Exploring cosmic origins with CORE: Cluster science
J.-b. Mélin, A. Bonaldi, M. Remazeilles, Yilun Guan, J. M. Diego, C. Hernández-Monteagudo, R. T. Génova-Santos, G. Luzzi, C. J. A. P. Martins, S. Grandis, J. J. Mohr, J. G. Bartlett, G. de Zotti, Simone Ferraro, D. Tramonte, J. A. Rubiño-Martín, J. F. Macías–Pérez, A. Achúcarro, P. A. R. Ade, R. Allison, M. Ashdown, M. Ballardini, A. J. Banday, R. Banerji, N. Bartolo, S. Basak, Kaustuv Basu, Richard A. Battye, D. Baumann, M. Bersanelli, Matteo Bonato, J. Borrill, F. R. Bouchet, F. Boulanger, T. Brinckmann, M. Bucher, C. Burigana, A. Buzzelli, Zhen-Yi Cai, M. Calvo, C. S. Carvalho, M. Castellano, A. Challinor, Jens Chluba, Sébastien Clesse, S. Colafrancesco, I. Colantoni, A. Coppolecchia, M. Crook, G. D’Alessandro, P. de Bernardis, G. de Gasperis, M. De Petris, E. Di Valentino, J. Errard, Stephen M. Feeney, R. Fernández-Cobos, F. Finelli⋆, F. Forastieri, S. Galli, M. Gerbino, J. González-Nuevo, J. Greenslade, Shaul Hanany, Will Handley, Carlos Hervías-Caimapo, M. Hills, E. Hivon, K. Kiiveri, T. Kisner, T. Kitching, M. Kunz, H. Kurki‐Suonio, L. Lamagna, A. Lasenby, M. Lattanzi, A.m.c Le Brun, J. Lesgourgues, Antony Lewis, M. Liguori, V. Lindholm, M. López-Caniego, B. Maffei, E. Martínez-González, S. Masi, P. Mazzotta, D. McCarthy, A. Melchiorri, D. Molinari, A. Monfardini, P. Natoli, M. Negrello, Alessio Notari, A. Paiella, D. Paoletti, G. Patanchon, M. Piat, G. Pisano, L. PolastriJournal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics2018 · DOI
This paper explores the scientific potential of the proposed CORE space mission for galaxy cluster cosmology. CORE, with its broad frequency coverage and advanced instrumentation, promises to deliver unprecedentedly large and deep cluster catalogs, significantly improving constraints on fundamental cosmological parameters like dark energy and neutrino masses, and complementing future ground-based observatories.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Understanding the universe's expansion history and the nature of dark energy and dark matter are central goals in modern cosmology. Galaxy clusters, being the largest gravitationally bound structures, are sensitive probes of the underlying cosmological model. Their abundance and evolution are directly linked to the growth of cosmic structure, which in turn is influenced by dark energy. However, accurately counting and characterizing these clusters, especially at high redshifts, is challenging. This paper addresses the need for a next-generation instrument capable of building a massive, high-quality cluster catalog to push the frontiers of cosmological measurements, and it investigates how such a mission, CORE, would perform and compare to other planned experiments.
Methods
The authors utilize realistic simulations of the millimeter sky, incorporating various astrophysical foregrounds and the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect from clusters. They employ a "Matched Multifilter" technique to identify clusters based on their SZ signal and noise levels. For cosmological parameter estimation, they use Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) and Fisher matrix analyses. A key aspect is the use of CMB halo lensing to calibrate cluster masses, a crucial step for accurate cosmological inference. They also explore the extraction of diffuse SZ maps and the measurement of the kinetic SZ effect.
Datasets
The study relies on simulated sky maps generated using the Planck Sky Model. These simulations include primary CMB, galactic emission (dust, free-free, synchrotron), infrared point sources, and cluster signals. The authors also reference data from previous missions like Planck and ground-based surveys like SPT and ACT for comparison and validation. No new observational datasets were introduced.
Key Insights and Ideas
CORE's Cluster Catalog Power: CORE's broad frequency coverage and sensitivity will enable the detection of tens of thousands of galaxy clusters, extending to high redshifts (z > 1.5), far surpassing previous surveys.
