Abstract
This study employs a phenomenological approach to investigate how familial, social, and cultural factors influence the academic and career decision-making of Chinese and Indian STEM doctoral students in the U.S. Through semi-structured interviews with three Chinese and three Indian students, followed by thematic analysis, the study identified five themes and ten subthemes. Findings indicate that Indian students reported strong reinforcement from familial and societal expectations to pursue careers in engineering and medicine, whereas Chinese students did not demonstrate such strong tendencies to choose specific fields based on familial influences. Moreover, the acculturation process of studying abroad led to a shift in identity, particularly through the development of research autonomy and financial self-sufficiency. Career decisions after graduation were influenced by social policies and family background, such as work-life balance, employment opportunities, and the legacy of the One-Child Policy.
Introduction
Chinese and Indian students constitute over 50% of the international student population in the U.S., with a heavy concentration in STEM fields. Despite their significant presence, research often treats "international students" as a monolith, overlooking the distinct cultural pressures that drive their decisions. This study addresses the gap in understanding how deeply ingrained cultural norms—specifically the centrality of family in collectivist societies—interact with the "acculturation" process of studying abroad. It explores how these students navigate the transition from "knowledge learners" in their home cultures to "knowledge creators" in the more autonomous U.S. academic environment.
Methodology and Framework
The research utilizes a phenomenological approach, focusing on the lived experiences of participants. The analysis is grounded in two primary theoretical frameworks: Family System Theory (FST), which views the family as an interconnected emotional unit, and Acculturation Theory (AT), which examines how individuals adapt to new cultural environments.
The study involved semi-structured interviews with six international STEM doctoral students (3 Chinese, 3 Indian). The participants represented a mix of genders and ages (23–30) across various fields, including Systems Engineering, Biological Engineering, and Cell and Molecular Biology. The interviews were analyzed using thematic analysis to identify recurring patterns in their narratives.
Key Insights and Results
The thematic analysis identified five major themes that characterize the doctoral journey and decision-making process for these students.
The "Elite" Beacon and Major Selection
For both groups, a U.S. education is viewed as a significant social status symbol. However, a sharp contrast emerged in major selection: Indian students reported that choosing engineering or medicine was often a "familial duty" and rarely negotiable. Conversely, Chinese students felt more agency in choosing their specific fields, though they still felt the weight of general high expectations from their families.
Identity Evolution and Autonomy
Students experienced a cognitive shift from being passive "students" to independent "researchers." This transition often conflicts with home-country educational systems that emphasize theory over practical autonomy. Interestingly, as students reach the PhD level, family expectations often shift from academic performance to personal well-being, largely because parents are unfamiliar with the complexities of the U.S. doctoral system.
The Stay vs. Return Decision
Decisions regarding post-graduation plans are rarely purely personal. For Chinese students, the "One-Child Policy" creates a unique pressure; being an only child often dictates a return home to care for aging parents. In contrast, Indian participants highlighted "work-life balance" as a primary reason for wanting to stay in the U.S., noting that such a concept is often absent in the professional culture of their home country.
Conclusion
The study highlights that the academic and career trajectories of international STEM students are shaped by "invisible hands" of family and culture. While the U.S. environment fosters independence, students remain deeply connected to their home-country obligations. Future research is suggested to use larger, random samples to enhance generalizability and to explore how these cultural norms are passed down to future generations in the diaspora.
Summary updated