Exploration of Pedestrian Head Injuries—Collision Parameter Relationships through a Combination of Retrospective Analysis and Finite Element Method

Wenjun Liu, Sen Su, Jinlong Qiu, Zhang Yongyong, Zhiyong YinInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study combines real-world accident data with advanced finite element modeling to investigate how different collision parameters (speed, impact angle) affect pedestrian head injuries. The findings highlight that higher impact speeds and rear-side impacts pose a greater risk, offering crucial insights for improving vehicle safety designs and pedestrian protection strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Pedestrian-vehicle collisions remain a significant cause of severe injury and fatality worldwide. While the general understanding is that higher speeds lead to worse outcomes, there's a need for a more detailed, parameter-specific understanding of how these collisions impact pedestrian heads. Specifically, the relationship between various collision parameters (like impact speed and the angle of contact) and the severity of head injuries, including skull fractures and brain trauma, is not fully elucidated. Existing research often relies on simpler models or limited datasets, leaving a gap in our ability to accurately predict and prevent these injuries. This paper aims to bridge this gap by combining statistical analysis of actual accident data with sophisticated finite element simulations to explore these complex relationships.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged approach:

  1. Retrospective Statistical Analysis: They analyzed data from 61 car-pedestrian collision cases in Chongqing, China. Injuries were classified using the Abbreviated Injury Scale (AIS 2005 Revision). Collision parameters like impact speed (categorized into 25-39 km/h, 40-55 km/h, and ≥55 km/h) and contact angles (left, right, back) were recorded. Statistical tests (Fisher's Exact Test) were used to identify significant differences in injury patterns across these parameters.
  2. Finite Element Method (FEM) Simulation: A detailed finite element model of a car (from the National Car Crash Analysis Center) and a sophisticated human body model (THUMS version 4.0) were used. The THUMS model, known for its detailed anatomical representation, was scaled to represent a 50th percentile Chinese pedestrian (154 cm height, 48.6 kg weight). Simulations were conducted with varying impact velocities (25, 40, and 55 km/h) and contact angles (front, left, right, back). Key injury assessment parameters like the Head Injury Criterion (HIC), peak stress on the skull, and maximal principal strain in the brain were calculated.

The study then compared and analyzed the results from both methods to draw conclusions.

Datasets

  • Real-world Accident Data: Data from 61 car-pedestrian collision cases collected between 2010 and 2014 in Chongqing, China. This dataset included detailed injury information and determined impact parameters.
  • Finite Element Models:
    • A validated FE model of a car (from the National Car Crash Analysis Center).
  • The THUMS (Total Human Model for Safety) version 4.0 FE model of a pedestrian, specifically the "standing posture" version.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Speed Kills (and Injures Severely): The study strongly reinforces that increasing impact velocity directly correlates with more severe head injuries, including skull fractures and brain contusions. This is a fundamental but critical finding that underpins many safety initiatives.
  • Impact Angle Matters Greatly: The direction of impact is not just a secondary factor. The research highlights that impacts from the rear of the pedestrian's head are significantly more damaging than front or side impacts, even at the same velocity. This suggests that the head's interaction with different parts of the vehicle's front structure (like the hood) can lead to vastly different injury outcomes.
  • Back Impacts are Particularly Risky: For shorter stature pedestrians, impacts from the rear of the head appear to pose a greater risk of severe injury. This is a crucial insight for designing vehicles that offer better protection across a wider range of pedestrian sizes and impact scenarios.
  • FEM and Statistics Align: A key success of this study is the strong agreement between the statistical analysis of real-world data and the results from the FEM simulations. This validation increases confidence in the predictive power of the FE models for understanding injury mechanisms.

Key Results

  • Statistical Significance: Both impact velocity and contact angle showed statistically significant differences (p < 0.05) in the occurrence of skull fractures, brain contusions/lacerations, and overall head injury severity (AIS3+).
  • HIC Trends: HIC values increased with impact velocity. For a constant velocity, HIC was highest for back impacts, followed by front and side impacts. For example, at 55 km/h, the HIC reached 10,711 for a back impact.
  • Skull Stress: Peak stress on the skull also increased with impact velocity. Back impacts consistently resulted in higher peak skull stress compared to front or side impacts at the same velocity. For instance, at 55 km/h, peak stress was 230 MPa for a back impact.
  • Brain Strain: Maximal principal strain in the brain, a predictor of traumatic brain injury, also increased with velocity and was highest for back impacts. At 55 km/h, the maximal principal strain for a back impact was 0.79.
  • Case Study Validation: The FEM simulations for two specific accident cases accurately reconstructed the real injuries, including fatal outcomes, demonstrating the model's predictive capability. Case 2, a back impact, showed higher HIC, skull stress, and brain strain values, aligning with the overall findings.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Retrospective Data Limitations: The retrospective analysis had a limited number of front impact cases, which the authors suggest should be addressed in future work.
  • Pedestrian Characteristics: While the study used a scaled model, it acknowledges that individual pedestrian characteristics like age, sex, height, and weight can significantly influence injury severity. Future research should delve deeper into these individual-level factors.
  • Gait and Kinematics: The paper points out that pedestrian head movement characteristics, such as transverse translation and head rotation, which are influenced by gait, also play a role and warrant further investigation.
  • Automotive Design Implications: The findings on back impacts suggest a need for automotive designers to consider how to better protect pedestrians from these specific types of collisions, potentially prioritizing them in safety design and research.

Summary updated

Abstract

There are a very limited number of reports concerning the relationship between pedestrian head injuries and collision parameters through a combination of statistical analysis methods and finite element method (FEM). This study aims to explore the characteristics of pedestrian head injuries in car-pedestrian collisions at different parameters by using the two means above. A retrospective analysis of pedestrian head injuries was performed based on detailed investigation data of 61 car-pedestrian collision cases. The head damage assessment parameters (head injury criterion (HIC), peak stress on the skull, maximal principal strain for the brain) in car-pedestrian simulation experiments with four contact angles and three impact velocities were obtained by FEM. The characteristics of the pedestrian head injuries were discussed by comparing and analyzing the statistical analysis results and finite element analysis results. The statistical analysis results demonstrated a significant difference in skull fractures, contusion and laceration of brain and head injuries on the abbreviated injury scale (AIS)3+ was found at different velocities (<i>p</i> < 0.05) and angles (<i>p</i> < 0.05). The simulation results showed that, in pedestrian head-to-hood impacts, the values of head damage assessment parameters increased with impact velocities. At the same velocity, these values from the impact on the pedestrian's back were successively greater than on the front or the side. Furthermore, head injury reconstruction and prediction results of two selected cases were consistent with the real injuries. Overall, it was further spelled out that, for shorter stature pedestrians, increased head impact velocity results in greater head injury severity in car-pedestrian collision, especially in pedestrian head-to-hood impacts. Under a back impact, the head has also been found to be at greater damage risk for shorter stature pedestrians, which may have implications on automotive design and pedestrian protection research if prevention and treatment of these injuries is to be prioritized over head injuries under a front or side impact.
BibTeX
@article{liu2016exploration,
  author = {Wenjun Liu and Sen Su and Jinlong Qiu and Zhang Yongyong and Zhiyong Yin},
  title = {{Exploration of Pedestrian Head Injuries—Collision Parameter Relationships through a Combination of Retrospective Analysis and Finite Element Method}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph13121250},
}
Figure