Experimental Study on Damage Effect of Mid-Infrared Pulsed Laser on Charge Coupled Device (CCD) and HgCgTe Detectors

Yang Liu, Feng Zhou, Yunzhe Wang, Yin Zhang, Yunfeng Zhang, Hanyu Zheng, Junfeng Shao2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the damage mechanisms of mid-infrared (MIR) pulsed lasers on Charge Coupled Devices (CCDs) and HgCdTe detectors, which are crucial components in imaging systems. The study establishes damage thresholds and reveals that thermal effects are the primary cause of damage, with out-of-band lasers proving more damaging than in-band lasers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Photodetectors are vulnerable to laser damage, especially when exposed to lasers significantly stronger than their normal operating signals. While research has explored damage from in-band lasers (where absorption is high) and some out-of-band lasers, there's a notable gap in understanding the specific damage mechanisms and thresholds of mid-infrared (MIR) pulsed lasers on CCDs and HgCdTe detectors. These MIR lasers are increasingly used in applications like lidar and atmospheric analysis, making their potential impact on sensitive detectors a critical concern for system design and protection.

Methods

The researchers conducted experimental damage studies using a 3.8 µm mid-infrared pulsed laser. They employed a high-energy DF laser as the primary light source and utilized a sophisticated experimental platform that included a mid-IR beam expander, power meters, and attenuators. For spot size measurement, they used a second-order moment theory and image analysis of the laser spot. Damage thresholds were determined by observing the onset of point damage, line damage, and complete detector failure under controlled laser energy densities. Theoretical models for thermal conduction in CCDs and HgCdTe detectors were also used to complement the experimental findings.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental measurements rather than pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Thermal Damage Dominance: The primary mechanism for MIR pulsed laser damage to both CCDs and HgCdTe detectors is thermal. The laser energy is absorbed, leading to localized heating and subsequent material degradation.
  • Out-of-Band Threat: Out-of-band MIR lasers, despite having lower absorption coefficients, can cause significant damage. The study found that the damage thresholds for out-of-band lasers were approximately double those of in-band lasers.
  • HgCdTe vs. CCD Vulnerability: HgCdTe detectors exhibited lower damage thresholds (0.41-0.95 J/cm²) compared to CCDs (0.88-1.89 J/cm²), indicating they are more susceptible to MIR laser damage.
  • Damage Progression: For both detector types, damage progresses through distinct stages: point damage, followed by line damage, and finally complete failure. This progression is linked to increasing laser energy density.
  • Microlens as a Weak Point: In CCDs, the microlens layer, with its lower melting point, is often the first component to incur damage, leading to a shift in the focal point and subsequent damage to underlying layers.

Key Results

  • Damage Thresholds:
    • HgCdTe detectors: Point damage at 0.412 J/cm², line damage at 0.551 J/cm², and complete damage at 0.953 J/cm².
  • CCDs: Point damage at 0.883 J/cm², line damage at 1.019 J/cm², and complete damage at 1.892 J/cm².
  • Damage Morphology: Observed damage included melting, cracking, and short-circuiting in CCDs, and ablation and melting in HgCdTe detectors.
  • Transmittance: The packaging glass of CCDs showed significant transmittance for the 3.8 µm laser, indicating that the damage originates from the detector chip itself, not the protective glass.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Wavelength Range: The experiments focused on a single MIR wavelength (3.8 µm). Further research could explore a broader range of MIR wavelengths to understand spectral dependencies.
  • Pulse Width: The study used a specific pulse width (135 ns). Investigating the effect of different pulse widths (e.g., picosecond or nanosecond) on damage mechanisms and thresholds would be valuable.
  • Repetitive Pulsing: The experiments were conducted in a 1-on-1 mode (single pulse). The effects of repetitive laser pulsing, which is common in many applications, on detector damage were not explored.
  • Theoretical Model Refinement: While theoretical models were used, further refinement and validation with a wider range of experimental data could improve predictive capabilities.
  • Laser Protection Strategies: The findings provide a basis for developing effective laser protection strategies for these detectors, which could be a focus for future work.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{liu2024experimental,
  author = {Yang Liu and Feng Zhou and Yunzhe Wang and Yin Zhang and Yunfeng Zhang and Hanyu Zheng and Junfeng Shao},
  title = {{Experimental Study on Damage Effect of Mid-Infrared Pulsed Laser on Charge Coupled Device (CCD) and HgCgTe Detectors}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/s24134380},
}

Loading related content...

Figure