Exploring the Contribution of Proprioceptive Reflexes to Balance Control in Perturbed Standing

Anne D. Koelewijn, Auke Jan IjspeertFrontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how proprioception, specifically muscle stretch and force feedback reflexes, contributes to maintaining balance during unexpected disturbances. By simulating a human-like musculoskeletal model on a perturbed platform, the researchers found that proprioceptive reflexes are crucial for balance, with length feedback appearing slightly more effective than force feedback in replicating human responses.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Maintaining an upright stance, especially when faced with unexpected movements like tripping or standing on a shifting surface, is a complex motor control problem. Humans rely on a combination of sensory inputs – vision, vestibular system, and proprioception (the sense of body position and movement) – to stay balanced. While previous research has explored how these systems work together, understanding the specific contribution of proprioception alone, and the relative importance of its different components (like muscle stretch vs. force sensing), remains an open question. This paper aims to disentangle these contributions by focusing solely on proprioceptive reflexes and their role in perturbed standing.

Methods

The researchers developed a detailed, sagittal-plane neuro-musculoskeletal model of the human body, incorporating six degrees of freedom and nine muscles per leg. This model was designed to stand on a platform that could be randomly perturbed, mimicking real-world balance challenges.

The core of their approach was a controller based on proprioceptive reflexes:

  • Feedforward Activation: A baseline muscle activation signal.
  • Reflex Loops:
    • Length Feedback: Mimics signals from muscle spindles, responding to changes in muscle length.
  • Force Feedback: Mimics signals from Golgi tendon organs, responding to muscle force.
  • Dead Zone: A crucial element where feedback control is deactivated when the body's center of mass (CoM) is within a safe zone. This prevents jerky movements and reflects the idea that minor CoM shifts don't always require immediate correction.

They then optimized the controller's parameters (feedforward inputs, dead zone size, and reflex gains) by minimizing muscular effort while ensuring the model remained upright during the simulated perturbations. This optimization was performed for three controller configurations:

  1. Base Model: Using both length and force feedback.
  2. Length Feedback Model: Using only length feedback.
  3. Force Feedback Model: Using only force feedback.

The simulation results were then quantitatively compared to experimental data from human participants who experienced similar perturbations.

Datasets

The study utilized experimental data from a previous study by Wang and van den Bogert (2020b) which involved human participants standing on a platform subjected to random square-pulse perturbations. This dataset provided ground reaction forces and marker data, from which joint angles and moments were derived. The researchers used this data for both optimizing their controller and for evaluating its performance.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Proprioception is Key: The study strongly suggests that proprioceptive reflexes alone can explain a significant portion of balance control during perturbed standing.
  • Length vs. Force Feedback: While both feedback types contribute, muscle length feedback (from muscle spindles) appears to be slightly more effective than force feedback (from Golgi tendon organs) in replicating the observed human joint angle dynamics.
  • Intermittent Control is Crucial: The "dead zone" concept, where reflexes are only active when the CoM is near the edge of the base of support, is vital for achieving smooth, human-like control. This highlights the importance of intermittent control strategies in balance.
  • Effort Minimization is a Driving Factor: Optimizing for minimal muscular effort produced results that were qualitatively similar to human behavior, suggesting this is a fundamental objective in balance control. However, the simulated effort was lower than observed in humans, hinting at other contributing objectives.
  • Time Delays Matter: The timing of reflex responses (time delays) significantly impacts the correlation between simulated and experimental data, underscoring the need for accurate physiological time delays in neural control models.

Key Results

  • The optimized controllers produced simulated postures that were, on average, within 5 degrees of the experimental average joint angles.
  • The base model (force + length feedback) showed moderate correlations for hip and knee joint angles and weak correlations for ankle angles and moments with experimental data.
  • The length feedback model demonstrated slightly better replication of experimental joint angle time series compared to the force feedback model.
  • The force feedback model showed longer periods of inactivity in its responses, unlike the experiment and the length feedback model.
  • Simulated joint moments were generally lower than those observed in human experiments, suggesting that humans might employ strategies that increase effort for other reasons (e.g., robustness, faster responses).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified Muscle Spindle Model: The study used a simplified model of muscle spindles, which primarily respond to length. Future work could incorporate velocity-dependent responses and short-range stiffness, which are known to influence muscle behavior and could improve simulation accuracy.
  • Intermittent Control Threshold: The exact trigger for the intermittent control (dead zone) was based on the CoM position. However, the authors suggest that foot pressure distribution might be a more accurate trigger, as CoM estimation has a significant time delay in humans.
  • Limited Perturbation Range: The controller was optimized for a specific magnitude of perturbation. Its performance in different environments or with varying perturbation types was not tested.
  • Other Sensory Modalities: The study focused solely on proprioception. Future research could integrate vestibular and visual feedback to create a more comprehensive model of human balance control.
  • Other Optimization Objectives: The discrepancy between simulated and experimental joint moments suggests that humans might optimize for more than just effort. Identifying these additional objectives (e.g., stability margins, energy efficiency) is a promising avenue for future work.

Summary updated

Abstract

Humans control balance using different feedback loops involving the vestibular system, the visual system, and proprioception. In this article, we focus on proprioception and explore the contribution of reflexes based on force and length feedback to standing balance. In particular, we address the questions of how much proprioception alone could explain balance control, and whether one modality, force or length feedback, is more important than the other. A sagittal plane neuro-musculoskeletal model was developed with six degrees of freedom and nine muscles in each leg. A controller was designed using proprioceptive reflexes and a dead zone. No feedback control was applied inside the dead zone. Reflexes were active once the center of mass moved outside the dead zone. Controller parameters were found by solving an optimization problem, where effort was minimized while the neuro-musculoskeletal model should remain standing upright on a perturbed platform. The ground was perturbed with random square pulses in the sagittal plane with different amplitudes and durations. The optimization was solved for three controllers: using force and length feedback (base model), using only force feedback, and using only length feedback. Simulations were compared to human data from previous work, where an experiment with the same perturbation signal was performed. The optimized controller yielded a similar posture, since average joint angles were within 5 degrees of the experimental average joint angles. The joint angles of the base model, the length only model, and the force only model correlated weakly (ankle) to moderately with the experimental joint angles. The ankle moment correlated weakly to moderately with the experimental ankle moment, while the hip and knee moment were only weakly correlated, or not at all. The time series of the joint angles showed that the length feedback model was better able to explain the experimental joint angles than the force feedback model. Changes in time delay affected the correlation of the joint angles and joint moments. The objective of effort minimization yielded lower joint moments than in the experiment, suggesting that other objectives are also important in balance control, which cause an increase in effort and thus larger joint moments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{koelewijn2020exploring,
  author = {Anne D. Koelewijn and Auke Jan Ijspeert},
  title = {{Exploring the Contribution of Proprioceptive Reflexes to Balance Control in Perturbed Standing}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fbioe.2020.00866},
}

Loading related content...

Figure