Experimental Study on Flexural Capacity of Reinforced Concrete Beam after Collision

Guanghui Wang, Xiaoyan Liu, Cheng-Long Wei, Zhenhao Zhang, Weiwei WangJournal of Engineering Science and Technology Review 2017 · DOI

Abstract

The residual load-bearing capacity of a reinforced concrete (RC) beam with collision damage was studied based on the loading test and theoretical analysis of the damaged beam to determine whether the damaged RC beam bridge after truck collision, could continue to be used and reveal the mechanical properties of the damaged beam. First, an experiment was conducted on the RC beam after truck collision to obtain material parameters. The nonlinear finite element models of two experimental beams were then corrected according to experimental results, based on which the experimental schemes of the damaged beam were designed and its loading test was performed. Finally, according to the experimental and finite element calculation results, the concept of damage coefficient was adopted and the calculation methods for the flexural capacity of the damaged beam were proposed. Research results indicate that the normal section failure at the midspan of the damaged RC beam arises from the edge position of the damaged region. The upper concrete on the section of the damaged part is crushed under the failure. The normal section bearing capacity of the damaged beam is slightly lower than that of the undamaged beam. The short-term flexural capacity of the damaged beam can be determined by the 5% decreasing bearing capacity of the undamaged beam only when the concrete in the tensile region is damaged after collision. The bearing capacities of the damage beam may be determined by the calculation formula for rebar damage when they are cracked. This research provides the theoretical and experimental foundations for the evaluation of the technical state of the RC bridges after collision.

Introduction

In many regions, current safety standards regarding bridge collisions are extremely conservative. Often, any bridge beam struck by an over-height vehicle is automatically classified as "Class V" (dangerous), necessitating immediate demolition and reconstruction. This practice can lead to significant economic waste if the beam still retains substantial structural integrity. This study addresses the need for a more nuanced understanding of residual load-bearing capacity, specifically investigating how much capacity is lost and whether it can be calculated without destructive testing.

Methodology

The researchers adopted a practical approach by salvaging two 13-meter-long RC I-beams from a flyover in Yueyang, China, which had been damaged by an excavator strike.

Visual evidence of collision damage on a salvaged RC I-beam, showing concrete spalling and exposed reinforcement.

One seriously damaged beam and one relatively undamaged beam were transported to a laboratory for comprehensive testing. The team utilized ultrasonic-rebound methods to map concrete strength and rebar scanners to locate internal steel. A multi-stage loading test was then performed, pushing both beams to total structural failure. To capture precise mechanical behavior, the beams were equipped with 18 deflection measuring points and 76 strain gauges. Furthermore, nonlinear finite element models (FEA) were developed and calibrated using the experimental data to simulate various damage scenarios, ranging from 0% to 70% concrete loss.

Key Insights and Results

The study revealed a critical distinction between structural stiffness and ultimate strength. While collision damage significantly reduces initial stiffness—causing the damaged beam to enter a permanent "plastic" deformation state almost immediately—the ultimate bending capacity remained remarkably resilient.

The Resilience of the Tension Zone

Concrete is inherently weak in tension, which is why steel reinforcement is placed at the bottom of beams. The experimental results showed that even with severe concrete spalling at the bottom (the tension zone), the ultimate capacity only decreased by approximately 2-3%, provided the internal rebar remained intact. Based on this, the authors propose a "5% Rule": if damage is confined to the tensile concrete, engineers can safely estimate residual capacity as 95% of the original design.

The Danger Zone

Structural integrity is most at risk when damage reaches the top of the beam (the compression zone). If the upper concrete is crushed or if the overall damage degree exceeds 0.6, the load-bearing capacity can drop by 14% or more very rapidly.

Validation

The damaged beam failed at 430 kN, compared to 440 kN for the undamaged beam—a negligible 2.3% difference. The researchers proposed a new calculation formula incorporating a rebar damage coefficient ($D_s$). When validated against FEA results, the formula maintained an error rate under 3%, suggesting it is a reliable tool for field assessments.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that many RC beams struck by vehicles may still possess sufficient flexural capacity for continued use. However, the study focused primarily on midspan collisions. Future work is required to investigate collisions near supports, which may trigger shear failure rather than flexural failure, and to evaluate the long-term serviceability (vibration and cracking) of repaired beams under daily traffic loads.

Summary updated

Abstract

The residual load-bearing capacity of a reinforced concrete (RC) beam with collision damage was studied based on the loading test and theoretical analysis of the damaged beam to determine whether the damaged RC beam bridge after truck collision, could continue to be used and reveal the mechanical properties of the damaged beam. First, an experiment was conducted on the RC beam after truck collision to obtain material parameters. The nonlinear finite element models of two experimental beams were then corrected according to experimental results, based on which the experimental schemes of the damaged beam were designed and its loading test was performed. Finally, according to the experimental and finite element calculation results, the concept of damage coefficient was adopted and the calculation methods for the flexural capacity of the damaged beam were proposed. Research results indicate that the normal section failure at the midspan of the damaged RC beam arises from the edge position of the damaged region. The upper concrete on the section of the damaged part is crushed under the failure. The normal section bearing capacity of the damaged beam is slightly lower than that of the undamaged beam. The short-term flexural capacity of the damaged beam can be determined by the 5% decreasing bearing capacity of the undamaged beam only when the concrete in the tensile region is damaged after collision. The bearing capacities of the damage beam may be determined by the calculation formula for rebar damage when they are cracked. This research provides the theoretical and experimental foundations for the evaluation of the technical state of the RC bridges after collision.
BibTeX
@article{wang2017experimental,
  author = {Guanghui Wang and Xiaoyan Liu and Cheng-Long Wei and Zhenhao Zhang and Weiwei Wang},
  title = {{Experimental Study on Flexural Capacity of Reinforced Concrete Beam after Collision}},
  journal = {Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.25103/jestr.101.16},
}
Figure