Experts and authorities receive disproportionate attention on Twitter during the COVID-19 crisis

Kristina Gligoric, Manoel Horta Ribeiro, Martin Müller, Olesia Altunina, Maxime Peyrard, Marcel Salathé, Giovanni Colavizza, Robert WestarXiv 2020 · arXiv

Abstract

During the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic, concerns about a "misinformation infodemic" were widespread. However, this study demonstrates that Twitter users significantly amplified the voices of experts and authorities. Accounts categorized under healthcare, science, and government experienced surges in engagement that far exceeded their increases in posting volume. This suggests a collective public shift toward seeking and promoting trustworthy information during the global health emergency.

Introduction

The World Health Organization (WHO) identified an "infodemic" early in the COVID-19 crisis, fearing that low-quality information would overshadow critical public health guidance. While social media is often criticized for the rapid spread of "fake news," this research investigates the "structural importance" of accounts—such as scientists and government officials—to see if their expertise translated into increased attention during the pandemic.

Methodology

The researchers analyzed Twitter activity from January to May 2020 using a multi-step pipeline:

  1. Taxonomy: Accounts were classified into 13 categories (e.g., Healthcare, Science, Government).
  2. Sampling: 14,200 accounts with popular COVID-19 tweets were sampled.
  3. Classification: A BERT-based machine learning model was trained to categorize millions of users across the COVID-19 tweet stream.
  4. Analysis: The study compared "tweet volume" (posting frequency) against "engagement volume" (retweets and likes) using Inverse Probability Weighting (IPW) to ensure representative results.

Results: The Selective Attention Boost

The study found that while posting increased across most categories, the surge in engagement was highly selective. Authoritative sources received a disproportionate "attention boost."

Figure 2: Comparison of tweet volume and engagement volume across different account categories.

As shown in the figure above, categories like Government and Politics, Healthcare, and Science saw engagement peaks (+402%, +319%, and +281% respectively) that vastly outpaced their increases in posting volume. For instance, government accounts doubled their posting but quadrupled their engagement. In contrast, categories like Sports and Religion saw their "effectiveness" (engagements per tweet) decline as public attention shifted toward crisis-relevant information.

Discussion: Expertise vs. Clout

A key finding of the research is that traditional social media "clout" (follower count) was not the primary driver of engagement during the crisis.

Figure 3: Relationship between follower rank and engagement rank, highlighting the "attention boost" for expert accounts.

The data indicates that Healthcare and Science accounts, despite often having lower average follower counts than News Media or Sports accounts, achieved significantly higher engagement ranks. This suggests that the relevance of expertise became the dominant factor in information sharing. Furthermore, the study distinguishes between "transient" authority (spikes in Healthcare/Science engagement that eventually regressed) and "persistent" authority (sustained high engagement for Government accounts).

Conclusion and Limitations

The macro-level trends on Twitter during the first wave of COVID-19 provide a counter-narrative to the "infodemic" fear, showing that "voices of reason" were the most widely shared. However, the study has limitations: it relies on account bios for categorization rather than individual tweet content, and it measures attention rather than the scientific accuracy of the messages. Future work should explore content-level quality and how these attention patterns evolve as a crisis transitions from a health emergency to a long-term societal issue.

Summary updated

Abstract

Timely access to accurate information is crucial during the COVID-19 pandemic. Prompted by key stakeholders' cautioning against an "infodemic", we study information sharing on Twitter from January through May 2020. We observe an overall surge in the volume of general as well as COVID-19-related tweets around peak lockdown in March/April 2020. With respect to engagement (retweets and likes), accounts related to healthcare, science, government and politics received by far the largest boosts, whereas accounts related to religion and sports saw a relative decrease in engagement. While the threat of an "infodemic" remains, our results show that social media also provide a platform for experts and public authorities to be widely heard during a global crisis.
BibTeX
@misc{gligoric2020experts,
  author = {Kristina Gligoric and Manoel Horta Ribeiro and Martin Müller and Olesia Altunina and Maxime Peyrard and Marcel Salathé and Giovanni Colavizza and Robert West},
  title = {{Experts and authorities receive disproportionate attention on Twitter during the COVID-19 crisis}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2008.08364},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2008.08364},
}
Figure