Exploring the Association between Neighborhood Blue Space and Self-Rated Health among Elderly Adults: Evidence from Guangzhou, China

Yujie Chen, Yuan Yuan, Yuquan ZhouInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how neighborhood blue spaces (like rivers and lakes) impact the self-rated health (SRH) of elderly adults in Guangzhou, China. It reveals that stress acts as a key mediator, and that older and lower-income individuals benefit most from these blue spaces, suggesting targeted urban planning for healthy aging.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As global populations age and urbanize, understanding how the built environment influences the health of older adults is crucial. While the positive effects of "blue spaces" (natural or constructed water bodies) on health are increasingly recognized, much of this research has focused on Western countries. There's a significant knowledge gap regarding these associations in rapidly urbanizing, high-density Asian megacities, particularly concerning the underlying mechanisms and how these effects might differ across demographic and socioeconomic groups within these contexts. This paper aims to bridge this gap by exploring the complex pathways linking neighborhood blue space to the self-rated health of elderly individuals in Guangzhou, China, considering both individual and neighborhood-level factors.

Methods

The study employed a multidisciplinary approach, combining survey data with geospatial and environmental information.

  • Multilevel Linear Modeling: This statistical technique was used to analyze data with a hierarchical structure (individuals nested within neighborhoods). It allowed the researchers to disentangle the influence of neighborhood-level factors (like blue space availability) from individual-level factors on elderly adults' SRH.
  • Multistep Mediation Analysis: This method was used to explore the "how" and "why" behind the observed associations. It helps to decompose the total effect of blue space on SRH into direct effects and indirect effects mediated by other factors (e.g., stress, physical activity). Bootstrap tests were used to statistically confirm the significance of these mediating pathways.
  • Stratified Analysis: To understand group differences, the analysis was stratified by age, gender, and income. This allowed the researchers to identify specific subgroups that might be more or less affected by neighborhood blue spaces.
  • Sensitivity Analysis: Propensity Score Matching (PSM) was used to control for potential selection bias, ensuring that the observed relationships were robust and not simply due to pre-existing differences between individuals living in areas with varying levels of blue space.

Datasets

  • Questionnaire Survey Data: Collected from 966 elderly individuals (aged 60-90) residing in 20 selected neighborhoods in Guangzhou, China. This data included self-rated health (SRH) and information on potential mediators and covariates.
  • Remote Sensing Images: Used to derive neighborhood blue space indicators (e.g., Normalized Difference Water Index - NDWI, proportion of water area). Landsat 8 satellite images with a 30m spatial resolution were utilized.
  • Street Views and Environmental Data: While mentioned as used, specific details on their direct contribution to the quantitative analysis are less explicit in the provided text.
  • Air Quality Data: Obtained from national monitoring points in Guangzhou and spatially interpolated.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Stress as a Key Mediator: The most significant finding is that stress reduction is a crucial pathway through which neighborhood blue spaces influence elderly adults' health. This suggests that the restorative qualities of blue spaces help alleviate stress, which in turn improves SRH.
  • Vulnerable Groups Benefit Most: The study highlights that older individuals (over 75) and those in lower-income brackets experience a stronger positive association between neighborhood blue spaces and their SRH. This points to the importance of equitable access to these resources for health promotion.
  • Water Quality Matters: The NDWI, an indicator of water coverage and potentially water quality, was negatively associated with SRH. This suggests that polluted blue spaces might have detrimental effects, underscoring the need for not just presence but also quality of blue spaces.
  • Multidisciplinary Approach is Essential: The study effectively integrates geographical, environmental, and public health perspectives to provide a nuanced understanding of the blue space-health nexus.

Key Results

  • Overall Association: Neighborhood blue space characteristics were significantly associated with elderly adults' SRH.
  • Mediating Effect of Stress: Stress was identified as a significant partial mediator in the relationship between neighborhood blue space (specifically NDWI) and SRH. The bootstrap tests confirmed this, with a 95% CI for the mediating effect of stress not including zero.
  • Stratified Findings:
    • Age: Participants over 75 years old showed a significant association between distance to water bodies and SRH, and hydrophilicity index and SRH. Stress fully mediated the association for this age group.
  • Gender: No significant mediating effects were found for gender groups.
  • Income: Both low-income and middle-high-income groups showed associations, with stress fully mediating the relationship for both. Specifically, per capita water area had a negative association with SRH in the low-income group.
  • Other Mediators: Pollution, physical activity duration, and social contact did not show significant mediating roles in the overall analysis.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cross-Sectional Design: The study's cross-sectional nature limits its ability to establish definitive causal inferences.
  • Self-Reported Data: Reliance on self-reported SRH and mediator data introduces potential biases.
  • Lack of Usage Data: The study could not account for the frequency or duration of blue space use, which could influence the observed associations.

Future research should focus on longitudinal studies to establish causality, incorporate objective health and environmental data (e.g., water quality testing), and explore the impact of water pollution more deeply. Further investigation into the specific mechanisms of stress reduction and the role of different types of blue spaces is also recommended. The authors also suggest exploring other potential mediators and objective measures of health outcomes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Blue spaces is associated with self-rated health (SRH), but little is known about the pathways underlying this association among Chinese urban elderly individuals. Based on neighborhood effect theory, this study examined the relationship between neighborhood blue spaces and SRH among elderly individuals using data from a questionnaire survey conducted in Guangzhou, remote sensing images, street views, and environmental information in the context of a Chinese megacity. In addition, multilevel linear model and mediating effect model empirical analyses were performed. Results showed that first, the SRH of the elderly was associated with individual- and neighborhood-level factors. Second, the multilevel mediation model revealed that multiple biopsychosocial pathways existed between neighborhood blue spaces and the SRH of the elderly, specifically, the blue space characteristics related to the SRH of the elderly via the mediating effect of stress. Third, owing to demographic characteristics and socioeconomic status, the stratified analyses also indicated a strong association between neighborhood blue spaces and SRH outcomes in the older and low-income groups. The mediating effect of stress in the age and income groups was also observed, and the mediation pathways and group differences were confirmed in the context of Chinese cities. This research enriches the empirical literature on blue spaces and elderly health from a multidisciplinary perspective and suggests the need for "healthy neighborhood" and "health-aging" planning in Chinese settings.
BibTeX
@article{chen2022exploring,
  author = {Yujie Chen and Yuan Yuan and Yuquan Zhou},
  title = {{Exploring the Association between Neighborhood Blue Space and Self-Rated Health among Elderly Adults: Evidence from Guangzhou, China}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph192316342},
}
Figure