Exploring the ternary interactions in Cu–ZnO–ZrO2 catalysts for efficient CO2 hydrogenation to methanol

Yuhao Wang, Shyam Kattel, Wengui Gao, Kongzhai Li, Ping Liu, Jingguang G. Chen, Hua WangNature Communications 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the complex interplay between copper (Cu), zinc oxide (ZnO), and zirconium dioxide (ZrO2) in catalysts designed for converting CO2 and hydrogen into methanol. By combining in-situ spectroscopy and theoretical calculations, they pinpoint the ZnO-ZrO2 interface as crucial for CO2 activation and the formate pathway, while metallic Cu is essential for hydrogen supply, leading to a highly efficient catalyst.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The conversion of carbon dioxide (CO2) into valuable chemicals like methanol is a critical area of research for mitigating climate change and developing sustainable energy solutions. Copper-supported catalysts, particularly those incorporating ZnO and ZrO2 (Cu-ZnO-ZrO2 or CZZ), have shown great promise due to their high activity and selectivity. However, the precise role of each component and their synergistic interactions within these complex ternary systems remain poorly understood. This lack of fundamental understanding hinders the rational design of even more efficient catalysts. Previous research often focused on binary systems (e.g., Cu/ZnO or Cu/ZrO2), leaving the specific contributions of the ZnO-ZrO2 interface and the combined ternary interactions largely unexplored, especially under realistic reaction conditions.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Catalyst Synthesis: They prepared three-dimensional ordered macroporous (3DOM) CZZ catalysts with varying ZnO particle sizes. This controlled morphology allowed them to investigate the impact of ZnO size on catalytic performance. They also prepared conventional (nonporous) CZZ catalysts for comparison.
  • In Situ Diffuse Reflectance Infrared Fourier Transform Spectroscopy (DRIFTS): This technique was used to monitor the surface species and reaction intermediates in real-time under actual reaction conditions (3 MPa pressure, 493 K temperature). This is crucial for understanding the reaction mechanism as it happens.
  • Density Functional Theory (DFT) Calculations: DFT was employed to model the interactions at the atomic level, specifically focusing on the ZnO-ZrO2 interface. This allowed them to calculate binding energies, activation energies, and reaction pathways for key steps in the CO2 hydrogenation to methanol process.
  • Standard Characterization Techniques: Techniques like SEM, TEM, EDS, XRD, XPS, and CO2-TPD were used to characterize the physical and chemical properties of the synthesized catalysts.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental and computational investigations of synthesized catalysts, not on training or evaluating models on pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The ZnO-ZrO2 Interface is Key for CO2 Activation: The study strongly suggests that the interface between ZnO and ZrO2 is the primary site for CO2 adsorption and its initial conversion into intermediates like formate. This is a significant finding, as it highlights the importance of the support material's interaction beyond just providing a scaffold for the active metal.
  • Formate Pathway Dominates: The in-situ DRIFTS experiments clearly indicate that the CO2 hydrogenation to methanol over these CZZ catalysts proceeds via the formate pathway, where formate is a crucial intermediate that is subsequently hydrogenated.
  • Synergistic Roles of Components:
    • ZnO-ZrO2 Interface: Facilitates CO2 adsorption and the hydrogenation of carbonate intermediates to more reactive species (formate).
  • Metallic Cu: Essential for the dissociation of H2 and providing the necessary hydrogen atoms for the subsequent hydrogenation steps, particularly for converting formate to methoxy and then to methanol.
  • Tuning ZnO Particle Size Matters: Reducing the ZnO particle size significantly enhances catalytic activity, likely by increasing the density of the active ZnO-ZrO2 interface.
  • Absence of CO as a Primary Intermediate: Unlike some other CO2 hydrogenation mechanisms, the formation of CO (via the reverse water-gas shift reaction) was not found to be a direct precursor to methanol under the studied conditions, reinforcing the formate pathway.
  • DFT Confirms Experimental Observations: The theoretical calculations align well with the experimental findings, providing atomic-level explanations for the observed reactivity and the importance of the ZnO-ZrO2 interface.

Key Results

  • High Catalytic Performance: The optimized 3DOM CZZ catalyst (M-CZZ(16)) achieved a remarkable 18.2% CO2 conversion and 80.2% methanol selectivity at 493 K and 3.0 MPa. This performance is noted as among the best reported for CZZ catalysts under comparable conditions.
  • ZnO Particle Size Effect: Catalytic activity (CO2 conversion, methanol selectivity, and TOF) decreased with increasing ZnO particle size, underscoring the importance of the ZnO-ZrO2 interface.
  • Formate Formation: In situ DRIFTS showed strong formate bands (1589, 1386, 1362 cm⁻¹) appearing rapidly upon H2 introduction, indicating efficient CO2 conversion to formate.
  • DFT Binding Energies: The binding energy of CO2 on the ZrO2/ZnO interface (-2.32 eV) was significantly stronger than on other interfaces, supporting its role in CO2 activation. The energy barrier for the rate-limiting step (*HCOO hydrogenation) was also lowered at the ZnO-ZrO2 interface.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cu Component in DFT: The DFT calculations primarily focused on the ZnO-ZrO2 interface and did not explicitly model the metallic Cu component in detail. While the paper acknowledges Cu's role in H2 dissociation, a more integrated DFT model could provide deeper insights into the ternary synergy.
  • Oxygen Vacancies: While XPS and CO2-TPD suggest the ZnO-ZrO2 interaction promotes oxygen vacancies, their direct role in the reaction mechanism could be further elucidated.
  • Tuning Interactions: The paper suggests that tuning the ZnO-ZrO2 interaction is a key factor for catalyst design. Future work could explore various methods to precisely control this interaction and its impact on catalyst performance.
  • Long-Term Stability: While the catalysts showed high activity, long-term stability studies under industrial conditions would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

The synergistic interaction among different components in complex catalysts is one of the crucial factors in determining catalytic performance. Here we report the interactions among the three components in controlling the catalytic performance of Cu-ZnO-ZrO<sub>2</sub> (CZZ) catalyst for CO<sub>2</sub> hydrogenation to methanol. The in situ diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy (DRIFTS) measurements under the activity test pressure (3 MPa) reveal that the CO<sub>2</sub> hydrogenation to methanol on the CZZ catalysts follows the formate pathway. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations agree with the in situ DRIFTS measurements, showing that the ZnO-ZrO<sub>2</sub> interfaces are the active sites for CO<sub>2</sub> adsorption and conversion, while the presence of metallic Cu is also necessary to facilitate H<sub>2</sub> dissociation and to provide hydrogen resource. The combined experiment and DFT results reveal that tuning the interaction between ZnO and ZrO<sub>2</sub> can be considered as another important factor for designing high performance catalysts for methanol generation from CO<sub>2</sub>.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2019exploring,
  author = {Yuhao Wang and Shyam Kattel and Wengui Gao and Kongzhai Li and Ping Liu and Jingguang G. Chen and Hua Wang},
  title = {{Exploring the ternary interactions in Cu–ZnO–ZrO2 catalysts for efficient CO2 hydrogenation to methanol}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-019-09072-6},
}
Figure