Abstract
A group of graduate students was assigned to design and conduct training as their group project. Nevertheless, the whole world, including Malaysia was hit by the Covid-19 pandemic. Everyone in the country was under the first phase of the Movement Control Order (MCO). Hence, face-to-face training was not a viable option. Alternatively, the students had to conduct online training. The assignment was the first-time experience for them to design and provide training. A question arose on how well the graduate students' experience was in designing, implementing, and evaluating online training. This article presents a qualitative study on implementing an online training program titled "Learning How to Make Halal Chinese Dumplings Online!" by graduate students in the Training Design and Management course at Universiti Putra Malaysia. This study aimed to explore the design and implementation of the online training program. Data collection was through an online focus group discussion (FGD) involving 11 respondents and a document analysis of a written report by the training implementers. The central theme that emerged from the data analysis is training design for online training. Meanwhile, the sub-themes are as follows: (a) training needs analysis and rationale for online training in making halal Chinese dumplings, (b) training design, (c) training evaluation, and (d) challenges in conducting online training. Methodologically, this study implies the feasibility of successful data collection via online platforms. The findings on the well-designed and implemented online training based on training needs analysis and continuous evaluation suggested that we could still gain access to the ocean of knowledge via formal or informal online learning and education programs at a challenging time of Pandemic Covid-19.
Introduction
The COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent Movement Control Orders (MCO) in Malaysia created an immediate crisis for educators and trainers: how do you teach hands-on, tactile skills—like cooking—when you cannot meet in person? This paper examines how graduate students at Universiti Putra Malaysia successfully pivoted a traditional face-to-face vocational training project into a digital format during the lockdowns. The study explores the logistical, pedagogical, and technical hurdles of this transition, specifically focusing on whether first-time trainers could effectively design, implement, and evaluate a digital program that traditionally requires sensory feedback and physical supervision.
Methodology
The researchers employed a qualitative case study approach consisting of two primary data collection methods:
- Online Focus Group Discussion (FGD): Conducted via Zoom with 11 graduate students who designed and implemented the training. The discussion followed a semi-structured protocol based on the ADDIE model.
- Document Analysis: A systematic review of the students' final project report, which included data from their own Training Needs Analysis (TNA) and participant evaluations.
The instructional design was grounded in the ADDIE Model (Analysis, Design, Development, Implementation, and Evaluation) integrated with Action Change Theory (ACT), which focuses on how rewards and goal-directed systems drive behavior change.
Data and Participants
The study draws on three distinct groups of human data:
- The Designers: 11 graduate students (Masters in Human Resource Development) participated in the FGD.
- The TNA Sample: 39 potential participants were surveyed via Google Forms to shape the training content.
- The Training Participants: 124 individuals joined the online training and provided evaluation data. This group was predominantly female (75.8%) and of Malay ethnicity (83.1%).
Key Insights and Implementation
TNA as a Strategic Compass
The success of the training wasn't just about the recipe; it was about the context. The Training Needs Analysis revealed that during the MCO, people weren't just looking for food—they were looking for "bonding activities" with family. This led the designers to frame dumpling making as a family-centric activity rather than just a culinary skill.
The Micro-Learning Mandate
The TNA data showed a clear preference for brevity. Potential participants requested videos under 10 minutes. This aligns with the "science of attention," suggesting that for vocational online training, "less is more" to ensure completion.
Social Media and Niche Targeting
The study highlighted the "powerful effect" of social media. WhatsApp (39.2%) and Instagram (11.9%) were the primary discovery channels, proving that even with zero budget, targeted social sharing can reach a significant audience quickly. Furthermore, by specifically targeting "Halal Chinese Dumplings," the trainers addressed a specific cultural gap in the Malaysian market, which likely contributed to the high engagement among the Malay demographic.
Results and Evaluation
- High Satisfaction: Over 96% of participants agreed that the video demonstrated the process clearly and step-by-step.
- Behavioral Intent: 27.4% of participants intended to make the dumplings "straight away," and 50% planned to do so within a week, indicating successful learning transfer.
- The Engagement Gap: Despite high satisfaction scores, the average watch time was only 1:44 minutes (approximately 25% of the video duration). This reveals a significant disparity between "perceived value" and "actual engagement," a common challenge in asynchronous online learning.
Discussion and Limitations
The authors noted that inconsistent internet connections were a major barrier, both for the trainers' internal discussions and for the participants' ability to view high-quality video content. Additionally, because the study took place during a strict lockdown, the trainers themselves lacked access to professional recording tools and a full range of ingredients (e.g., they could only demonstrate boiled dumplings, not fried or steamed versions).
Conclusion
The study demonstrates that rigorous training needs analysis and social media integration can overcome the physical barriers of a pandemic to deliver effective skill-based education. Future research should explore more interactive, real-time online communication to increase engagement and "immersion," potentially moving beyond passive YouTube videos to more synchronous or VR-based training environments.
Summary updated