TL;DR
This pilot study investigates how repetitive head impacts (RHI) affect the stability of digital cognitive tests in older adults. The findings suggest that while digital measures are generally stable, individuals with a history of RHI show more variability and less improvement with practice, highlighting the importance of considering RHI when interpreting cognitive assessments.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Repetitive head impacts (RHI), common in contact sports and military service, are linked to cognitive decline and neurodegenerative diseases. Traditional neuropsychological tests might not capture the subtle cognitive changes that can occur in individuals with RHI. Digital cognitive measures, like those from the Defense Automated Neurobehavioral Assessment (DANA), are proposed as more sensitive alternatives. However, there's a lack of understanding regarding how RHI influences the stability of these digital measures over time in cognitively intact older adults. This study aims to fill that gap by examining the intraindividual variability of DANA performance in older adults with and without a history of RHI.
Methods
This pilot study analyzed data from participants in the Boston University Alzheimer's Disease Research Center. RHI status was determined using the 2021 NINDS TES Research Diagnostic Criteria. Participants had at least three days of engagement with the DANA system. The core of the analysis involved quantifying intraindividual variability using the coefficient of variation (CV) for various DANA tasks. Mann-Whitney U tests were used to compare CVs between the RHI and non-RHI groups. Additionally, a linear mixed-effects model was employed to examine day-to-day variations and group differences, controlling for age, sex, and the number of usage days.
Datasets
The study utilized data from participants enrolled in the Boston University Alzheimer's Disease Research Center. These participants completed annual study visits that included the Uniform Data Set. The Defense Automated Neurobehavioral Assessment (DANA) was introduced in 2021 and used for this study. No new benchmarks were introduced; the study evaluated existing digital cognitive measures.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Digital Measures Show Promise for Sensitivity: The study suggests that digital cognitive measures might be more sensitive to subtle differences in cognitive performance, particularly in populations with a history of RHI.
- RHI Impacts Cognitive Stability: A history of RHI appears to be associated with greater day-to-day variability in cognitive performance, even in individuals who are currently cognitively intact. This implies that RHI might subtly affect the consistency of cognitive function.
- Practice Effects Differ: Individuals with RHI showed less benefit from repeated practice on the DANA tasks compared to those without RHI. This suggests that the learning or consolidation mechanisms might be altered by RHI exposure.
- Context is Crucial for Interpretation: The findings strongly emphasize that RHI history is a critical factor to consider when interpreting longitudinal cognitive assessments in aging populations. Ignoring this history could lead to misinterpretations of cognitive changes.
Key Results
The study included 58 cognitively intact older adults (mean age 75.4 years, 67.2% women). Ten participants had a history of RHI, primarily from soccer, football, and rugby.
- Variability Differences: Older adults with RHI exhibited significantly greater variability across several DANA tasks, including Go/No-Go, Code Substitution, and Simple Response Time, compared to the non-RHI group.
- Practice Effect Interaction: While overall day-to-day fluctuations in DANA performance were small, a significant interaction effect was observed for the RHI group in the Procedural Response Time task. Specifically, each additional day of DANA usage was associated with faster response times, but this benefit was less pronounced or different in the RHI group.
- Specific Task Variability: Table 2 shows that for some measures, like SDRT (Standard Deviation of Response Time) in Go/No-Go and ART correct (Average Response Time for correct test trials) in Code Substitution, the RHI group had higher CV values, indicating greater variability.
Limitations and Future Work
Limitations: * Pilot Study: This is a pilot study with a small sample size, particularly for the RHI group (n=10). This limits the generalizability of the findings. * Retrospective RHI Assessment: RHI history was assessed retrospectively, which can be subject to recall bias. * Definition of RHI: The study relies on the 2021 NINDS TES Research Diagnostic Criteria, which may not capture all forms or severities of RHI.
Future Work: * Larger Cohorts: Future research should involve larger cohorts to confirm these findings and explore RHI's impact more robustly. * Prospective RHI Data: Collecting prospective data on RHI exposure would provide more accurate and detailed information. * Mechanistic Understanding: Further investigation is needed to understand the underlying biological mechanisms by which RHI affects cognitive stability and practice effects. * Clinical Implications: Exploring how these findings can be integrated into clinical practice for better assessment and management of cognitive health in individuals with RHI history is crucial.
Summary updated