Experimental Limits on Weak Annihilation Contributions to<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi>b</mml:mi><mml:mo>→</mml:mo><mml:mi>u</mml:mi><mml:mi>l</mml:mi><mml:mi>ν</mml:mi></mml:math>Decays

J. L. Rosner, N. E. Adam, J. Alexander, K. Berkelman, D. G. Cassel, J. E. Duboscq, K. M. Ecklund, R. Ehrlich, L. Fields, L. Gibbons, R. Gray, S. W. Gray, D. L. Hartill, B. K. Heltsley, D. Hertz, C. D. Jones, J. Kandaswamy, D. L. Kreinick, В. Е. Кузнецов, H. Mahlke-Krüger, T. O. Meyer, P. U. E. Onyisi, T. Sanuki, D. Peterson, E. A. Phillips, J. Pivarski, D. Riley, A. Rýd, A. J. Sadoff, H. Schwarthoff, X. Shi, S. Stroiney, W. Sun, T. Wilksen, M. Weinberger, S. B. Athar, P. Avery, L. Breva-Newell, R. Patel, V. Potlia, H. Stoeck, J. Yelton, P. Rubin, C. Cawlfield, B. I. Eisenstein, I. Karliner, D. Kim, N. Lowrey, P. Naik, C. Sedlack, M. Selen, J. J. Thaler, E. J. White, J. Wiss, M. R. Shepherd, D. M. Asner, K. W. Edwards, D. Besson, T. K. Pedlar, D. Cronin-Hennessy, K. Y. Gao, D. T. Gong, J. Hietala, Y. Kubota, T. Klein, B. W. Lang, R. Poling, A. W. Scott, A. Smith, S. Dobbs, Z. Metreveli, K. K. Seth, A. Tomaradze, P. Zweber, J. Ernst, K. Arms, H. Severini, S. Dytman, W. A. Love, S. Mehrabyan, J. Mueller, V. Savinov, Z. Li, A. Lopez, H. Méndez, J. E. Ramirez Vargas, G. S. Huang, D. H. Miller, V. Pavlunin, B. Sanghi, I. P. J. Shipsey, G. S. Adams, Mark Anderson, J. P. Cummings, I. Dankó, J. Napolitano, Q. He, H. Muramatsu, C. S. Park, E. H. ThorndikePhysical 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the first experimental constraints on "Weak Annihilation" (WA) contributions to a specific type of B meson decay ($b \to ul\nu$). These contributions, though theoretically predicted to be small, could introduce significant uncertainty into measurements of the fundamental CKM matrix element $|V_{ub}|$. The CLEO experiment has established an upper limit on the WA contribution, providing crucial validation for $|V_{ub}|$ measurements.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Precisely determining the magnitude of the CKM matrix element $|V_{ub}|$ is a high priority in particle physics. One of the primary methods for this determination involves studying inclusive semileptonic decays of B mesons, specifically $B \to Xul\nu$. While significant progress has been made through both experimental measurements and theoretical advancements, a persistent concern is the potential impact of a process called "Weak Annihilation" (WA).

WA is a theoretical contribution to these decays that arises from a four-quark operator. Crucially, WA is expected to be concentrated in the region of high momentum transfer ($q^2$) between the lepton-neutrino pair and the hadronic system. This kinematic region is precisely where experiments often focus to isolate $b \to u$ decays from the much larger $b \to c$ background. Therefore, even a small WA contribution could significantly bias inclusive $|V_{ub}|$ measurements, particularly those relying on high-$q^2$ regions or specific kinematic cuts. This paper aims to experimentally constrain the size of this WA contribution for the first time, thereby improving the reliability of $|V_{ub}|$ determinations.

Methods

The CLEO experiment utilized a large dataset of approximately 15.5 fb$^{-1}$ collected at the $\Upsilon(4S)$ resonance. The analysis focused on identifying semileptonic $B \to Xul\nu$ decays by reconstructing the four-momentum of the neutrino using a "missing momentum and missing energy" technique. This method leverages the near-hermeticity of the CLEO detectors to infer the neutrino's properties from the imbalance of energy and momentum in the event.

The core of the analysis involved fitting the reconstructed $q^2$ spectra of candidate $B \to Xul\nu$ events. These spectra were modeled as a sum of three components:

  1. $B \to Xclv$ background: This is the dominant background and is well-understood.
  2. Non-WA $B \to Xulv$: This represents the standard theoretical prediction for the $b \to u$ transition.
  3. Weak Annihilation (WA) $B \to Xulv$: This is the component of interest, modeled using a range of theoretical inputs that capture different kinematic possibilities for the WA process.

