Exploring the Galactic Warp through Asymmetries in the Kinematics of the Galactic Disk

Xinlun Cheng, Borja Anguiano, Steven R. Majewski, Christian R. Hayes, Phil Arras, C. Chiappini, Sten Hasselquist, A. B. A. Queiroz, Christian Nıtschelm, D. A. García–Hernández, Richard R. Lane, Alexandre Roman–Lopes, Peter M. FrinchaboyThe Astrophysical Journal 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages Gaia DR2 and APOGEE data with sophisticated distance estimations to create the most detailed map yet of stellar motions in the Milky Way's outer disk. They reveal a clear signature of the galactic warp in stellar kinematics, finding it to be lopsided and modeling its onset and precession, suggesting an external gravitational origin.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Milky Way galaxy isn't perfectly flat; its outer disk is known to be "warped," meaning it bends out of shape. This warp significantly influences how stars move, but studying its full extent has been challenging. Previous research was often limited to regions near our Sun due to inaccuracies in estimating stellar distances. This paper aims to overcome these limitations by using a more comprehensive dataset and advanced techniques to map the warp's influence on stellar kinematics across a much larger volume of the galaxy. Understanding the warp is crucial for comprehending the overall structure and evolution of our galaxy.

Methods

The authors combine data from two major astronomical surveys: Gaia DR2, which provides precise astrometric (position and motion) data for billions of stars, and APOGEE, which offers detailed chemical composition and radial velocity information for a subset of stars. A key innovation is the use of "StarHorse" distances, which combine Gaia data with other photometric surveys to provide more accurate distance estimates, especially for stars further away. They then analyze the vertical (z) and radial (R) velocities of stars, looking for patterns related to their Galactocentric radius, angular momentum, and azimuthal angle. They also develop a simple analytical model based on the Jeans Equation to explain the observed kinematic trends, particularly the global increase and subsequent decrease in vertical velocity.

Datasets

  • Gaia DR2: Provides 6-dimensional phase-space coordinates (positions, parallaxes, proper motions, radial velocities) for millions of stars.
  • APOGEE (SDSS-IV): Provides high-resolution spectroscopic data, from which stellar atmospheric parameters and chemical abundances are derived.
  • StarHorse: A code used to derive more accurate stellar distances and extinctions by combining Gaia DR2 data with other photometric catalogs (Pan-STARRS1, 2MASS, AllWISE) and informative Galactic priors.
  • Sanders & Das (2018) stellar age catalog: Used to investigate age variations in warp characteristics.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Warp is Lopsided: The study finds that the vertical velocity trends with azimuthal angle are not symmetrical, suggesting the galactic warp is "lopsided" rather than perfectly balanced.
  • External Origin Strongly Supported: The warp's parameters (onset radius and precession rate) remain consistent across different stellar age groups. This consistency points towards an external, gravitational influence (like a satellite galaxy interaction) as the cause, rather than an internal process that would likely evolve differently with age.
  • Detailed Kinematic Mapping: By combining precise distances with kinematic data, the authors provide the most detailed and radially expansive view of the warp's impact on stellar motions to date.
  • Ripples and Spiral Arms: Smaller, wave-like "ripples" are observed in both vertical and radial velocities, which show some correlation with the positions of known spiral arms, though the relationship isn't perfectly one-to-one.

Key Results

  • A clear decrease in vertical velocity is observed starting around a Galactocentric radius of R = 13 kpc and angular momentum Lz = 2800 kpc km s⁻¹.
  • The analytical model for the warp's onset radius yielded a best fit of $R_1 = 8.87 \pm 0.09$ kpc and a precession rate of $w_p = -13.57 \pm 0.28$ km s⁻¹ kpc⁻¹.
  • The study confirms that thin disk stars are the primary tracers of the warp's kinematic signature, as opposed to thick disk or halo stars.
  • While the precession rate and lopsidedness of the warp appear similar across different age populations, the amplitude of the vertical velocity response varies, with younger stars showing a larger amplitude.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplicity: The analytical model used to explain the warp is a simplification and does not fully capture all observed phenomena, such as the smaller-scale ripples or the warp's lopsidedness.
  • Inner Galaxy: The model is designed for and constrained by the outer disk (R > 8 kpc), and thus does not accurately represent the kinematics within the solar circle.
  • Halo Contamination: For older stellar populations (>9 Gyr), the presence of halo stars can contaminate the sample, making it difficult to isolate the warp's signature.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future work could explore more complex models that incorporate additional physics (like flaring, disk truncation, or star formation history) and investigate the detailed mechanisms behind the observed kinematic ripples. Further studies could also refine the warp parameters and explore its interaction with other galactic components.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Previous analyses of large databases of Milky Way stars have revealed the stellar disk of our Galaxy to be warped and that this imparts a strong signature on the kinematics of stars beyond the solar neighborhood. However, due to the limitation of accurate distance estimates, many attempts to explore the extent of these Galactic features have generally been restricted to a volume near the Sun. By combining the Gaia DR2 astrometric solution, StarHorse distances, and stellar abundances from the APOGEE survey, we present the most detailed and radially expansive study yet of the vertical and radial motions of stars in the Galactic disk. We map velocities of stars with respect to their Galactocentric radius, angular momentum, and azimuthal angle and assess their relation to the warp. A decrease in vertical velocity is discovered at Galactocentric radius R = 13 kpc and angular momentum L z = 2800 kpc km s −1 . Smaller ripples in vertical and radial velocity are also discovered superposed on the main trend. We also discovered that trends in the vertical velocity with azimuthal angle are not symmetric about the peak, suggesting the warp is lopsided. To explain the global trend in vertical velocity, we built a simple analytical model of the Galactic warp. Our best fit yields a starting radius of and precession rate of . These parameters remain consistent across stellar age groups, a result that supports the notion that the warp is the result of an external, gravitationally induced phenomenon.
BibTeX
@article{cheng2020exploring,
  author = {Xinlun Cheng and Borja Anguiano and Steven R. Majewski and Christian R. Hayes and Phil Arras and C. Chiappini and Sten Hasselquist and A. B. A. Queiroz and Christian Nıtschelm and D. A. García–Hernández and Richard R. Lane and Alexandre Roman–Lopes and Peter M. Frinchaboy},
  title = {{Exploring the Galactic Warp through Asymmetries in the Kinematics of the Galactic Disk}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/abc3c2},
}
Figure