill this gap by examining user perceptions and their influence on the intention to use EBSSs, using a modified TAM framework.
Methods
The researchers employed a quantitative approach using Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM) to analyze data collected from a survey of EBSS users in China. They extended the classic TAM by incorporating four additional variables: perceived pleasure (PP), perceived environmental value (PEV), perceived cost (PC), and perceived reliability (PR). These variables, along with perceived usefulness (PU) and perceived ease of use (PEU), were hypothesized to influence behavior attitude (BA) and behavior intention (BI), ultimately affecting actual behavior (AB). The study also conducted a multigroup analysis (MGA) to explore how demographic factors (age, gender, education, and prior experience with classic bike-sharing systems) moderate the relationships within the model.
Datasets
The study utilized a dataset of 399 valid responses collected through a questionnaire survey administered to EBSS users in Xiangtan, China. The survey included questions about demographic information and the EBSS-TAM scale, which measured nine latent variables using Likert scales. No new benchmarks were introduced; the data was collected specifically for this study.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Beyond Usefulness and Ease: While perceived usefulness and ease of use are foundational to technology acceptance, this study highlights that for EBSSs, factors like the sheer enjoyment (perceived pleasure) and trustworthiness (perceived reliability) of the service are crucial for shaping positive attitudes.
- Environmental Value's Indirect Role: The paper suggests that while EBSSs are environmentally friendly, users don't necessarily prioritize this aspect directly when forming their attitudes or intentions. This implies that marketing efforts might be more effective if they focus on the immediate benefits (pleasure, cost, reliability) rather than solely on environmental impact.
- Cost Matters for Attitude, Not Necessarily Intention: Perceived cost significantly influences a user's attitude towards EBSSs, but it doesn't directly translate into their intention to use the service. This could mean that while users might have a negative attitude due to cost, they might still use the service if other factors (like convenience or necessity) are strong enough.
- Younger, Male Users are Key: The multigroup analysis revealed that younger users (under 35) are more inclined to switch to EBSSs, and male users report higher satisfaction due to ease of use. This points to specific demographic segments that could be targeted for growth.
- New Users Value Environmental Benefits More: Interestingly, users who have never used classic bike-sharing systems perceive the environmental value of EBSSs more strongly. This suggests that EBSSs might be a gateway for new users to adopt sustainable transportation.
Key Results
- Perceived usefulness (PU) positively impacts behavior attitude (BA) and behavior intention (BI).
- Perceived ease of use (PEU) positively affects BA, PU, perceived pleasure (PP), and perceived environmental value (PEV).
- Perceived pleasure (PP) positively impacts BA but has no direct effect on BI.
- Perceived cost (PC) negatively impacts BA but has no direct effect on BI.
- Perceived reliability (PR) positively impacts BA but has no direct effect on BI.
- Perceived environmental value (PEV) did not show a significant direct impact on BA or BI.
- Behavior attitude (BA) has a significant positive effect on behavior intention (BI), and BI has a significant positive effect on actual behavior (AB).
- Younger users (under 35) showed a stronger positive impact of BA on BI compared to older users.
- Male users reported a stronger positive impact of PEU on PP.
- Users who never used classic bike-sharing systems showed a stronger positive impact of PEU on PEV.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations. Firstly, the study was conducted in a small- to medium-sized city in China, and its findings may not be directly generalizable to large metropolises. Future research could explore the applicability of these findings in different urban contexts. Secondly, the study focused on user perceptions; future work could incorporate the perspectives of city authorities, traditional bicycle suppliers, and other stakeholders. Finally, the authors suggest exploring the incorporation of interactions between consumers, businesses, and employees into the conceptual model to provide a more holistic understanding of EBSS adoption.
Summary updated