Exploring the Interaction between Local and Global Latent Configurations for Clustering Single-Cell RNA-Seq: A Unified Perspective

Nairouz Mrabah, Mohamed Mahmoud Amar, Mohamed Bouguessa, Abdoulaye Baniré DialloAAAI 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces scTPF, a novel deep learning framework for clustering single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) data. It addresses the critical challenge of balancing reconstruction and clustering tasks by proposing a unique topological and probabilistic filtering mechanism to mitigate "Feature Randomness" and a graph-based correction strategy to counter "Feature Drift," leading to improved cell type identification.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) generates vast datasets that are crucial for understanding complex biological systems, from tissue development to disease mechanisms. A fundamental step in analyzing this data is clustering cells into distinct types based on their gene expression profiles. While deep learning, particularly autoencoders, has shown promise, current methods struggle with three key issues:

  1. Feature Randomness (FR): Errors introduced during the pseudo-supervised embedding clustering task can accumulate, corrupting latent representations and hindering accurate clustering.
  2. Feature Drift (FD): The reconstruction task, aimed at reducing FR, can inadvertently conflict with the clustering objective by altering the very features needed to distinguish cell types.
  3. Ignoring Latent Space Topology: Many methods overlook the valuable information contained in the local and global structural relationships between cells in the latent space, which can offer complementary insights for clustering.

These challenges lead to suboptimal clustering results, making it difficult to accurately identify cell types, especially rare ones.

Methods

scTPF tackles these issues through a two-phase approach:

Phase 1: Pretraining (Self-Supervision) * Graph Auto-Encoder: The model first uses a graph auto-encoder to learn low-dimensional latent representations (Z) of cells, capturing both gene expression (X) and cell-cell structural information (A) from an initial graph G. * Reconstruction Objective: A self-supervised loss function (Lss) is employed to reconstruct the input graph G from the latent codes Z. This phase aims to learn robust initial representations and prevent the extraction of pseudo-labels from random latent codes.

Phase 2: Clustering (Pseudo-Supervision + Self-Supervision) This phase introduces the core innovations:

  • Pseudo-Supervision with FR Protection:
    • Topological and Probabilistic Filter (F): This novel filter is designed to identify reliable samples for embedding clustering. It combines:
  • A probabilistic component that considers the global relationship between latent codes and trainable clustering centers.
  • A topological component that analyzes the local neighborhood structure of cells in the latent space using a k-NN graph.
  • Pseudo-Supervised Loss (Lps): This loss uses a target clustering distribution (q) derived from the filtered reliable samples to guide the embedding clustering task, effectively mitigating Feature Randomness.
  • Self-Supervision with FD Correction:
    • Graph Progressive Transformation (T): This mechanism progressively transforms the initial graph G into a more clustering-oriented graph Gclus. It involves two operations:
  • Global Configuration Adjustment (T1): Modifies the gene expression features (X) based on latent centers to create Xclus.
  • Local Configuration Adjustment (T2): Modifies the graph structure (A) based on latent topology and clustering assignments to create Aclus.
  • Clustering-Oriented Self-Supervised Loss (Lss(Gclus)): This loss aims to reconstruct the transformed graph Gclus, counteracting Feature Drift by making the reconstruction task more aligned with clustering.

The overall loss for this phase is a combination of the pseudo-supervised loss (Lps) and the clustering-oriented self-supervised loss (Lss(Gclus)), balanced by a hyperparameter γ.

Datasets

The paper evaluates scTPF on eight representative real-world scRNA-seq datasets from various sequencing platforms and species. These datasets are standard benchmarks for scRNA-seq analysis. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The FR-FD Trade-off is Crucial: The paper highlights that existing deep clustering methods often overlook the inherent conflict between reducing Feature Randomness (FR) and preventing Feature Drift (FD). scTPF's unified approach directly addresses this trade-off.
  • Topology Matters for Clustering: Integrating local and global topological information from the latent space is not just beneficial but essential for robust clustering. The proposed filter (F) and transformation (T) leverage this by analyzing both neighborhood structures and overall data distribution.
  • Gradual Filtering is Key: Instead of trying to correct noisy pseudo-labels after they are generated, scTPF's filter proactively selects reliable samples, leading to more stable and accurate learning.
  • Progressive Graph Transformation: The idea of gradually transforming the graph structure and content to be more "clustering-oriented" is a novel way to align the self-supervised reconstruction task with the primary clustering objective.

Key Results

  • State-of-the-Art Performance: scTPF consistently outperforms existing state-of-the-art methods (including deep embedding, deep clustering, and deep graph clustering approaches) across eight scRNA-seq datasets in terms of ACC, NMI, and ARI metrics. For example, the average difference in performance between scTPF and the next best method (scTAG) was significant.
  • Effective Mitigation of FR and FD: Ablation studies demonstrate that the proposed FR and FD mechanisms significantly improve clustering performance, as evidenced by lower FR and FD metrics (AFR and AFD).
  • Competitive Computational Cost: Despite its advanced architecture, scTPF's execution time remains competitive with many other recent strategies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Hyperparameter Sensitivity: While the paper shows scTPF is robust to a range of hyperparameters (€ and k), tuning these might still require careful consideration for optimal performance on new datasets.
  • Computational Cost of Graph Construction: Building and processing the k-NN graph in the latent space can add to the computational overhead, especially for very large datasets.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further exploration of the interaction between local and global latent configurations could lead to even more sophisticated clustering methods. The framework could also be extended to other single-cell analysis tasks beyond clustering.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{mrabah2023exploring,
  author = {Nairouz Mrabah and Mohamed Mahmoud Amar and Mohamed Bouguessa and Abdoulaye Baniré Diallo},
  title = {{Exploring the Interaction between Local and Global Latent Configurations for Clustering Single-Cell RNA-Seq: A Unified Perspective}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1609/aaai.v37i8.26107},
}
Figure