The analysis carefully accounted for various sources of background, including continuum $e^+e^- \to q\bar{q}$ events and misidentified leptons. The $q^2$ spectra were analyzed in different lepton-momentum bins to maximize sensitivity to the high-$q^2$ region where WA is expected to manifest. A $\chi^2$ fit was performed for each of 30 different WA models, allowing the rates of the $B \to Xclv$, non-WA $B \to Xulv$, and WA $B \to Xulv$ components to float independently.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this analysis is approximately 15.5 fb$^{-1}$ of $e^+e^-$ collision data collected by the CLEO II, CLEO II.V, and CLEO III detectors at the Cornell Electron Storage Ring (CESR). This dataset was collected at the $\Upsilon(4S)$ resonance, which is ideal for studying B meson decays. Data collected just below the $\Upsilon(4S)$ threshold was used to estimate and subtract continuum background.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • WA is a real concern for $|V_{ub}|$: The paper provides the first experimental evidence that WA contributions, while potentially small, are a significant factor to consider when determining $|V_{ub}|$ from inclusive measurements.
  • High-$q^2$ region is sensitive to WA: The analysis highlights that the high-$q^2$ region of the $B \to Xul\nu$ decay spectrum is where WA effects are most pronounced and thus where experimental limits can be most effectively placed.
  • Model dependence is crucial: The authors explored a range of theoretical models for WA, acknowledging that the precise kinematic manifestation of WA is not fully understood and depends on non-perturbative QCD effects. This approach allows for a more robust constraint by covering various theoretical possibilities.
  • CLEO's capabilities were essential: The analysis relied heavily on the excellent hermeticity and particle identification capabilities of the CLEO detectors to accurately reconstruct the kinematics of semileptonic decays and infer the presence of a neutrino.

Key Results

The CLEO experiment set the following 90% confidence level upper limits on the WA contribution relative to the total $b \to u$ rate ($R_{WA} = \Gamma_{WA}/\Gamma_{b \to u}$):

  • Full phase space: $R_{total} < 7.4\%$
  • Endpoint region ($p_l > 2.2$ GeV/c): $R_{endpoint} < 15.5\%$
  • Combined $q^2$ and $M_X$ regions: $R_{q^2M_X} < 14.5\%$ and $R_{M_X} < 8.6\%$

These limits translate to a constraint on the potential bias in $|V_{ub}|$ determinations, with the paper stating that the limits on a bias are half of these WA fraction values. This is a significant improvement over previous, more speculative estimates.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Statistics-limited: The authors acknowledge that the results are statistics-limited, meaning that larger datasets would allow for even tighter constraints.
  • Model dependence: While a range of WA models were explored, the precise nature of WA is still subject to theoretical uncertainties. Future theoretical work could refine these models.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that further studies of semileptonic decays in the charm sector and analyses of the moments of the B semileptonic $q^2$ distribution are needed to fully understand weak annihilation and its impact on $|V_{ub}|$. The authors also note that achieving a 5% precision goal for $|V_{ub}|$ will require such detailed understanding.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present the first experimental limits on high-q2 contributions to charmless semileptonic decays of the form expected from the weak annihilation (WA) decay mechanism. Such contributions could bias determinations of /Vub/ from inclusive measurements of B-->Xulupsilon. Using a wide range of models based on available theoretical input we set a limit of GammaWA/Gammab-->u<7.4% (90% confidence level) on the WA fraction, and assess the impact on previous inclusive determinations of /Vub/.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rosner2006experimental,
  author = {J. L. Rosner and N. E. Adam and J. Alexander and K. Berkelman and D. G. Cassel and J. E. Duboscq and K. M. Ecklund and R. Ehrlich and L. Fields and L. Gibbons and R. Gray and S. W. Gray and D. L. Hartill and B. K. Heltsley and D. Hertz and C. D. Jones and J. Kandaswamy and D. L. Kreinick and В. Е. Кузнецов and H. Mahlke-Krüger and T. O. Meyer and P. U. E. Onyisi and T. Sanuki and D. Peterson and E. A. Phillips and J. Pivarski and D. Riley and A. Rýd and A. J. Sadoff and H. Schwarthoff and X. Shi and S. Stroiney and W. Sun and T. Wilksen and M. Weinberger and S. B. Athar and P. Avery and L. Breva-Newell and R. Patel and V. Potlia and H. Stoeck and J. Yelton and P. Rubin and C. Cawlfield and B. I. Eisenstein and I. Karliner and D. Kim and N. Lowrey and P. Naik and C. Sedlack and M. Selen and J. J. Thaler and E. J. White and J. Wiss and M. R. Shepherd and D. M. Asner and K. W. Edwards and D. Besson and T. K. Pedlar and D. Cronin-Hennessy and K. Y. Gao and D. T. Gong and J. Hietala and Y. Kubota and T. Klein and B. W. Lang and R. Poling and A. W. Scott and A. Smith and S. Dobbs and Z. Metreveli and K. K. Seth and A. Tomaradze and P. Zweber and J. Ernst and K. Arms and H. Severini and S. Dytman and W. A. Love and S. Mehrabyan and J. Mueller and V. Savinov and Z. Li and A. Lopez and H. Méndez and J. E. Ramirez Vargas and G. S. Huang and D. H. Miller and V. Pavlunin and B. Sanghi and I. P. J. Shipsey and G. S. Adams and Mark Anderson and J. P. Cummings and I. Dankó and J. Napolitano and Q. He and H. Muramatsu and C. S. Park and E. H. Thorndike},
  title = {{Experimental Limits on Weak Annihilation Contributions to<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mi>b</mml:mi><mml:mo>→</mml:mo><mml:mi>u</mml:mi><mml:mi>l</mml:mi><mml:mi>ν</mml:mi></mml:math>Decays}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.96.121801},
}
Figure