Experimental muscle pain reduces initial motor unit discharge rates during sustained submaximal contractions

Dario Farina, Lars Arendt‐Nielsen, Thomas Graven‐NielsenJournal of Applied Physiology 2004 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that experimentally induced muscle pain alters motor control strategies during sustained contractions. Specifically, pain reduces the initial firing rate of motor units and dampens the typical decline in firing rate over time, suggesting a role for nociceptive afferents in modulating motor output.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Sustained submaximal muscle contractions are known to cause a decrease in motor unit discharge rates over time. The underlying mechanisms for this phenomenon are not fully understood, but two main hypotheses involve reflex mechanisms: reduced activity of muscle spindles and inhibitory effects from group III and IV muscle afferents. Since a significant portion of these afferents are nociceptive (pain-sensing), and experimental muscle pain can activate them, this study investigates whether induced muscle pain influences the temporal modulation of motor unit discharge rates during sustained contractions. The key question is whether pain itself alters the way motor units adjust their firing patterns over time, independent of other fatigue-related mechanisms.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of intramuscular and surface electromyography (EMG) to record motor unit activity from the tibialis anterior muscle in 11 healthy volunteers. Participants performed 4-minute isometric contractions at 25% of their maximal voluntary contraction (MVC) torque. To induce experimental pain, hypertonic saline was injected into the tibialis anterior of one leg (painful condition), while isotonic saline was injected into the other leg (control condition). This within-subject design allowed for direct comparison.

Key techniques included:

  • Intramuscular EMG: Using fine wire electrodes to record individual motor unit action potentials.
  • Multichannel Surface EMG: Employing a linear array of electrodes to capture the propagation of action potentials across the muscle surface.
  • Signal Decomposition: A sophisticated algorithm was used to identify and isolate individual motor unit firing patterns from the intramuscular EMG signals.
  • Spike-Triggered Averaging: Surface EMG signals were averaged based on the timing of identified motor unit action potentials to assess surface action potential properties.
  • Conduction Velocity Estimation: A multichannel technique was used to estimate the speed at which action potentials travel along muscle fibers.
  • Visual Analog Scale (VAS): Subjects rated their pain intensity over time.

The study analyzed motor unit discharge rate and conduction velocity at specific time intervals throughout the 4-minute contractions. Statistical analysis involved mixed-model ANOVAs to account for repeated measures (injection type, time) and between-group factors (leg side).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized data collected directly from human participants during experimental procedures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pain as a Modulator of Motor Control: The most significant insight is that experimentally induced muscle pain directly alters motor control strategies during sustained contractions. It's not just a passive sensation; it actively influences how the nervous system recruits and fires motor units.
  • Dampened Temporal Decline: The typical decrease in motor unit firing rate observed during sustained contractions was less pronounced when the muscle was painful. This suggests that nociceptive input might interfere with or modulate the physiological mechanisms responsible for this decline.
  • Reduced Initial Firing Rate: Pain led to a lower initial discharge rate of motor units at the onset of contraction, indicating an immediate inhibitory effect.
  • Preserved Conduction Velocity: Crucially, muscle pain did not affect motor unit conduction velocity or other surface action potential properties. This implies that the pain-induced changes are primarily at the level of neural control (motoneuron excitability) rather than directly altering the electrical properties of the muscle fibers themselves.

Key Results

  • Pain Intensity: Hypertonic saline reliably induced higher VAS scores than isotonic saline, confirming the effectiveness of the pain stimulus. Pain intensity remained stable for the first 150 seconds of contraction before slightly decreasing.
  • Torque Production: Exerted torque and its variability were unaffected by the presence of pain, indicating that subjects could maintain the target force output despite the altered motor unit firing patterns.
  • Motor Unit Discharge Rate:
    • The initial discharge rate was lower in the painful condition (right leg: 10.6 ± 0.2 pps) compared to the non-painful condition (right leg: 11.3 ± 0.2 pps; P < 0.01).
  • The decrease in discharge rate over the 4-minute contraction was smaller in the painful condition (0.4 ± 0.1 pps) compared to the non-painful condition (1.3 ± 0.1 pps).
  • Conduction Velocity: Motor unit conduction velocity and its decrease over time were not significantly different between painful and non-painful contractions. Initial values were around 4.0-4.1 m/s, with a decrease of about 0.6-0.7 m/s over 4 minutes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Pain Intensity: The study used a moderate level of pain. It's unclear if higher pain intensities would produce more pronounced effects or different patterns.
  • Specific Muscle Group: The findings are specific to the tibialis anterior muscle. Further research could explore if these effects generalize to other muscle groups.
  • Superficial Motor Units: The study focused on motor units accessible via the employed techniques, which might favor more superficial units.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future research should investigate other mechanisms that could contribute to maintaining constant force despite altered firing rates, such as changes in synergistic-antagonist muscle activity, recruitment of additional motor units, or short-term synchronization. They also highlight the need to explore how changes in muscle stiffness might play a role. The findings indirectly support the idea that the maintenance of constant force during sustained activation, even with declining discharge rates, is not solely mediated by changes in muscle fiber electrical membrane properties.

Summary updated

Abstract

The aim of this human study was to investigate the effect of experimentally induced muscle pain on the modifications of motor unit discharge rate during sustained, constant-force contractions. Intramuscular and multichannel surface electromyographic (EMG) signals were collected from the right and left tibialis anterior muscle of 11 volunteers. The subjects performed two 4-min-long isometric contractions at 25% of the maximal dorsiflexion torque, separated by a 20-min rest. Before the beginning of the second contraction, hypertonic (painful; right leg) or isotonic (nonpainful; left leg) saline was injected into the tibialis anterior. Pain intensity scores did not change significantly in the first 150 s of the painful contraction. Exerted torque and its coefficient of variation were the same for the painful and nonpainful contractions. Motor unit discharge rate was higher in the beginning of the nonpainful contraction than the painful contraction on the right side [means +/- SE, 11.3 +/- 0.2 vs. 10.6 +/- 0.2 pulses/s (pps); P < 0.01] whereas it was the same for the two contractions on the left side (11.6 +/- 0.2 vs. 11.5 +/- 0.2 pps). The decrease in discharge rate in 4 min was smaller for the painful (0.4 +/- 0.1 pps) than for the control contractions (1.3 +/- 0.1 pps). Initial value and decrease in motor unit conduction velocity were not different in the four contractions (right leg, 4.0 +/- 0.1 m/s with decrease of 0.6 +/- 0.1 m/s in 4 min; left leg, 4.1 +/- 0.1 m/s with 0.7 +/- 0.1 m/s decrease). In conclusion, stimulation of nociceptive afferents by injection of hypertonic saline did not alter motor unit conduction velocity but reduced the initial motor unit discharge rates and the difference between initial and final discharge rates during sustained contraction.
BibTeX
@article{farina2004experimental,
  author = {Dario Farina and Lars Arendt‐Nielsen and Thomas Graven‐Nielsen},
  title = {{Experimental muscle pain reduces initial motor unit discharge rates during sustained submaximal contractions}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Physiology},
  year = {2004},
  doi = {10.1152/japplphysiol.01059.2004},
}
Figure