Exploring Left-Wing Extremism on the Decentralized Web: An Analysis of Lemmygrad.ml

Utkucan Balci, Michael Sirivianos, Jeremy BlackburnarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

While academic research has predominantly focused on far-right extremism within decentralized digital spaces, this study shifts the focus toward far-left "tankie" communities. By analyzing the Lemmygrad.ml instance, researchers found that the deplatforming of extremist subreddits, such as r/GenZedong, acted as a catalyst for a massive migration to the decentralized web. This shift resulted in a significant surge in both user activity and the prevalence of toxic content, highlighting the role of the "Fediverse" as a safety valve for displaced extremist groups.

Introduction: The Rise of the "Tankie" Migration

The Decentralized Web, or Fediverse, is often presented as a democratic, user-owned alternative to centralized social media platforms. However, its lack of central authority also makes it a sanctuary for ideologies pushed off mainstream sites. While much research has examined right-wing fringe platforms like Gab or Truth Social, left-wing extremism—specifically "tankie" Marxist-Leninist communities that support authoritarian regimes—remains understudied. This research investigates how these groups behave when migrating from mainstream platforms like Reddit to decentralized alternatives like Lemmy.

Methodology: Tracking the Fediverse

The researchers employed a multi-pronged computational approach to analyze Lemmygrad.ml from its inception in 2019 through April 2022. The study utilized a custom crawler to collect 91,271 posts across 465 distinct communities.

To quantify harmful speech, the team used Google’s Perspective API, tracking six attributes: toxicity, severe toxicity, insult, identity attack, threat, and profanity. Content was flagged as "high-scoring" if it had a probability score $\ge 0.8$. Additionally, the researchers used BERTopic, a transformer-based topic modeling technique, to discover thematic clusters without prior bias. This allowed for a temporal analysis of user activity and toxicity levels relative to real-world events, such as Reddit's "quarantining" of related subreddits.

Results: The Deplatforming Catalyst

The data reveals a clear "migration effect." The deplatforming of r/GenZedong on Reddit did not silence the community; instead, it triggered an immediate and massive spike in activity on Lemmygrad.ml.

Monthly post counts showing the massive activity surge following Reddit's quarantine of r/GenZedong in early 2022.

Following the March 2022 Reddit quarantine, the community c/genzedong on Lemmy saw a peak of 8,666 posts from 572 users in a single month. Overall monthly posts on the instance rose from approximately 4,300 in February 2022 to nearly 15,000 by April 2022. This confirms that decentralized instances serve as vital infrastructure for banned extremist groups to reorganize.

Content and Toxicity Analysis

The influx of displaced users was accompanied by a shift in rhetorical style. The proportion of toxic and severely toxic posts reached new highs during the peak migration period in early 2022.

Percentage of high-scoring toxic content over time, showing a notable increase in toxicity and profanity during the 2022 migration period.

Topic modeling identified key areas of discourse, including support for "Actually Existing Socialist" (AES) countries like North Korea (DPRK) and China. However, the analysis also revealed ideological overlaps with far-right rhetoric, including antisemitism and the justification of military invasions. For instance, researchers documented posts explicitly justifying the Russian invasion of Ukraine and using "Zionist" as a catch-all slur.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The study highlights the "double-edged sword" of decentralization. While providing a space for free expression, these platforms also facilitate the persistence of extremist ideologies. Future work is needed to expand this analysis beyond a single instance to the broader federated network and to conduct direct quantitative comparisons between left-wing and right-wing extremist rhetoric. Developing governance mechanisms that balance free speech with the mitigation of extremism remains a critical challenge for the decentralized web.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study investigates the presence of left-wing extremism on the Lemmygrad.ml instance of the decentralized social media platform Lemmy, from its launch in 2019 up to a month after the bans of the subreddits r/GenZedong and r/GenZhou. We conduct a temporal analysis on Lemmygrad.ml's user activity, with also measuring the degree of highly abusive or hateful content. Furthermore, we explore the content of their posts using a transformer-based topic modeling approach. Our findings reveal a substantial increase in user activity and toxicity levels following the migration of these subreddits to Lemmygrad.ml. We also identify posts that support authoritarian regimes, endorse the Russian invasion of Ukraine, and feature anti-Zionist and antisemitic content. Overall, our findings contribute to a more nuanced understanding of political extremism within decentralized social networks and emphasize the necessity of analyzing both ends of the political spectrum in research.
BibTeX
@misc{balci2025exploring,
  author = {Utkucan Balci and Michael Sirivianos and Jeremy Blackburn},
  title = {{Exploring Left-Wing Extremism on the Decentralized Web: An Analysis of Lemmygrad.ml}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2507.23699},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.23699},
}
Figure