Experimental Testing of Bionic Peripheral Nerve and Muscle Interfaces: Animal Model Considerations

Martin Aman, Konstantin D. Bergmeister, Christopher Festin, Matthias E. Sporer, Michael Russold, Clemens Gstoettner, Bruno K. Podesser, Alexander Gail, Dario Farina, Paul S. Cederna, Oskar C. AszmannFrontiers in Neuroscience 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper addresses the critical need for robust preclinical animal models in developing advanced bionic prosthetics. By analyzing existing literature, the authors highlight that current animal testing often falls short of simulating long-term, real-world use, and propose a tiered approach using small and large animals to ensure the safety and efficacy of future human implants.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The development of sophisticated bionic prosthetics is significantly hampered by the challenge of creating reliable and high-bandwidth interfaces between humans and machines. While implantable electrodes in nerves and muscles offer a promising solution to overcome the limitations of traditional surface electrodes, their long-term biocompatibility and functionality must be rigorously tested before human implantation. This preclinical testing is crucial for regulatory approval and patient safety. However, selecting the appropriate animal model that accurately simulates the demands of a lifelong prosthetic application, considering factors like chronic use, mechanical stress, and ethical implications, is a complex and often overlooked aspect of research. This paper aims to provide a comprehensive overview and critical analysis of existing animal models used for testing these interfaces, guiding researchers toward more effective and ethically sound experimental designs.

Methods

The authors conducted a systematic literature review following PRISMA guidelines to identify studies involving animal models for testing bionic interfaces or electrodes connected to peripheral nerves or muscles. They analyzed these studies based on animal model type, group size, experiment duration, origin of publication, and interface type. Beyond this quantitative analysis, they also qualitatively assessed behavioral, ethical, and economic considerations associated with different models. The paper further includes a discussion of their own surgical experiences with rat, sheep, and primate models and proposes a framework for standardized international testing.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study is a literature review and analysis of existing research, not based on a specific dataset.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Chronic" Gap: A significant finding is that only about 37% of the reviewed animal studies were truly "chronic" (lasting over 3 months), which is crucial for understanding long-term performance and potential complications of implants. This suggests a widespread underestimation of the duration needed for adequate preclinical testing.
  • Cost vs. Benefit: While large animal models are considerably more expensive (up to 45 times more than small animals), their cost is deemed relatively small compared to the potential costs associated with complications and device failures in human applications. This emphasizes the importance of investing in appropriate large-animal studies.
  • Model Specialization: Different animal models are better suited for specific aspects of testing. Small animals (like rats) are ideal for initial biocompatibility and functionality assessments due to lower costs and easier handling, while larger animals (like sheep) are necessary for evaluating real-sized implants and long-term performance under more realistic mechanical loads.
  • Neural Dominance: The vast majority of studies (77%) focused on neural interfaces, with muscular interfaces being tested in only 23% of cases. This highlights a potential area for increased research focus, especially as muscle-based control is a key component of advanced prosthetics.
  • Standardization is Key: The paper advocates for international standardization in testing approaches to ensure comparability of results across different research groups and institutions, particularly when using models like sheep that are more widely available and ethically accepted than others.

Key Results

  • A total of 8859 studies were initially identified, with 198 ultimately included in the final analysis.
  • Most studies originated from North America (55%) and Europe (34%).
  • Small animal models, particularly rats (40%), were the most commonly used.
  • Neural interfaces were tested in 77% of studies, compared to 23% for muscular interfaces.
  • Large animal models had a mean duration of 135 ± 87.2 days with an average of 5.3 ± 3.4 animals per trial.
  • Small animal models had a mean duration of 85 ± 11.2 days with an average of 12.4 ± 1.7 animals per trial.
  • Only 37.2% of small animal studies and 36.9% of large animal studies met the definition of chronic tests (>3 months).
  • Costs for large animals can be up to 45 times higher than for small animals.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the majority of studies do not meet the criteria for chronic testing, which limits the understanding of long-term performance. They also note that certain animal models have limitations in simulating specific human movements (e.g., walking analysis in non-biped animals).

Future work should focus on:

  • Implementing a Tiered Testing Approach: Combining preliminary testing in small animals (rats) with subsequent long-term evaluation in large animals (sheep) to assess biocompatibility, impedance, and tissue regeneration.
  • Standardizing Testing Protocols: Developing international standards for preclinical testing to ensure reproducibility and comparability of results.
  • Considering Non-Biped Animals: Addressing the challenges of simulating bipedal locomotion in animal models.
  • Ethical and Economic Considerations: Continuing to balance the scientific necessity of animal testing with ethical considerations and cost-effectiveness.
  • NHP for Complex Interfaces: Utilizing non-human primate (NHP) models for testing highly complex interfaces or when specific biomechanical similarities to humans are essential, but only when justified by the advanced stage of device development.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Introduction:</b> Man-machine interfacing remains the main challenge for accurate and reliable control of bionic prostheses. Implantable electrodes in nerves and muscles may overcome some of the limitations by significantly increasing the interface's reliability and bandwidth. Before human application, experimental preclinical testing is essential to assess chronic <i>in-vivo</i> biocompatibility and functionality. Here, we analyze available animal models, their costs and ethical challenges in special regards to simulating a potentially life-long application in a short period of time and in non-biped animals. <b>Methods:</b> We performed a literature analysis following the PRISMA guidelines including all animal models used to record neural or muscular activity via implantable electrodes, evaluating animal models, group size, duration, origin of publication as well as type of interface. Furthermore, behavioral, ethical, and economic considerations of these models were analyzed. Additionally, we discuss experience and surgical approaches with rat, sheep, and primate models and an approach for international standardized testing. <b>Results:</b> Overall, 343 studies matched the search terms, dominantly originating from the US (55%) and Europe (34%), using mainly small animal models (rat: 40%). Electrode placement was dominantly neural (77%) compared to muscular (23%). Large animal models had a mean duration of 135 ± 87.2 days, with a mean of 5.3 ± 3.4 animals per trial. Small animal models had a mean duration of 85 ± 11.2 days, with a mean of 12.4 ± 1.7 animals. <b>Discussion:</b> Only 37% animal models were by definition chronic tests (>3 months) and thus potentially provide information on long-term performance. Costs for large animals were up to 45 times higher than small animals. However, costs are relatively small compared to complication costs in human long-term applications. Overall, we believe a combination of small animals for preliminary primary electrode testing and large animals to investigate long-term biocompatibility, impedance, and tissue regeneration parameters provides sufficient data to ensure long-term human applications.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{aman2020experimental,
  author = {Martin Aman and Konstantin D. Bergmeister and Christopher Festin and Matthias E. Sporer and Michael Russold and Clemens Gstoettner and Bruno K. Podesser and Alexander Gail and Dario Farina and Paul S. Cederna and Oskar C. Aszmann},
  title = {{Experimental Testing of Bionic Peripheral Nerve and Muscle Interfaces: Animal Model Considerations}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neuroscience},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fnins.2019.01442},
}
Figure