Exploration of water-recycled cassava bioethanol production integrated with anaerobic digestion treatment

Fubao Sun, Zhonggui Mao, Lei Tang, Hongjian Zhang, Chengming Zhang, Fangfang Zhai, Jing ZhangAFRICAN 2010 · DOI

Abstract: Due to the limited success of discharge target-hitting treatment in coping with environmental pollution from the alcohol industry, our attention was directed towards the distillery spent (DS) wash recycle in a cleaner bioethanol production by integrating anaerobic digestion treatment with conventional fermentation. An anaerobic digestion effluent from an alcohol waste water treatment plant is applicable for single use in ethanol fermentation. With further experimental estimate, the recycle of DS treated by a sole thermophilic up flow anaerobic sludge blanket (UASB) treatment was adverse to ethanol fermentation, resulting in a gradual increase of the residual total sugar from 1.2% at batch 1 to 8.0% at batch 5 after 48 h. With a combination of the thermophilic and mesophilic UASB treatment, the thirteenbatch fermentation recycling its DS achieved ~10.5% of ethanol production and > 90% of starch utilization after 48 h, which was comparable to that using tap water. This revealed a potential of the anaerobic digestion treatment in water-saving and emission reduction for bioethanol industry.

Introduction

The bioethanol industry, particularly when using cassava as a feedstock, faces a significant environmental challenge. For every liter of ethanol produced, approximately 8 to 15 liters of distillery spent (DS) wash are generated. This waste stream is acidic, dark-colored, and contains high levels of organic matter (Chemical Oxygen Demand, or COD), making it difficult and costly to treat to standard discharge levels. While recycling this waste water back into the process is a desirable "circular economy" goal, direct reuse often inhibits fermentation due to the accumulation of volatile organic compounds and salts. This study explores integrating anaerobic digestion to treat DS wash for sustainable reuse.

Methods

The researchers proposed integrating Up-flow Anaerobic Sludge Blanket (UASB) bioreactors into the production cycle to "clean" the DS wash for reuse as dilution water. The core experimental setup involved treating the DS wash with anaerobic bacteria to break down organic matter and produce biogas, then using the resulting effluent to dilute the next batch of cassava feedstock.

Integrated process flow for cassava bioethanol production with two-stage anaerobic digestion recycling.

Three primary scenarios were evaluated:

  1. Single-use treated waste water: Using Anaerobic Digestion Discharge Water (ADDW) from an existing plant.
  2. Single-stage recycling: Treating DS wash with a sole thermophilic (60°C) UASB before recycling.
  3. Two-stage recycling: A robust system using a thermophilic (60°C) UASB followed by a mesophilic (35°C) UASB.

Key Insights and Results

The Nutrient Bonus

Initial tests showed that using treated waste water (ADDW) for a single batch actually outperformed tap water. Yeast growth was faster and reached higher concentrations, likely because the treated water retained beneficial micronutrients (K, S, N, P, and trace metals) that acted as a fermentation fertilizer.

Overcoming the "Inhibitor Wall"

While a single-stage thermophilic UASB initially worked, performance degraded rapidly during continuous recycling. By the 5th batch, residual sugar increased from 1.2% to 8.0%, and fermentation time nearly doubled, indicating a buildup of fermentation-unfriendly substances.

The integration of a second, mesophilic (35°C) digestion stage proved to be the critical solution. This two-stage system likely eliminated specific volatile inhibitors and stabilized nutrient levels, allowing for long-term stability.

Long-term Stability and Performance

The two-stage recycling system achieved an ethanol concentration of ~10.5% (v/v) and a starch utilization rate of >90%, matching the performance of fresh tap water. Crucially, this performance remained stable through 13 consecutive recycling batches.

Stability of total sugar consumption over 13 consecutive recycling batches using the two-stage UASB treatment system.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that integrating two-stage anaerobic digestion (thermophilic and mesophilic) into the bioethanol production process enables a closed-loop water cycle. The system maintains high ethanol yields and starch utilization while significantly reducing fresh water consumption and waste discharge. This approach offers a viable path for the bioethanol industry to achieve cleaner production and emission reduction goals.

Summary updated

Abstract

Due to the limited success of discharge target-hitting treatment in coping with environmental pollution from the alcohol industry, our attention was directed towards the distillery spent (DS) wash recycle in a cleaner bioethanol production by integrating anaerobic digestion treatment with conventional fermentation. An anaerobic digestion effluent from an alcohol waste water treatment plant is applicable for single use in ethanol fermentation. With further experimental estimate, the recycle of DS treated by a sole thermophilic up flow anaerobic sludge blanket (UASB) treatment was adverse to ethanol fermentation, resulting in a gradual increase of the residual total sugar from 1.2% at batch 1 to 8.0% at batch 5 after 48 h. With a combination of the thermophilic and mesophilic UASB treatment, the thirteenbatch fermentation recycling its DS achieved ~10.5% of ethanol production and > 90% of starch utilization after 48 h, which was comparable to that using tap water. This revealed a potential of the anaerobic digestion treatment in water-saving and emission reduction for bioethanol industry. Key words : Anaerobic digestion, cassava, cleaner bioethanol production, distillery spent wash, thermophilic and mesophilic up flow anaerobic sludge blanket, recycle and reuse.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2010exploration,
  author = {Fubao Sun and Zhonggui Mao and Lei Tang and Hongjian Zhang and Chengming Zhang and Fangfang Zhai and Jing Zhang},
  title = {{Exploration of water-recycled cassava bioethanol production integrated with anaerobic digestion treatment}},
  booktitle = {AFRICAN},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.5897/ajb10.506},
}
Figure