Exploring Precursors of Construction Accidents in China: A Grounded Theory Approach

Zhen Li, Rui Mao, Qing Feng Meng, Xin Hu, Hong LiInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses a grounded theory approach to analyze 135 construction accident reports from China, identifying key precursor factors and developing a framework for their management. The research highlights the importance of understanding the interplay between behavioral and physical precursors to improve construction safety.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The construction industry is inherently dangerous, with a high rate of accidents and fatalities. While precursor management is recognized as a crucial strategy for predicting and preventing accidents, there's a lack of comprehensive understanding regarding what constitutes "precursors" within the specific context of construction safety. This gap hinders the effective implementation of safety management strategies. This paper aims to fill this void by identifying and categorizing accident precursors in the Chinese construction sector and proposing a structured approach to their management.

Methods

The study employs a grounded theory approach, a qualitative research methodology that builds theory from data. The process involved:

  1. Data Collection: Gathering 135 construction accident reports from the Ministry of Housing and Construction of the People's Republic of China.
  2. Open Coding: Decomposing accident reports to identify initial concepts and labels related to precursors.
  3. Axial Coding (Spindle Coding): Grouping and categorizing the initial codes into broader concepts and parent-child node structures.
  4. Selective Coding: Identifying core categories and developing a storyline around them, leading to the development of an indicator system for precursors.
  5. Theoretical Saturation Test: Validating the findings by re-coding a subset of reports and consulting with industry experts to ensure the completeness and logical consistency of the results.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 135 construction accident reports collected from the official website of the Ministry of Housing and Construction of the People's Republic of China, covering incidents that occurred between 2013 and 2020.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Precursors are multifaceted: Accidents aren't caused by a single factor but by a complex interplay of behavioral and physical elements.
  • Behavioral factors dominate: The study found that behavioral precursors (individual and organizational) are more prevalent and influential than physical precursors in construction accidents.
  • Organizational drivers are key: While individual actions are direct causes, organizational factors (like supervision, safety culture, and management systems) often lay the groundwork for these behaviors.
  • Detectability vs. Influence: Organizational precursors are more detectable but have less direct influence, while physical precursors are less detectable but have a more immediate impact.
  • A three-stage management framework: The research proposes a structured approach to precursor management: identification, response, and effectiveness testing.

Key Results

The study developed an indicator system for construction accident precursors, categorized into:

  • Behavioral Factors (65.4%):
    • Individual Behavioral Factors (36.2%): Including personnel safety awareness, safe operation, worker attitude, illegal operations, and subjective attitudes.
  • Organizational Driver Factors (29.2%): Including lack of inspection, inadequate organization/coordination, lack of government supervision, safety atmosphere, and failure to implement organizational systems.
  • Physical Factors (34.4%):
    • Objective Physical Factors (15.6%): Including lack of safety equipment, physical uneven force, lack of security identification, and unreasonable design.
  • Construction Environmental Factors (8%): Including unstable construction conditions and worse weather.
  • Mechanical Equipment Factors (10.8%): Including lack of mechanical safety protection, poor machinery quality, and outdated hoisting machinery.

The study also identified that collapse (44.4%) and falling from a height (37%) are the most frequent accident types, with specific precursors linked to each. For instance, lack of safety supervision and weak safety awareness are key for collapse accidents, while imperfect safety management systems are critical for falls from height.

A precursor management strategy was proposed, comprising three stages:

  1. Identification: Recognizing potential precursors before they escalate.
  2. Response: Taking appropriate actions to mitigate identified precursors.
  3. Effectiveness Testing: Evaluating the success of the implemented responses.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study is based on a qualitative analysis using grounded theory. They suggest that future research could incorporate quantitative analysis methods for a more comprehensive exploration. Additionally, the development of more efficient and real-time identification technologies for precursors is recommended. The paper also points to the need for establishing a complete set of behavioral and physical-based early warning mechanisms and further exploring the characteristics of high-incidence accidents like collapses and falls.

Summary updated

Abstract

The implementation of precursor management can improve safety performance of construction projects through effectively managing the correlations between construction accidents and their precursors. However, a system of comprehensive knowledge about what precursors mean within the context of construction safety is still lacking. This study aims to capture the nature of precursors in the construction industry and explore the process of a precursor event evolving into a construction accident to fill this gap. Based on 135 construction accident reports in China, this study adopts grounded theory to identify different types of accident precursors and explore their interactions with the development of the accident. An indicator system of precursors for construction accidents was developed, which included two major categories of precursors: behavioral factors and physical factors and five minor categories of precursors: individual behavior factors, organizational driving factors, objective physical factors, construction environmental factors, mechanical equipment factors. In addition, a precursor management strategy that includes the three stages of identification, response and effectiveness testing was established. The results of the study reveal the correlations between precursors and construction accidents, which can promote construction professionals' better understanding about precursors and improve their capabilities of managing precursors in practice.
BibTeX
@article{li2021exploring,
  author = {Zhen Li and Rui Mao and Qing Feng Meng and Xin Hu and Hong Li},
  title = {{Exploring Precursors of Construction Accidents in China: A Grounded Theory Approach}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph18020410},
}
Figure