Exploring the disparity of influence between users in the discussion of Brexit on Twitter: Twitter influence disparity in Brexit If so, write it here

Amirarsalan Rajabi, Alexander V. Mantzaris, Kuldip Singh Atwal, Ivan GaribayJ. Comput. Soc. Sci 2021 · DOI · OpenReview

Abstract

This study investigates the impact of political polarization on the distribution of influence within Twitter networks during the Brexit referendum and the 2017 UK snap election. By analyzing a dataset of 50 million tweets, researchers found that while participation from general users spiked during these political crises, social capital—measured by retweets and likes—became significantly more concentrated among a small elite of influencers. This suggests that polarization provides a structural incentive for digital "aristocrats" to dominate public discourse.

Introduction

Political polarization is often viewed as a social ill that jeopardizes democratic stability. However, from a network science perspective, the question remains: Why does it persist? This research addresses the "disparity of influence"—the gap between high-influence users (influencers) and the rest of the population. Specifically, the study explores whether hyper-polarized events like the Brexit referendum act as a "leveler" for discourse or if they exacerbate existing inequalities in social capital.

Methodology

The researchers employed a data-driven approach to validate theoretical stochastic models of message exchange. Their methodology involved:

  1. User Stratification: Dividing users into two tiers: $T_{top}$ (the top 50% by follower count) and $T_{bottom}$ (the bottom 50%).
  2. Economic Metrics: Adapting the Gini coefficient to measure "retweet inequality," treating retweets as units of social capital.
  3. Disparity Ratios: Calculating the Retweet Ratio and Favorite Ratio (engagement of $T_{top}$ divided by $T_{bottom}$) to track the widening gap between elite and regular users.
  4. Interaction Analysis: Tracking cross-group interactions between "Leave" and "Remain" supporters to quantify polarization levels.

The study utilized a massive dataset of over 50 million tweet IDs related to Brexit collected between 2016 and 2019, including a manually curated subset of 802 users to ensure high data quality and human-centric behavior.

The Activity vs. Impact Paradox

A primary finding of the study is the "Activity vs. Impact Paradox." During the peaks of the Brexit referendum and the 2017 snap election, there was a massive surge in the number of unique users participating in the discussion.

Figure 1: Number of unique users participating in Twitter discussions around the 2016 Brexit Referendum.
Figure 2: Number of unique users participating in Twitter discussions around the 2017 UK Snap Election.

While the relative activity of regular users ($T_{bottom}$) increased during these crises, the influencers ($T_{top}$) received a disproportionately higher share of the total engagement. The data suggests that polarization creates a "market condition" where influencers can accumulate social capital more efficiently. Because the environment is so divided, users are more likely to signal-boost "anchor" accounts that represent their side, further entrenching the influencer's dominance without requiring them to produce more content.

Key Results

  • Gini Coefficient Spikes: The concentration of retweets increased significantly during the 2016 referendum and the 2017 snap election, indicating that social capital became more elite-focused during these periods.
  • Retweet Ratio Explosion: Around the date of the Brexit referendum, the ratio of retweets received by influencers versus regular users surged. While stable during "quiet" periods, it spiked as the vote approached.
  • Favorite Ratio Stability: Interestingly, the "Favorite Ratio" (likes) remained more stable than the retweet ratio. This suggests that while "liking" is a personal endorsement, "retweeting" is the primary engine of influence disparity during periods of high polarization.

Conclusion

The study provides empirical evidence for the "stochastic message exchange model," proving that influencers do not necessarily need to increase their output during a crisis to gain influence; the polarized network structure does the work for them. Future research should investigate "depolarizing incentives" that could make the democratic process more uniform and less dominated by a few vocal anchors.

Summary updated

Abstract

The topic of political polarization has received increased attention for valid reasons. Given that an increased amount of the social exchange for opinions happens online, social media platforms provide a good source of information to investigate various aspects of the phenomena. In this work, data collected from Twitter are used to examine polarization surrounding the topic of the Brexit referendum on the membership of the European Union. The analysis specifically focuses on the question of how different tiers of users in terms of influence can project their opinions and if the polarized conditions affect the relative balance in the broadcast capabilities of the tiers. The results show that during polarization periods, users of the higher tier have increased capabilities to broadcast their information in relation to the lower tiers thereby further dominating the discussion. This validates previous modeling investigations and the hypothesis that polarization provides an opportunity for influencers to increase their relative social capital.
BibTeX
@article{rajabi2021exploring,
  author = {Amirarsalan Rajabi and Alexander V. Mantzaris and Kuldip Singh Atwal and Ivan Garibay},
  title = {{Exploring the disparity of influence between users in the discussion of Brexit on Twitter: Twitter influence disparity in Brexit If so, write it here}},
  journal = {J. Comput. Soc. Sci.},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1007/s42001-021-00112-0},
}
Figure