Telescope Size Matters: The diameter of CORE's primary mirror significantly impacts the number of detected clusters and the achievable mass resolution, with larger mirrors yielding deeper and more precise measurements.
CMB Halo Lensing is Key: Using CMB halo lensing to calibrate cluster masses is crucial for breaking degeneracies in cosmological parameter constraints and is a self-sufficient method for CORE.
Synergy with Ground-Based Experiments: Combining CORE data with future ground-based observatories like CMB-S4 offers a powerful synergy, enabling significantly deeper and more precise cosmological measurements.
Diffuse SZ Map Potential: CORE's ability to extract a clean, full-sky diffuse SZ map will provide a powerful new probe for cosmology, particularly for constraining $\sigma_8$.
Key Results
A CORE mission with a 150 cm mirror is expected to detect around 50,000 clusters.
CORE will be able to measure individual cluster halo masses with a 1-$\sigma$ sensitivity of 4x10$^{14}$ M$_{\odot}$ (120 cm aperture) to 10$^{14}$ M$_{\odot}$ (180 cm aperture).
Combining CORE with a South Pole CMB-S4 observatory could detect over 200,000 clusters, reaching a limiting mass of 2-3 x 10$^{13}$ M$_{\odot}$.
CORE cluster counts alone can provide competitive constraints on the dark energy equation-of-state parameters ($w_0, w_a$), with $\sigma_{w_0} \approx 0.28$ and $\sigma_{w_a} \approx 0.31$.
In combination with primary CMB data, CORE cluster counts can reduce these uncertainties to $\sigma_{w_0} \approx 0.05$ and $\sigma_{w_a} \approx 0.13$, and constrain the sum of neutrino masses to $\Sigma m_\nu = 39$ meV.
CORE can constrain the evolution of the CMB temperature with redshift to $\sigma_\beta \lesssim 2.7 \times 10^{-3}$ at low redshift.
CORE analysis of the diffuse SZ map is expected to improve constraints on $\sigma_8$ by an order of magnitude compared to Planck.
Limitations and Future Work
Mass Calibration Uncertainty: While CMB halo lensing is a powerful tool, the accuracy of mass calibration (specifically the parameter $1-b$) is critical for maximizing cosmological constraints. Achieving a 1% mass calibration is important.
Intracluster Dust Contamination: Dust emission from clusters can contaminate the measurement of the intracluster medium temperature using the relativistic SZ effect, making this measurement difficult.
Evolution of SZ Flux-Mass Relation: The exact number of high-redshift clusters detected is tied to the uncertain evolution of the cluster SZ flux-mass relation.
Future Work: The paper suggests that CORE, in combination with future ground-based experiments like CMB-S4, offers a significant leap in cosmological science. Further work could involve more detailed analysis of specific cosmological models and the impact of various systematic uncertainties. The paper also highlights the need for larger samples and improved measurements to further refine constraints.
Summary updated
Abstract
We examine the cosmological constraints that can be achieved with a galaxy cluster survey with the future CORE space mission. Using realistic simulations of the millimeter sky, produced with the latest version of the Planck Sky Model, we characterize the CORE cluster catalogues as a function of the main mission performance parameters. We pay particular attention to telescope size, key to improved angular resolution, and discuss the comparison and the complementarity of CORE with ambitious future ground-based CMB experiments that could be deployed in the next decade. A possible CORE mission concept with a 150 cm diameter primary mirror can detect of the order of 50,000 clusters through the thermal Sunyaev-Zeldovich effect (SZE). The total yield increases (decreases) by 25% when increasing (decreasing) the mirror diameter by 30 cm. The 150 cm telescope configuration will detect the most massive clusters (>1014 Mo) at redshift z>1.5 over the whole sky, although the exact number above this redshift is tied to the uncertain evolution of the cluster SZE flux-mass relation; assuming self-similar evolution, CORE will detect 0∼ 50 clusters at redshift z>1.5. This changes to 800 (200) when increasing (decreasing) the mirror size by 30 cm. CORE will be able to measure individual cluster halo masses through lensing of the cosmic microwave background anisotropies with a 1-σ sensitivity of 4×1014 Mo, for a 120 cm aperture telescope, and 1014 Mo for a 180 cm one. From the ground, we estimate that, for example, a survey with about 150,000 detectors at the focus of 350 cm telescopes observing 65% of the sky would be shallower than CORE and detect about 11,000 clusters, while a survey with the same number of detectors observing 25% of sky with a 10 m telescope is expected to be deeper and to detect about 70,000 clusters. When combined with the latter, CORE would reach a limiting mass of M500 ∼ 2-3 × 1013 Mo and detect 220,000 clusters (5 sigma detection limit). Cosmological constraints from CORE cluster counts alone are competitive with other scheduled large scale structure surveys in the 2020's for measuring the dark energy equation-of-state parameters w0 and wa (σw0=0.28, σwa=0.31). In combination with primary CMB constraints, CORE cluster counts can further reduce these error bars on w0 and wa to 0.05 and 0.13 respectively, and constrain the sum of the neutrino masses, Σ mν, to 39 meV (1 sigma). The wide frequency coverage of CORE, 60-600 GHz, will enable measurement of the relativistic thermal SZE by stacking clusters. Contamination by dust emission from the clusters, however, makes constraining the temperature of the intracluster medium difficult. The kinetic SZE pairwise momentum will be extracted with 0S/N=7 in the foreground-cleaned CMB map. Measurements of TCMB(z) using CORE clusters will establish competitive constraints on the evolution of the CMB temperature: (1+z)1-β, with an uncertainty of σβ ≲ 2.7× 10-3 at low redshift (z ≲ 1). The wide frequency coverage also enables clean extraction of a map of the diffuse SZE signal over the sky, substantially reducing contamination by foregrounds compared to the Planck SZE map extraction. Our analysis of the one-dimensional distribution of Compton-y values in the simulated map finds an order of magnitude improvement in constraints on σ8 over the Planck result, demonstrating the potential of this cosmological probe with CORE.
BibTeX
@article{melin2018exploring,
author = {J.-B. Mélin and A. Bonaldi and M. Remazeilles and Yilun Guan and J. M. Diego and C. Hernández-Monteagudo and R. T. Génova-Santos and G. Luzzi and C. J. A. P. Martins and S. Grandis and J. J. Mohr and J. G. Bartlett and G. de Zotti and Simone Ferraro and D. Tramonte and J. A. Rubiño-Martín and J. F. Macías–Pérez and A. Achúcarro and P. A. R. Ade and R. Allison and M. Ashdown and M. Ballardini and A. J. Banday and R. Banerji and N. Bartolo and S. Basak and Kaustuv Basu and Richard A. Battye and D. Baumann and M. Bersanelli and Matteo Bonato and J. Borrill and F. R. Bouchet and F. Boulanger and T. Brinckmann and M. Bucher and C. Burigana and A. Buzzelli and Zhen-Yi Cai and M. Calvo and C. S. Carvalho and M. Castellano and A. Challinor and Jens Chluba and Sébastien Clesse and S. Colafrancesco and I. Colantoni and A. Coppolecchia and M. Crook and G. D’Alessandro and P. de Bernardis and G. de Gasperis and M. De Petris and G. De Zotti and E. Di Valentino and J. Errard and Stephen M. Feeney and R. Fernández-Cobos and F. Finelli⋆ and F. Forastieri and S. Galli and M. Gerbino and J. González-Nuevo and J. Greenslade and Shaul Hanany and Will Handley and Carlos Hervías-Caimapo and M. Hills and E. Hivon and K. Kiiveri and T. Kisner and T. Kitching and M. Kunz and H. Kurki‐Suonio and L. Lamagna and A. Lasenby and M. Lattanzi and A.M.C Le Brun and J. Lesgourgues and Antony Lewis and M. Liguori and V. Lindholm and M. López-Caniego and B. Maffei and E. Martínez-González and S. Masi and P. Mazzotta and D. McCarthy and A. Melchiorri and D. Molinari and A. Monfardini and P. Natoli and M. Negrello and Alessio Notari and A. Paiella and D. Paoletti and G. Patanchon and M. Piat and G. Pisano and L. Polastri},
title = {{Exploring cosmic origins with CORE: Cluster science}},
journal = {Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics},
year = {2018},
doi = {10.1088/1475-7516/2018/04/019},
}