Exploring Early Stage Cost-Estimation Methods Using Off-the-Shelf Tools: A Preliminary Study

Haifeng Zhu, Narek R. Shougarian, Greg Ojard, Kaushik Sinha, Oliver de Weck, Eileen ArnoldCSDM 2016 · DOI

Introduction

In the realm of complex systems engineering, particularly within the aerospace sector, the ability to accurately estimate costs during the initial design phases is critical. Decisions made early in the lifecycle significantly influence the total cost of ownership and the feasibility of a project. However, traditional cost analysis methodologies are often hindered by their reliance on historical data, which is frequently proprietary, restricted, or difficult to adapt to novel architectures. This paper presents a preliminary study on a tool designed to bridge this gap by utilizing off-the-shelf software to provide early-stage cost estimates for airplane-engine architectures.

The Problem: Data Bottlenecks in Cost Estimation

Design Space Exploration (DSE) is a fundamental practice in modern engineering that allows designers to evaluate various trade-offs across a wide range of configurations. To be effective, DSE requires cost estimates at multiple levels of granularity—from individual components to the entire system.

The primary obstacle to achieving this is the "historical data bottleneck." Conventional cost-estimation models are built upon decades of proprietary data. For many organizations or new entrants into the field, this data is inaccessible. Furthermore, even when available, adapting historical data to reflect emerging technologies or unconventional engine architectures requires substantial manual effort, making it unsuitable for the rapid iterations required in early-stage design.

Methodology and Tool Architecture

To address these challenges, the authors developed a tool that prioritizes accessibility and interoperability. Instead of constructing a new, data-dependent estimation engine from scratch, the approach integrates existing, publicly available off-the-shelf tools.

The methodology is defined by three core pillars:

  1. Networked Interoperability: The tool is architected to function within complex systems engineering toolchains. By emphasizing interoperability, it can be integrated into a networked environment where it communicates with other engineering and simulation tools, ensuring that cost estimation is not an isolated activity but a part of the broader design workflow.
  2. Data Independence: A significant advantage of this tool is its ability to perform cost analysis without direct reliance on historical data. This circumvents the proprietary bottlenecks that typically stall early-stage analysis, allowing for more flexible exploration of new concepts.
  3. Multi-level Generation: The tool provides a holistic view of costs by generating estimates at both the macro (system) and micro (component) levels. This dual-level approach allows engineers to understand how specific component choices impact the overall development cost of the engine architecture.

Conclusion

While this study represents a preliminary step, the integration of off-the-shelf tools for cost estimation offers a promising path forward for aerospace engineering. By removing the dependency on restricted historical data and fostering interoperability, this approach enables more robust Design Space Exploration, ultimately leading to better-informed decision-making in the early stages of complex system development.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2016exploring,
  author = {Haifeng Zhu and Narek R. Shougarian and Greg Ojard and Kaushik Sinha and Oliver de Weck and Eileen Arnold},
  title = {{Exploring Early Stage Cost-Estimation Methods Using Off-the-Shelf Tools: A Preliminary Study}},
  booktitle = {CSDM},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-319-49103-5\_28},
}
Figure