Experimental test of high-dimensional quantum contextuality based on contextuality concentration

Zhenghao Liu, Hui-Xian Meng, Zhen‐Peng Xu, Jie Zhou, Jing‐Ling Chen, Jin‐Shi Xu, Chuan‐Feng Li, Guang‐Can Guo, Adán CabelloarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Contextuality is a distinctive feature of quantum theory and a fundamental resource for quantum computation. However, existing examples of contextuality in high-dimensional systems lack the necessary robustness required in experiments. Here we address this problem by identifying a family of noncontextuality inequalities whose maximum quantum violation grows with the dimension of the system. At first glance, this contextuality is the single-system version of multipartite Bell nonlocality taken to an extreme form. What is interesting is that the single-system version achieves the same degree of contextuality but uses a Hilbert space of lower dimension. That is, contextuality "concentrates" as the degree of contextuality per dimension increases. We show the practicality of this result by presenting an experimental test of contextuality in a seven-dimensional system. By simulating sequences of quantum ideal measurements with destructive measurements and repreparation in an all-optical setup, we report a violation of 68.7 standard deviations of the simplest case of the noncontextuality inequalities identified. Our results advance the investigation of high-dimensional contextuality, its connection to the Clifford algebra, and its role in quantum computation.

Introduction

In classical physics, we assume that a measurement simply reveals a pre-existing property of an object that exists independently of the measurement process. Quantum mechanics challenges this through contextuality: the outcome of a measurement depends on the "context"—the set of other compatible measurements performed simultaneously. While contextuality is a vital resource for quantum computing, particularly for magic state distillation, testing it in high-dimensional systems is notoriously difficult due to the sensitivity of multi-particle entangled states to noise and experimental imperfections.

This research, conducted by a collaborative team from the University of Science and Technology of China and the University of Seville, demonstrates a record-breaking degree of quantum contextuality in a single 7-dimensional photonic system. By "concentrating" the correlations typically found in multi-particle systems into a single high-dimensional particle, the team achieved the strongest experimental evidence of contextuality to date.

Methods

The researchers utilized a graph-theoretical approach to translate multipartite Bell inequalities into a single-particle scenario. They proved that the contextuality of an $n$-qubit system (occupying a $2^n$-dimensional space) can be "concentrated" into a single system of dimension $2^n - 1$. For their experiment, this meant mapping the properties of a 3-qubit system onto a 7-dimensional qudit.

Experimental setup and beam profiles. (a) The all-optical setup uses Spatial Light Modulators (SLMs) to encode states and shape wavefronts, with Single-Photon Avalanche Detectors (SPADs) for measurement. (b, c) Comparison of theoretical and experimental beam profiles for the 7-dimensional system.

The experimental implementation used an all-optical setup where a single photon's spatial path served as the 7-dimensional qudit. Spatial Light Modulators (SLMs) were employed to encode quantum states and implement complex measurements. To emulate "ideal" non-demolition measurements with standard destructive photon detectors, the team used a "prepare-and-measure" scheme: performing a destructive measurement and immediately re-preparing the resulting state for the next measurement in the sequence.

Results

The experiment yielded a violation of the noncontextuality inequality by 68.7 standard deviations. When quantified by the "quantum-classical ratio" (the ratio of the quantum value to the maximum classical limit), the experiment achieved a value of 1.273, the highest ever observed in a single system.

Experimental results. (a) Measured probabilities across four contexts, showing the distribution of outcomes $p_1$ through $p_{16}$. (b) The projector-state matrix used to verify the high-dimensional contextuality and the fidelity of the implementation.

Key findings include:

  • Logical Contextuality: The team demonstrated "Hardy-like" contextuality, a logical paradox where classical physics predicts a 0% probability for certain events that quantum mechanics predicts will happen with 100% probability. They observed these "forbidden" events with over 97.6% success.
  • High Fidelity: Beam profiles captured via CCD cameras confirmed high-fidelity state preparation, achieving an average Pearson correlation of 95.5% with theoretical predictions.
  • No-Signaling Verification: Rigorous testing confirmed the "no-signaling" condition, ensuring the results were due to true quantum contextuality rather than experimental disturbance.

Discussion and Conclusion

The primary limitation of this work is the use of destructive measurements and repreparation. While this accurately emulates sequential measurement statistics, future tests could aim for non-destructive measurements on the same physical photon.

Nonetheless, "contextuality concentration" proves that moving from multipartite systems to indivisible high-dimensional systems makes contextuality more robust, providing more "quantumness" per dimension. This scalability suggests that using Clifford algebra and graph products could lead to even higher-dimensional systems and more extreme violations, opening new paths for robust quantum information processing.

Summary updated

Abstract

Contextuality is a distinctive feature of quantum theory and a fundamental resource for quantum computation. However, existing examples of contextuality in high-dimensional systems lack the necessary robustness required in experiments. Here we address this problem by identifying a family of noncontextuality inequalities whose maximum quantum violation grows with the dimension of the system. At first glance, this contextuality is the single-system version of multipartite Bell nonlocality taken to an extreme form. What is interesting is that the single-system version achieves the same degree of contextuality but uses a Hilbert space of lower dimension. That is, contextuality ``concentrates'' as the degree of contextuality per dimension increases. We show the practicality of this result by presenting an experimental test of contextuality in a seven-dimensional system. By simulating sequences of quantum ideal measurements with destructive measurements and repreparation in an all-optical setup, we report a violation of 68.7 standard deviations of the simplest case of the noncontextuality inequalities identified. Our results advance the investigation of high-dimensional contextuality, its connection to the Clifford algebra, and its role in quantum computation.
BibTeX
@misc{liu2022experimental,
  author = {Zhenghao Liu and Hui-Xian Meng and Zhen‐Peng Xu and Jie Zhou and Jing‐Ling Chen and Jin‐Shi Xu and Chuan‐Feng Li and Guang‐Can Guo and Adán Cabello},
  title = {{Experimental test of high-dimensional quantum contextuality based on contextuality concentration}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2209.02808},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2209.02808},
}
Figure