Abstract
Ambient awareness refers to the ability of social media users to obtain knowledge about who knows what (i.e., users' expertise) in their network, by simply being exposed to other users' content (e.g, tweets on Twitter). Previous work, based on user surveys, reveals that individuals self-report ambient awareness only for parts of their networks. However, it is unclear whether it is their limited cognitive capacity or the limited exposure to diagnostic tweets (i.e., online content) that prevents people from developing ambient awareness for their complete network. In this work, we focus on in-wall ambient awareness (IWAA) in Twitter and conduct a two-step data-driven analysis, that allows us to explore to which extent IWAA is likely, or even possible. First, we rely on reactions (e.g., likes), as strong evidence of users being aware of experts in Twitter. Unfortunately, such strong evidence can be only measured for active users, which represent the minority in the network. Thus to study the boundaries of IWAA to a larger extent, in the second part of our analysis, we instead focus on the passive exposure to content generated by other users -- which we refer to as in-wall visibility. This analysis shows that only for a subset of users IWAA is plausible, while for the majority it is unlikely, if even possible, to develop IWAA. We hope that our methodology paves the way for the emergence of data-driven approaches for the study of ambient awareness.
Introduction
Social scientists have long theorized about ambient awareness: the subconscious mapping of network expertise through peripheral skimming of "mundane" social media updates. While previous studies relied on subjective self-reports, it remained unclear whether limited awareness stems from human cognitive constraints or a lack of diagnostic information in the feed. This study introduces In-Wall Ambient Awareness (IWAA)—awareness derived specifically from a user’s home timeline—and employs a data-driven framework to quantify its boundaries on Twitter.
Dataset and Topical Diversity
The researchers collected data via the Twitter API between July and November 2020, focusing on 2,002 Twitter Lists across over 20 diverse topics ranging from technical fields like Artificial Intelligence and Data Science to entertainment categories like Music and Marvel.
The dataset included 1,836 "seekers" (users interested in a topic) and 12,033 "experts" (users recognized by others as knowledgeable), forming nearly 37,000 seeker-expert pairs.
Methodology: From Reactions to Visibility
The study utilizes a two-step approach to measure awareness signals:
- Reaction Analysis: Active interactions (likes, retweets, replies) serve as strong evidence of awareness. However, since 90% of users are "lurkers," this metric only captures a small fraction of the population.
- Visibility Modeling: To account for passive exposure, the authors reconstructed the "wall" (home timeline) for a subset of users. They estimated in-wall visibility using a decay function for tweet visibility ($f_{es}$) and an asymmetric Laplace kernel to model user online presence ($o_s$). This allowed for the calculation of Lower and Upper Bounds of exposure.
Characterizing Seekers and Experts
A fundamental prerequisite for IWAA is the presence of diagnostic content. Analysis of user profiles reveals significant differences between seekers and experts. Experts are notably more active, particularly in producing original tweets rather than just replies or retweets. They also possess larger follower counts and are included in significantly more Twitter Lists, confirming their status as information hubs.
Key Findings
- The Visibility Bottleneck: The primary barrier to ambient awareness is not "information overload" but a lack of exposure. For over 60% of the "lurker" population, the upper bound of exposure to an expert's content was less than 36 seconds total over a 30-day period.
- Plausibility of Awareness: IWAA is only plausible for approximately 10% of seekers. Even in a "best-case" scenario where users see everything, the high volume of competing content often buries expert signals.
- The Role of Direct Following: Users are significantly more likely to develop awareness for experts they follow directly. Discovery via retweets from friends is rare, occurring less than 4% of the time.
Conclusion
This work moves the study of ambient awareness from subjective surveys to a rigorous, data-driven analysis. The findings suggest that for the majority of Twitter users, developing a comprehensive map of network expertise is likely impossible due to the structural limitations of the home timeline. Future research should explore awareness developed through other platform features like the "Explore" tab or algorithmic recommendation engines.
Summary updated