TL;DR
This paper investigates how subtle flavor-changing interactions in the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM), even with very heavy superpartners, can be probed by precise measurements of rare particle decays. By analyzing four distinct theoretical frameworks for how these interactions arise, the authors identify a set of six key observables that could reveal deviations from the Standard Model and help pinpoint the underlying physics.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM) offers elegant solutions to several fundamental problems in particle physics, such as the hierarchy problem and dark matter. However, direct searches for supersymmetric particles at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) have so far yielded null results, pushing the expected masses of these "superpartners" to very high scales (TeV or above). This raises a crucial question: if these particles are so heavy, how can we possibly test the MSSM?
One avenue is through "flavor physics" – the study of how fundamental particles transform into one another. While the Standard Model (SM) has a well-defined way of handling these transformations, the MSSM, with its additional particles and parameters, could introduce new, subtle ways for these transformations to occur. These new effects are often suppressed by the masses of the superpartners, meaning they are only observable if the superpartners are very heavy. However, even with heavy superpartners, these "flavor-changing" interactions can leave imprints on rare particle decays. The challenge is to identify which rare decays are most sensitive to these effects and to understand how different theoretical assumptions about the MSSM's flavor structure affect these predictions. This paper aims to address this by exploring the sensitivity of specific flavor-changing observables to the MSSM in the high-scale regime.
Methods
The authors employ a theoretical approach, analyzing the MSSM within four distinct frameworks that model the "flavor structure" of its soft-breaking terms. These frameworks are:
- Minimal Flavour Violation (MFV): This is the most conservative approach, assuming that any flavor-breaking in the MSSM is directly proportional to the SM's own flavor-breaking (encoded in the Yukawa couplings).
- U(2) chiral flavour symmetry: This framework assumes a flavor symmetry that primarily acts on the first two generations of quarks, with the third generation being treated differently.
- U(1) Froggatt-Nielsen: This model uses a U(1) symmetry to explain the observed mass hierarchies of quarks and introduces specific assignments for these charges.
- Disoriented A terms: This scenario focuses on flavor violation arising specifically from the "A terms" (trilinear couplings) in the MSSM, while assuming the mass terms are flavor-diagonal.
For each framework, they calculate the expected deviations from the SM for a set of six key flavor-changing observables. These calculations involve one-loop corrections from supersymmetric particles. The authors then compare these predictions to current experimental data and projected future improvements, using a statistical approach (chi-squared minimization) to determine how well each flavor model can explain potential deviations.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical calculations and comparisons with existing experimental data and future projections.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Flavor physics as a high-scale probe: Even with superpartners at the 10-100 TeV scale, flavor-changing observables can still provide sensitive probes of the MSSM, escaping direct detection at colliders.
- Complementarity of observables: No single observable is sufficient to distinguish between all flavor models. A combination of observables is needed to uniquely characterize the underlying flavor structure.
- Distinct signatures for different models: Each of the four flavor frameworks investigated leads to a characteristic pattern of deviations in the chosen observables, offering a "fingerprint" for each model.
- U(2) and Disoriented A-terms show promise: The U(2) chiral flavor symmetry and the Disoriented A-terms frameworks are found to be capable of accommodating larger deviations from the SM in certain observables compared to MFV, especially for the ∆F = 1 transitions.
- A-terms are key for ∆F = 1: The Disoriented A-terms model, in particular, can generate significant effects in ∆F = 1 observables due to potentially large chargino-mediated Z-penguin diagrams.
Key Results
The paper identifies six observables that are particularly sensitive to the flavor structure of the high-scale MSSM:
- ∆M<sub>d</sub> and ∆M<sub>s</sub>: Meson-antimeson mixing in the Bd and Bs systems.
- |ε<sub>K</sub>|: CP violation in kaon decays.
- B(K → πνν¯): Rare kaon decay into a pion and neutrinos.
- B(B → Xsγ): Rare B meson decay into an s quark and a photon.
- Phase of D-D mixing: CP violation in D meson mixing.
The analysis shows that for superpartner masses up to O(100) TeV, these observables can potentially reveal deviations from the SM. Specifically, the U(2) and Disoriented A-terms models can accommodate significant deviations in certain observables even at scales of 10 TeV. The paper also highlights that these observables remain relevant even in a long-term perspective, potentially being probed at future colliders like the FCC-hh.
Limitations and Future Work
- Tuning in U(1)FN: The U(1) Froggatt-Nielsen model requires some "tuning" of parameters at low energies to match experimental constraints, especially at lower scales (M < 10 TeV).
- Focus on quark sector: The analysis is limited to quark flavor-violating observables. The authors suggest that lepton-flavor violating observables and electric dipole moments could provide further constraints.
- Future improvements: The study relies on projected future improvements in experimental precision and theoretical calculations. The actual impact of these improvements will be crucial for testing these models.
- Specific implementation of U(1)FN: The authors note that their specific implementation of the U(1)FN model (neglecting non-universal A terms) limits its ability to explain deviations in B(K → πνν¯). A more general implementation could yield different results.
Future work could involve extending the analysis to include lepton flavor violation and electric dipole moments, as well as performing more detailed phenomenological studies for each flavor model.
Summary updated