Experimental Investigation on the Detection of Multiple Surface Cracks Using Vibrothermography with a Low-Power Piezoceramic Actuator

Changhang Xu, Jing Xie, Wuyang Zhang, Qingzhao Kong, Guoming Chen, Gangbing SongSensors 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel approach to detecting multiple surface cracks in metal parts using vibrothermography with a low-power piezoceramic actuator. By demonstrating effective crack detection with significantly reduced power requirements and exploring key influencing factors, this work offers a safer, more convenient, and potentially more cost-effective NDT solution for industrial applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional vibrothermography, a non-destructive testing (NDT) technique that uses mechanical vibrations to generate localized heat at defects, often relies on high-power actuators. While effective, these high-power systems can be cumbersome, inconvenient to deploy, and may even introduce additional damage to the inspected object. Furthermore, most existing research has focused on detecting single cracks, particularly in composite materials. There's a clear need for a vibrothermography method that can reliably detect multiple surface cracks in metal parts using a more manageable, lower-power excitation source, thereby enhancing safety and practicality.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the experimental investigation of a vibrothermography system utilizing a low-power piezoceramic (PZT) transducer as the actuator. This PZT transducer is designed as a sandwiched structure, distributing ultrasonic power over a circular surface, which is presented as a safer and more unique approach compared to focused ultrasonic welding horns. The system comprises a signal generator, a power amplifier, the PZT transducer, an infrared camera, and a computer for data acquisition and analysis.

Key experimental aspects include:

  • Low-Power Excitation: The PZT transducer, driven by a signal generator and amplifier, can produce signals up to 2 MHz with a maximum amplitude of 150 V, translating to a power range of approximately 5-14 W, significantly lower than conventional methods.
  • Specimen: A thin aluminum beam (500 mm × 100 mm × 3 mm) with three surface cracks of varying orientations was used.
  • Data Acquisition: An infrared camera captured temperature variations at a frame rate of 30 Hz.
  • Experimental Variables: The study systematically investigated the influence of:
  • Excitation signal amplitude.
  • Specimen constraint conditions (e.g., rigidly fixed at both ends, partially fixed, fixed at one end).
  • Relative position of the PZT transducer (same side vs. opposite side of the cracks).
  • Data Processing: Discrete Fourier Transformation (DFT) was employed as an image processing technique to enhance crack features, particularly for low excitation amplitudes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments were conducted on a custom-prepared aluminum beam specimen with intentionally introduced cracks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Low-Power Viability: The most significant insight is that effective detection of multiple surface cracks in metal is achievable with a low-power piezoceramic actuator. This challenges the notion that high power is always necessary for vibrothermography.
  • Simultaneous Detection: The PZT actuator can generate sufficient heat to simultaneously reveal all three cracks, regardless of their orientation, simplifying the detection process.
  • Crack Orientation Insensitivity: The study found that the detection results were not significantly sensitive to the orientation of the cracks on the thin aluminum beam.
  • DFT for Enhancement: Discrete Fourier Transformation proved to be a powerful tool for enhancing crack features in thermograms, enabling detection even at very low excitation amplitudes (e.g., 60 V). This is crucial for making low-power systems practical.
  • Constraint is Key: The constraint condition of the specimen plays a critical role. Rigidly fixing the specimen at both ends was found to be essential for effective crack detection, likely by optimizing mechanical wave propagation and subsequent heat generation at the cracks.
  • Transducer Position Robustness: The PZT transducer's position (same side or opposite side of the cracks) did not hinder detection, suggesting robustness for practical applications.

Key Results

  • All three surface cracks (two vertical, one horizontal) on the aluminum beam were successfully detected using the low-power PZT actuator.
  • Effective detection was achieved with excitation amplitudes as low as 80 V, with crack visibility and thermal contrast increasing with higher amplitudes up to 150 V.
  • Even at a low excitation amplitude of 60 V, where raw thermograms showed no visible cracks, DFT processing successfully identified at least one crack and improved the indication of others.
  • The study demonstrated that rigidly fixing the specimen at both ends provided the best detection results, while partially fixed or single-end fixed conditions yielded poor detection.
  • The PZT transducer mounted on the opposite side of the cracks also successfully detected them, with some indications of even clearer crack boundaries.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Specimen Specificity: The research was conducted on a thin aluminum beam with specific crack dimensions. The applicability to thicker materials, different metals, or cracks with varied depths and widths needs further investigation.
  • Limited Crack Types: The study focused on surface cracks. The effectiveness for subsurface defects or other types of damage (e.g., delamination, impact damage) is not explored.
  • Quantitative Characterization: While qualitative detection was demonstrated, further work is needed to quantitatively characterize crack dimensions (depth, length) using this low-power method.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest combining this technique with numerical models and other advanced image processing methods to further improve its feasibility for detecting surface cracks with varied dimensions or subsurface cracks on metal parts. They also aim to explore more complex geometries and materials.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{xu2017experimental,
  author = {Changhang Xu and Jing Xie and Wuyang Zhang and Qingzhao Kong and Guoming Chen and Gangbing Song},
  title = {{Experimental Investigation on the Detection of Multiple Surface Cracks Using Vibrothermography with a Low-Power Piezoceramic Actuator}},
  journal = {Sensors},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/s17122705},
}
Figure