TL;DR
This paper explores how to build better multi-document summarization systems by moving beyond simple word frequencies to more structured probabilistic topic models. Their proposed hierarchical topic model, HIERSUM, achieves state-of-the-art results on standard benchmarks and is preferred by human evaluators, suggesting that richer content representations lead to higher quality summaries.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Multi-document summarization aims to condense information from a collection of related documents into a concise summary. A key challenge is effectively representing the "content" of these documents to identify the most important information. Early approaches relied on simple word frequency counts, but these can be too simplistic. More advanced methods have explored graph-based or linguistic techniques, but a direct comparison of increasingly complex probabilistic topic models against simpler baselines for generic summarization was lacking. This paper aims to fill that gap by systematically exploring different content models, culminating in a hierarchical topic model that captures nuanced content structure.
Methods
The authors propose a progression of summarization models, starting with a simple word frequency-based approach (SUMBASIC) and progressively adding more structure.
- SUMBASIC: A baseline that scores sentences based on the frequency of non-stop words within the document set. It iteratively adds sentences with the highest scores, penalizing redundancy by squaring word probabilities.
- KLSUM: This model refines the objective by using the Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence between the document set's unigram distribution and a candidate summary's distribution. The goal is to find a summary whose word distribution closely matches the document set's.
- TOPICSUM: This model introduces a simple Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA)-style topic model to learn a content distribution for the document set. This learned distribution replaces the raw unigram distribution in the KLSUM criterion, aiming to better capture document content.
- HIERSUM: The core contribution, this model extends TOPICSUM by using a hierarchical LDA-style model. It learns a general content topic distribution for the entire document set, along with multiple specific "sub-topic" distributions that represent topical themes within the collection. This allows for richer content representation, distinguishing between general story concepts and specific sub-narratives. The model also incorporates sentence-level topic distributions and a "sticky" HMM to encourage lexical cohesion across sentences.
Datasets
- DUC 2006: Used for model development and initial evaluation.
- DUC 2007: Used for final evaluation, consisting of 45 document sets, each with 25 documents and 4 human reference summaries.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Richer content models improve summarization: Moving beyond simple word frequencies to structured probabilistic topic models, especially hierarchical ones, leads to better summarization quality.
- Hierarchy matters for content representation: HIERSUM's ability to model both general and specific topics within a document collection is crucial. This allows it to capture nuanced content that a single topic distribution might miss.
- Early sentences often contain general content: The model leverages this intuition by biasing early sentences towards emitting general content words, which is beneficial for creating coherent overall summaries.
- Topic models provide building blocks for structure: The authors argue that topic models offer a flexible foundation for incorporating more sophisticated summarization strategies.
Key Results
- Automatic Evaluation (ROUGE):
- HIERSUM (unigram) achieved state-of-the-art ROUGE performance on DUC 2006.
- HIERSUM (bigram) achieved comparable ROUGE scores to PYTHY (a strong supervised system) on DUC 2007, outperforming it in R-2 and R-SU4 metrics.
- Manual Evaluation:
- Users strongly preferred HIERSUM summaries over PYTHY summaries across all evaluated criteria (Overall quality, Non-Redundancy, Coherence, Focus).
- HIERSUM summaries were perceived as significantly less redundant and more coherent.
Limitations and Future Work
- Redundancy in HIERSUM unigram: The unigram version of HIERSUM was noted to be comparable to PYTHY but not statistically significantly better in some metrics. The bigram version improved this.
- Sentence ordering: While the KLSum criterion helps select sentences, the ordering of these sentences is based on their original position within the document, which might not always be optimal for coherence.
- Topic adaptation: The specific topics identified by HIERSUM are not adaptive to user interest. The authors suggest that this framework could be used for content discovery by presenting users with salient words from these topics.
- Topic models over n-grams: The paper notes that modeling over bigrams can lead to degenerate cases, suggesting future work on topic models over n-grams.
- Query-focused summarization: While the paper focuses on generic summarization, the authors mention that their topic models could be adapted for query-focused summarization.
Summary updated