Exploring Powered Wheelchair Users and Their Caregivers’ Perspectives on Potential Intelligent Power Wheelchair Use: A Qualitative Study

Dahlia Kairy, Paula W. Rushton, Philippe S. Archambault, Evelina Pituch, Caryne Torkia, Anas El Fathi, Paula Stone, François Routhier, Robert Forget, Louise Demers, Joëlle Pineau, Richard GourdeauInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This study explores the perspectives of power wheelchair users (PWUs) and their caregivers on the potential benefits and challenges of Intelligent Power Wheelchairs (IPWs). The findings highlight how IPW features like obstacle avoidance and path following could address current mobility difficulties, while also revealing a "cautious optimism" and emphasizing the crucial role of user input in IPW development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Millions of people worldwide rely on wheelchairs for mobility. While standard Power Wheelchairs (PWCs) offer significant benefits like increased independence and social participation, users still face numerous challenges. These include navigating difficult built environments (narrow doorways, crowded spaces), dealing with outdoor hazards (poor visibility, uneven surfaces), and physical limitations that can make controlling a PWC difficult or unsafe. Intelligent Power Wheelchairs (IPWs), equipped with advanced navigation assistance like obstacle avoidance and path following, are being developed to address these limitations. However, there's a need to understand how these new technologies align with the real-world experiences and needs of the people who would use them. This paper aims to bridge that gap by exploring the perspectives of PWU and their caregivers on the potential impact of IPWs on their daily lives and current challenges.

Methods

The researchers employed a qualitative exploratory study design, utilizing semi-structured individual interviews with both Power Wheelchair Users (PWUs) and their caregivers. A convenience sample of 12 PWUs and 4 caregivers participated. To facilitate discussion, participants were shown a four-minute video illustrating the functionalities of a prototype IPW in a realistic setting (a shopping mall). The interviews were guided by a semi-structured guide with open-ended questions, allowing for emergent themes. Data analysis involved thematic analysis, with initial coding done collaboratively by four team members, followed by a more in-depth analysis to identify overarching themes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on qualitative data gathered through interviews.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • IPWs as a Solution to Real-World Hurdles: Participants clearly articulated how IPW features like obstacle avoidance and path following could directly address many of the frustrating and sometimes dangerous situations they encounter daily, from scraping knuckles on doorframes to avoiding collisions in crowded spaces.
  • "Cautious Optimism" is Key: While users expressed excitement and saw the potential of IPWs ("Amazing!", "Genius!"), their optimism was tempered with concerns. They don't want IPWs to replace their own abilities but rather to augment them, and they need to be convinced of the technology's reliability, especially regarding obstacle avoidance.
  • User Input is Non-Negotiable: The study strongly reinforces the idea that user-centered design is paramount. Participants offered specific suggestions and highlighted features they found relevant or irrelevant, underscoring the need for ongoing dialogue between developers and end-users throughout the IPW development process.
  • Defining the "Ideal" IPW User: The study identified characteristics of individuals who would most benefit from IPWs, including those with poor motor control, decreased orientation, slower reaction times, visual impairments, and those experiencing fatigue. The relevance of IPWs is also expected to increase with age.

Key Results

Thematic analysis revealed three main themes:

  1. Challenging Situations that May Be Overcome by an IPW: Participants described numerous difficulties with current PWCs related to the built environment, outdoor navigation, and crowded places. They believe IPW features like obstacle avoidance, path following, and target following could significantly alleviate these issues. For example, obstacle avoidance was seen as crucial for navigating narrow spaces and avoiding unexpected obstacles.
  2. Cautious Optimism Concerning IPW Use: Participants were enthusiastic about IPW capabilities but expressed concerns about over-reliance, the potential for IPWs to make them "lazy," and the reliability of sensors, particularly in complex outdoor environments or when dealing with moving obstacles. Some felt they could still control their current PWC better than an automated system.
  3. Defining the Potential IPW User: Participants identified specific user groups who would benefit most, including individuals with motor, cognitive, or visual impairments, and those experiencing fatigue. They also noted that the benefits might become more pronounced as a user's condition progresses.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Video-Based Feedback: Participants provided feedback based on a video demonstration rather than direct experience with an IPW. While the video was effective in eliciting recall of relevant situations, actual use might yield different perspectives.
  • Limited Participant Pool: The study focused only on current PWU and their caregivers. Future research should include individuals who have been denied PWC use, those planning to acquire one, and perspectives from clinicians who prescribe these devices. The small number of caregivers (n=4) is also noted.
  • Exclusion of Cognitive Impairments: The current IPW prototype was not designed for users with cognitive impairments, and this population was not included in the study.
  • Generalizability: The findings are specific to the Montreal context and may not generalize to other geographical or healthcare system settings. The study also did not address the cost of IPWs.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Exploring the perspectives of prescribers.
  • Evaluating actual IPW use in various natural settings.
  • Developing appropriate measurement tools for assessing IPW use.
  • Investigating how IPWs might impact social participation.
  • Allowing users to select and opt-in/out of specific IPW features.
  • Providing adequate training and education for future IPW users.

Summary updated

Abstract

Power wheelchairs (PWCs) can have a positive impact on user well-being, self-esteem, pain, activity and participation. Newly developed intelligent power wheelchairs (IPWs), allowing autonomous or collaboratively-controlled navigation, could enhance mobility of individuals not able to use, or having difficulty using, standard PWCs. The objective of this study was to explore the perspectives of PWC users (PWUs) and their caregivers regarding if and how IPWs could impact on current challenges faced by PWUs, as well as inform current development of IPWs. A qualitative exploratory study using individual interviews was conducted with PWUs (n = 12) and caregivers (n = 4). A semi-structured interview guide and video were used to facilitate informed discussion regarding IPWs. Thematic analysis revealed three main themes: (1) "challenging situations that may be overcome by an IPW" described how the IPW features of obstacle avoidance, path following, and target following could alleviate PWUs' identified mobility difficulties; (2) "cautious optimism concerning IPW use revealed participants" addresses concerns regarding using an IPW as well as technological suggestions; (3) "defining the potential IPW user" revealed characteristics of PWUs that would benefit from IPW use. Findings indicate how IPW use may help overcome PWC difficulties and confirm the importance of user input in the ongoing development of IPWs.
BibTeX
@article{kairy2014exploring,
  author = {Dahlia Kairy and Paula W. Rushton and Philippe S. Archambault and Evelina Pituch and Caryne Torkia and Anas El Fathi and Paula Stone and François Routhier and Robert Forget and Louise Demers and Joëlle Pineau and Richard Gourdeau},
  title = {{Exploring Powered Wheelchair Users and Their Caregivers’ Perspectives on Potential Intelligent Power Wheelchair Use: A Qualitative Study}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph110202244},
}
Figure