TL;DR
This paper presents the first experimental constraints on "Weak Annihilation" (WA) contributions to a specific type of B meson decay ($b \to ul\nu$). These contributions, though theoretically predicted to be small, could introduce significant uncertainty into measurements of the fundamental CKM matrix element $|V_{ub}|$. The CLEO experiment has established an upper limit on the WA contribution, providing crucial validation for $|V_{ub}|$ measurements.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Precisely determining the magnitude of the CKM matrix element $|V_{ub}|$ is a high priority in particle physics. One of the primary methods for this determination involves studying inclusive semileptonic decays of B mesons, specifically $B \to Xul\nu$. While significant progress has been made through both experimental measurements and theoretical advancements, a persistent concern is the potential impact of a process called "Weak Annihilation" (WA).
WA is a theoretical contribution to these decays that arises from a four-quark operator. Crucially, WA is expected to be concentrated in the region of high momentum transfer ($q^2$) between the lepton-neutrino pair and the hadronic system. This kinematic region is precisely where experiments often focus to isolate $b \to u$ decays from the much larger $b \to c$ background. Therefore, even a small WA contribution could significantly bias inclusive $|V_{ub}|$ measurements, particularly those relying on high-$q^2$ regions or specific kinematic cuts. This paper aims to experimentally constrain the size of this WA contribution for the first time, thereby improving the reliability of $|V_{ub}|$ determinations.
Methods
The CLEO experiment utilized a large dataset of approximately 15.5 fb$^{-1}$ collected at the $\Upsilon(4S)$ resonance. The analysis focused on identifying semileptonic $B \to Xul\nu$ decays by reconstructing the four-momentum of the neutrino using a "missing momentum and missing energy" technique. This method leverages the near-hermeticity of the CLEO detectors to infer the neutrino's properties from the imbalance of energy and momentum in the event.
The core of the analysis involved fitting the reconstructed $q^2$ spectra of candidate $B \to Xul\nu$ events. These spectra were modeled as a sum of three components:
- $B \to Xclv$ background: This is the dominant background and is well-understood.
- Non-WA $B \to Xulv$: This represents the standard theoretical prediction for the $b \to u$ transition.
- Weak Annihilation (WA) $B \to Xulv$: This is the component of interest, modeled using a range of theoretical inputs that capture different kinematic possibilities for the WA process.
The analysis carefully accounted for various sources of background, including continuum $e^+e^- \to q\bar{q}$ events and misidentified leptons. The $q^2$ spectra were analyzed in different lepton-momentum bins to maximize sensitivity to the high-$q^2$ region where WA is expected to manifest. A $\chi^2$ fit was performed for each of 30 different WA models, allowing the rates of the $B \to Xclv$, non-WA $B \to Xulv$, and WA $B \to Xulv$ components to float independently.
Datasets
The primary dataset used in this analysis is approximately 15.5 fb$^{-1}$ of $e^+e^-$ collision data collected by the CLEO II, CLEO II.V, and CLEO III detectors at the Cornell Electron Storage Ring (CESR). This dataset was collected at the $\Upsilon(4S)$ resonance, which is ideal for studying B meson decays. Data collected just below the $\Upsilon(4S)$ threshold was used to estimate and subtract continuum background.
Key Insights and Ideas
- WA is a real concern for $|V_{ub}|$: The paper provides the first experimental evidence that WA contributions, while potentially small, are a significant factor to consider when determining $|V_{ub}|$ from inclusive measurements.
- High-$q^2$ region is sensitive to WA: The analysis highlights that the high-$q^2$ region of the $B \to Xul\nu$ decay spectrum is where WA effects are most pronounced and thus where experimental limits can be most effectively placed.
- Model dependence is crucial: The authors explored a range of theoretical models for WA, acknowledging that the precise kinematic manifestation of WA is not fully understood and depends on non-perturbative QCD effects. This approach allows for a more robust constraint by covering various theoretical possibilities.
- CLEO's capabilities were essential: The analysis relied heavily on the excellent hermeticity and particle identification capabilities of the CLEO detectors to accurately reconstruct the kinematics of semileptonic decays and infer the presence of a neutrino.
Key Results
The CLEO experiment set the following 90% confidence level upper limits on the WA contribution relative to the total $b \to u$ rate ($R_{WA} = \Gamma_{WA}/\Gamma_{b \to u}$):
- Full phase space: $R_{total} < 7.4\%$
- Endpoint region ($p_l > 2.2$ GeV/c): $R_{endpoint} < 15.5\%$
- Combined $q^2$ and $M_X$ regions: $R_{q^2M_X} < 14.5\%$ and $R_{M_X} < 8.6\%$
These limits translate to a constraint on the potential bias in $|V_{ub}|$ determinations, with the paper stating that the limits on a bias are half of these WA fraction values. This is a significant improvement over previous, more speculative estimates.
Limitations and Future Work
- Statistics-limited: The authors acknowledge that the results are statistics-limited, meaning that larger datasets would allow for even tighter constraints.
- Model dependence: While a range of WA models were explored, the precise nature of WA is still subject to theoretical uncertainties. Future theoretical work could refine these models.
- Future Work: The paper suggests that further studies of semileptonic decays in the charm sector and analyses of the moments of the B semileptonic $q^2$ distribution are needed to fully understand weak annihilation and its impact on $|V_{ub}|$. The authors also note that achieving a 5% precision goal for $|V_{ub}|$ will require such detailed understanding.
Summary updated