Exploring the Functional and Geometric Bias of Spatial Relations Using Neural Language Models

Simon Dobnik, Mehdi Ghanimifard, John KelleherNAACL 2018

TL;DR

This paper investigates whether neural language models can distinguish between functionally and geometrically biased spatial prepositions by analyzing their perplexity on image descriptions. The findings suggest that while language models can capture some of this bias, the interplay between object affordances and geometric configurations is complex and not perfectly mirrored by current models.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For robots and AI systems to effectively interact with humans in the real world, they need to understand and generate spatial descriptions. This is particularly challenging because spatial language isn't solely based on geometry; it also involves functional semantics – how objects are used and interact. For example, "the umbrella is over the man" isn't just about spatial positioning but also about the umbrella's function of providing shelter. This paper tackles the problem of computationally modeling this functional and geometric bias in spatial relations, specifically prepositions, and explores whether modern neural language models can capture these distinctions.

Methods

The core of this research involves training neural language models (specifically, recurrent neural networks with LSTM units) on large datasets of image descriptions. The models are trained to predict the next word in a sequence, and their performance is evaluated using perplexity, a measure of how well the model predicts the text.

Two main experimental setups are used:

  1. LM1 (Unrestricted Frequencies): A language model trained on the raw frequencies of spatial relations in the dataset. This model's perplexity is analyzed to see if functionally biased relations (which are often more specific) lead to higher perplexity due to their less frequent but more informative nature.
  2. LM2 (Balanced Frequencies): A language model trained with an equal number of instances for each spatial relation. This is done to remove the bias introduced by the frequency of relations themselves, allowing for a clearer examination of the inherent bias of the spatial relations.

Additionally, the researchers explore the impact of swapping spatial relations within a context to test how easily a language model can adapt to different spatial descriptions.

Datasets

The primary dataset used is Visual Genome, a large, crowd-sourced corpus of 108K images with annotations of relationships between objects, including spatial relations. This dataset is noted for its size but also for potential noise due to its crowd-sourced nature.

The paper also references previous work using:

  • IAPR TC-12 and Flickr8k for extracting spatial relation triplets.
  • Amsterdam Metaphor Corpus for understanding the frequency of spatial prepositions in different text genres.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Functional bias leads to higher perplexity (initially): Functionally biased spatial relations, which are more selective about the objects they describe, tend to result in higher perplexity for language models trained on unrestricted frequencies. This suggests that their specificity makes them less predictable in a general corpus.
  • Balancing frequencies reveals deeper patterns: When spatial relations are balanced in the training data (LM2), the distinction between functional and geometric bias becomes less clear in terms of perplexity. This indicates that the frequency of relations in natural language plays a significant role in how language models learn them.
  • Targets and landmarks matter: The "uniqueness" of targets and landmarks associated with a spatial relation is a key factor. Functionally biased relations often involve more unique targets, contributing to higher perplexity.
  • Sequential processing is a limitation: Language models process text sequentially (left-to-right). This can be a mismatch for spatial relations, where the target, relation, and landmark might be interpreted in a different order semantically than they appear syntactically. Swapping the order of these elements can significantly alter perplexity.
  • Language models encode world knowledge: The research suggests that language models, beyond just predicting words, can capture a surprising amount of information about world knowledge and semantic distinctions, including the functional and geometric aspects of spatial relations.

Key Results

  • LM1 (Unrestricted): Functionally biased relations (e.g., "on") generally showed higher perplexity than geometrically biased relations (e.g., "left," "right") on the test set, supporting Hypothesis 2.
  • LM2 (Balanced): When spatial relations were balanced, the distinction between functional and geometric bias became less pronounced in terms of perplexity. However, the analysis of unique targets and landmarks revealed that functionally biased relations are more selective.
  • Swapped Relations: When spatial relations were swapped within a context, perplexity generally increased, but the distinction between functionally and geometrically biased relations was not clearly cut, suggesting that language models learn specific contexts for these relations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dataset Bias: The results are dependent on the quality and size of the dataset. The Visual Genome dataset, while large, is crowd-sourced and may contain noise.
  • Graded Bias: The functional-geometric bias is not a strict dichotomy but a spectrum, making clear-cut distinctions challenging.
  • Other Semantic Relations: The measure of perplexity might also be influenced by other semantic distinctions beyond functional-geometric bias.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring dataset effects (e.g., using robotic action descriptions), normalizing composite spatial relations differently, and systematically investigating other spatial relations to identify their functional or geometric bias. They also highlight the potential for language models to capture a rich amount of world knowledge, though disentangling this knowledge remains a challenge.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{dobnik2018exploring,
  author = {Simon Dobnik and Mehdi Ghanimifard and John Kelleher},
  title = {{Exploring the Functional and Geometric Bias of Spatial Relations Using Neural Language Models}},
  booktitle = {Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2018},
}

Loading related content...

Figure