Experimental Study on Sweep Characteristics of Gas Gravity Drainage in the Interlayer Oil Reservoir

Hongwei Yu, Lu Wang, Daiyu Zhou, Fuyong Wang, Shi Li, Jun Li, Xinglong Chen, An Cao, Haishui HanFrontiers in Energy Research 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Stable gas gravity drainage (GGD) is an effective enhanced oil recovery (EOR) method for deep, thick reservoirs with large dip angles. However, reservoir heterogeneity—specifically the presence of interlayers—significantly impacts the stability of the gas-oil interface and overall sweep efficiency. This study utilizes 2D visual physical models to simulate GGD in the Donghe carboniferous oil reservoirs of the Tarim Basin. By employing high-speed cameras, researchers visualized the miscible zone between hydrocarbon gas and oil for the first time. Findings indicate that interlayers exert a shielding effect that traps oil and disrupts interface stability, though optimized injection rates and well placements can mitigate these effects, achieving recovery factors as high as 94%.

Introduction

Low-permeability reservoirs constitute nearly half of China's petroleum resources. Traditional water flooding often fails in these environments due to poor rock properties and complex geological structures. Gas gravity drainage (GGD), which involves injecting gas at the reservoir's crest to displace oil downward, offers a promising alternative for thick, tilted formations.

Real-world reservoirs are rarely homogeneous; they often contain interlayers—low-permeability barriers—and fractures that can cause gas to "channel" or bypass oil. Understanding how these features influence the gas-oil interface is critical for designing effective development schemes. This research seeks to quantify the impact of these geological barriers on sweep characteristics and final oil recovery.

Experimental Methodology

To investigate these dynamics, the researchers developed a series of 2D visual physical models based on the Donghe 1CIII reservoir parameters. The models featured a matrix permeability of 68.1 mD, an average porosity of 15.1%, and a pore throat radius of 60 nm. The oil phase was a synthetic mixture designed to replicate reservoir conditions (140°C, 45 MPa).

Design diagrams of the 2D visual physical models showing various well placements and interlayer configurations.

Four distinct model types were tested: homogeneous (control), dual interlayer, triple interlayer, and dual vertical fracture models. The experiments compared miscible drainage (using hydrocarbon gas) and immiscible drainage (using nitrogen) across varying injection pressures and rates. A high-speed camera captured the real-time movement of the gas-oil interface and the formation of the miscible zone.

Key Insights and Ideas

The Shielding Effect of Interlayers

Interlayers act as physical barriers that "shield" portions of the reservoir. They disrupt the stability of the gas-oil interface and the miscible zone, forcing injected gas to flow around them. This results in significant volumes of "remaining oil" trapped directly above or adjacent to the interlayers, which would otherwise be recovered in a homogeneous system.

Visualization of the Miscible Zone

A major contribution of this study is the first-ever visual recording of a miscible zone in a 2D physical model of this scale. In this zone, gas and oil blend into a single phase, effectively eliminating the capillary forces that typically trap oil within the rock's pores. Maintaining the stability of this zone is paramount for maximizing recovery.

Fracture Risks and Channeling

While fractures can facilitate flow, vertical fractures in a GGD context often lead to early gas breakthrough. This "channeling" allows the gas to reach production wells prematurely, leaving the vast majority of the oil in the surrounding rock matrix untouched.

Results and Discussion

The experimental results highlight the high potential of miscible GGD when properly managed:

  • Recovery Efficiency: Miscible hydrocarbon gas drainage in the dual interlayer model achieved an ultimate recovery factor of 94.16%.
  • Injection Rate Optimization: For immiscible drainage, a "critical rate" exists. In the dual vertical fracture model, increasing the nitrogen injection rate from 0.01 to 2 cm³/min caused the recovery factor to drop from 71.22% to 66.86% due to accelerated gas breakthrough.
  • Well Placement Impact: Strategic well positioning can overcome interlayer shielding. By moving production wells from intermediate positions to the bottom of the model, the swept area in the triple interlayer model increased by 40.4%, reaching a total sweep efficiency of 95.6%.
  • Pressure Stability: Higher displacement pressures were found to stabilize the gas-oil front, delaying breakthrough and enhancing overall recovery.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that while interlayers and fractures present significant challenges to gas gravity drainage, they are not insurmountable. The visualization of the miscible zone provides a new baseline for understanding gas-oil interactions in heterogeneous media. Future work should focus on the application of these findings to 3D volumetric models and explore the potential of CO2 injection, which could offer the dual benefit of enhanced oil recovery and carbon sequestration. For reservoir engineers, the key takeaway is the necessity of optimizing injection rates and well configurations to manage the shielding effects of geological heterogeneities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Stable gas gravity drainage is considered an effective method to enhance oil recovery, especially suitable for deep buried, large dip angle, and thick oil reservoirs. The influence of reservoir heterogeneity on controlling the gas–oil interface and sweep characteristics of injected gas is particularly important to design reservoir development schemes. In this study, according to the interlayer characteristics of Donghe carboniferous oil reservoirs in the Tarim Basin, NW China, 2D visual physical models are established, in which the matrix permeability is 68.1 mD and average pore throat radius is 60 nm. Then, hydrocarbon gas gravity drainage simulation experiments are carried out systematically, and a high-speed camera is used to record the process of gas–oil flow and interface movement. In this experiment, the miscible zone of crude oil and hydrocarbon gas is observed for the first time. The interlayer has an obvious shielding influence, which can destroy the stability of the gas–oil interface and miscible zone, change the movement direction of the gas–oil interface, and reduce the final oil recovery after gravity drainage. The remaining oil mainly is distributed near the interlayers. The higher displacement pressure leads to increased stability of the gas–oil displacement front and later gas breakthrough, which leads to higher oil recovery. The lower gas injection rate contributes to a slower front velocity and wider miscible zone, which could delay gas breakthrough. For the immiscible gas gravity drainage, there is a critical gas injection rate, with which the oil recovery factor is the highest.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yu2021experimental,
  author = {Hongwei Yu and Lu Wang and Daiyu Zhou and Fuyong Wang and Shi Li and Jun Li and Xinglong Chen and An Cao and Haishui Han},
  title = {{Experimental Study on Sweep Characteristics of Gas Gravity Drainage in the Interlayer Oil Reservoir}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2021.760315},
}
Figure