Experimental muscle pain increases variability of neural drive to muscle and decreases motor unit coherence in tremor frequency band

Utku Ş. Yavuz, Francesco Negro, Deborah Falla, Dario FarinaJournal of Neurophysiology 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that experimental muscle pain amplifies physiological tremor by increasing variability in the neural drive to muscles within the tremor frequency band (5-13 Hz). It also shows that pain reduces the coordination (coherence) between motor units in this band, suggesting a shift towards more independent neural inputs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While it's known that muscle pain affects force control and low-frequency neural signals, the precise impact of pain on higher-frequency neural drive and motor unit coordination remains less understood. Specifically, how pain influences the neural signals associated with physiological tremor (around 5-13 Hz, the alpha band) and descending cortical input (15-30 Hz, the beta band) was unclear. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating how experimental muscle pain alters the variability and coordination of neural signals controlling muscle force at these higher frequencies.

Methods

The researchers reanalyzed data from two previous studies involving intramuscular recordings of single motor unit activity from the abductor digiti minimi (ADM) and tibialis anterior (TA) muscles. Participants performed isometric contractions at low force levels (10% MVC for ADM, 25% MVC for TA) under three conditions: baseline (no pain), after an injection of isotonic saline (control), and after an injection of hypertonic saline (inducing experimental muscle pain).

Key techniques included:

  • Intramuscular EMG recording: Sterilized wire electrodes were inserted into the muscles to record individual motor unit action potentials.
  • Force recording: Isometric force was measured using load cells and torque transducers.
  • Composite Spike Train (CST): Individual motor unit spike trains were combined to create a representation of the overall neural drive to the muscle.
  • Power Spectral Density (PSD): Used to analyze the frequency content of both the force signal and the CST, identifying oscillations at different frequencies.
  • Coherence Analysis: A statistical method to quantify the degree of linear correlation between the neural activity of different motor units across specific frequency bands. This helps understand how synchronized or coordinated their inputs are.
  • Statistical Analysis: Repeated-measures ANOVA and Tukey's HSD post hoc tests were used to compare differences between conditions and frequency bands.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from 23 healthy subjects (9 for ADM, 7 for TA in the analyzed segments) in two previously conducted experimental sessions. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pain amplifies tremor: Muscle pain significantly increases the power of neural drive oscillations in the alpha band (5-13 Hz), which directly corresponds to physiological tremor. This suggests pain disrupts the precise control mechanisms that normally dampen these oscillations.
  • Coherence breakdown: Pain leads to a decrease in motor unit coherence in the alpha band. This is a crucial finding: it implies that while the overall neural drive in this band becomes more variable, the individual motor units are becoming less coordinated in their response to common inputs.
  • Independent inputs rise: The decrease in coherence, coupled with increased power in the neural drive, suggests that pain might be increasing the influence of independent, or "noisy," neural inputs to motor neurons, rather than just amplifying common inputs.
  • Beta band unaffected: Interestingly, the beta band (15-30 Hz), thought to be related to descending cortical signals, was not significantly affected by experimental muscle pain in terms of neural drive power or motor unit coherence. This suggests pain's influence is more localized to afferent feedback pathways involved in tremor.

Key Results

  • Force Variability: The standard deviation of the force signal was significantly greater in the hypertonic saline condition for both ADM and TA muscles (P < 0.01).
  • Neural Drive (CST) Power: The relative power of the neural drive (CST) was significantly higher in the hypertonic condition in the delta band (2-4 Hz) and the alpha band (5-13 Hz) for both muscles (P < 0.05).
  • Motor Unit Coherence: Coherence strength was significantly lower in the hypertonic saline condition in the alpha band (6-10 Hz) for both muscles (P < 0.05). For the ADM muscle, coherence was also lower in the beta band (14-18 Hz) (P < 0.05).
  • Integral Coherence: The integral of the coherence function across the full bandwidth (2-50 Hz) was lower in the hypertonic condition for both muscles (P < 0.05), indicating reduced overall short-term synchronization.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Pain: The study used experimental muscle pain induced by saline injections, which may not perfectly replicate the complexity of chronic or pathological pain conditions.
  • Submaximal Contractions: The experiments were conducted at low force levels. The effects of pain on neural control during higher force contractions or more complex motor tasks remain to be explored.
  • ADM vs. TA: While general trends were consistent, some specific effects (e.g., beta band coherence) were more pronounced in the ADM muscle compared to the TA. Further investigation into muscle-specific differences in pain modulation could be valuable.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future work could explore the role of specific afferent pathways (e.g., muscle spindles) in mediating these pain-induced changes. Investigating how these findings translate to clinical populations with chronic pain conditions would also be a significant next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

It has been observed that muscle pain influences force variability and low-frequency (<3 Hz) oscillations in the neural drive to muscle. In this study, we aimed to investigate the effect of experimental muscle pain on the neural control of muscle force at higher frequency bands, associated with afferent feedback (alpha band, 5-13 Hz) and with descending cortical input (beta band, 15-30 Hz). Single-motor unit activity was recorded, in two separate experimental sessions, from the abductor digiti minimi (ADM) and tibialis anterior (TA) muscles with intramuscular wire electrodes, during isometric abductions of the fifth finger at 10% of maximal force [maximum voluntary contraction (MVC)] and ankle dorsiflexions at 25% MVC. The contractions were repeated under three conditions: no pain (baseline) and after intramuscular injection of isotonic (0.9%, control) and hypertonic (5.8%, painful) saline. The results showed an increase of the relative power of both the force signal and the neural drive at the tremor frequency band (alpha, 5-13 Hz) between the baseline and hypertonic (painful) conditions for both muscles (P < 0.05) but no effect on the beta band. Additionally, the strength of motor unit coherence was lower (P < 0.05) in the hypertonic condition in the alpha band for both muscles and in the beta band for the ADM. These results indicate that experimental muscle pain increases the amplitude of the tremor oscillations because of an increased variability of the neural control (common synaptic input) in the tremor band. Moreover, the concomitant decrease in coherence suggests an increase in independent input in the tremor band due to pain.
BibTeX
@article{yavuz2015experimental,
  author = {Utku Ş. Yavuz and Francesco Negro and Deborah Falla and Dario Farina},
  title = {{Experimental muscle pain increases variability of neural drive to muscle and decreases motor unit coherence in tremor frequency band}},
  journal = {Journal of Neurophysiology},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1152/jn.00391.2015},
}
Figure