Experimental Investigation on the Characteristic Stress and Energy Evolution Law of Carbonaceous Shale: Effects of Dry–Wet Cycles, Confining Pressure, and Fissure Angle

Yu Li, Shengnan Li, Xianglong Liu, Aiguo Jiang, Dongge CuiProcesses 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study experimentally investigates how dry-wet cycles, confining pressure, and fissure angles affect the stress and energy behavior of carbonaceous shale. The findings reveal that increased confining pressure strengthens the shale, while dry-wet cycles degrade it. A specific fissure angle (45°) appears to be the most critical for failure, and a new energy-based indicator, Kcd, is proposed for predicting rock failure.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Carbonaceous shale, a common geological formation, is prone to softening and damage when exposed to alternating wet and dry conditions. This degradation poses significant challenges for engineering projects like tunnels and roadways, especially concerning stability and hazard prevention. While previous research has explored the effects of dry-wet cycles or confining pressure on rock mechanics, there's a need for a comprehensive understanding of how these factors, along with the presence of fissures, interact to influence the stress and energy evolution within the rock. This paper aims to fill that gap by systematically examining these coupled influences on carbonaceous shale.

Methods

The researchers conducted triaxial compression tests on carbonaceous shale samples. These samples were prepared with prefabricated fissures at various angles (0°, 30°, 45°, 60°, 90°) and subjected to different numbers of dry-wet cycles (0, 5, 10, 15) and confining pressures (0, 2, 4, 6 MPa). The dry-wet cycle involved soaking samples in water for 48 hours followed by drying at 105°C for 24 hours. The triaxial tests were performed using an MTS815 rock mechanics test system. The study then analyzed the characteristic stresses (closure, initiation, damage, and peak stress) and the energy evolution (total energy, elastic energy, and dissipated energy) at these characteristic stress points. A dissipated energy rate method was used to determine these characteristic stresses.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from the prepared carbonaceous shale samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Confining Pressure is a Stabilizer: Higher confining pressure significantly increases all characteristic stresses and energy storage capacities, effectively hindering crack initiation and propagation. This suggests that increasing confining pressure enhances the shale's ability to resist deformation and failure.
  • Dry-Wet Cycles are Destructive: Dry-wet cycles act as a primary driver of damage. They reduce characteristic stresses and energy storage, weakening the shale's capacity to absorb elastic strain energy and leading to progressive degradation.
  • Fissure Angle Dictates Anisotropy: The orientation of fissures plays a crucial role in the anisotropic damage of the rock. A 45° fissure angle appears to be the most critical, resulting in the lowest characteristic stresses and making the rock most susceptible to failure.
  • Energy Storage as an Early Warning: The ratio of elastic energy at damage stress to that at peak stress (Kcd) is proposed as a valuable early warning indicator for rock failure. A higher Kcd suggests a greater risk of failure.

Key Results

  • Confining Pressure Effects: As confining pressure increased from 0 to 6 MPa, closure stress, initiation stress, damage stress, and peak stress increased by 69.72%, 55.53%, 55.79%, and 41.35%, respectively. Total, elastic, and dissipated energies also showed a linear increase with confining pressure.
  • Dry-Wet Cycle Effects: After 15 dry-wet cycles, characteristic stresses reduced by up to 41.4%. Total, elastic, and dissipated energies also decreased significantly, indicating a weakened energy absorption and storage capacity.
  • Fissure Angle Effects: The characteristic stresses and energy indexes exhibited a "V"-shaped trend with increasing fissure angle, reaching their minimum at 45°. For instance, at 45°, total energy and elastic energy were at their lowest (68.86 kJ·m⁻³ and 59.06 kJ·m⁻³, respectively), indicating the highest proneness to failure.
  • Energy Evolution Stages: During deformation, elastic energy storage dominates in the early stages, while dissipated energy becomes more significant during accelerated crack propagation, indicating increased damage.
  • Kcd Indicator: Kcd generally decreased with increasing confining pressure, increased with dry-wet cycles, and showed a complex trend with fissure angle, peaking at 45°.

Limitations and Future Work

The study acknowledges that the anisotropic damage of rock is controlled by fissure angle, with the 45° angle being the most critical. The paper suggests that the energy storage level at damage stress (Kcd) can serve as an early warning indicator for rock failure. Future work could explore the application of this indicator in real-world engineering scenarios and investigate the long-term effects of combined environmental factors on carbonaceous shale stability. The paper also implies that understanding the energy distribution law before peak stress is crucial for revealing damage evolution characteristics and energy driving mechanisms.

Summary updated

Abstract

To investigate characteristic stress and energy evolution law of carbonaceous shale under dry–wet cycles and fissure angle, several samples with prefabricated fissure angles were prepared and subjected to the coupled influence of dry–wet cycles and loading. The results show that the closure stress, initiation stress, damage stress, and peak stress gradually increase with the increase in confining pressure, effectively suppressing the initiation and propagation of the crack. At the same time, the total energy, elastic energy, and dissipated energy at the crack characteristic stress are enhanced by a linear function relationship, significantly improving the bearing capacity and energy storage capacity of carbonaceous shale. The dry–wet cycle is regarded as the driving force of damage, reducing the crack characteristic stress and the total energy, elastic energy, and dissipated energy of crack characteristic stress. This results in a weakened capacity of the rock samples to store elastic strain energy, ultimately contributing to the damage degradation of carbonaceous shale. The anisotropic damage of rock is controlled by fissure angle. The crack characteristic stress and the total energy, elastic energy, and dissipated energy of crack characteristic stress with a 45° fissure angle is the smallest. Finally, the energy storage level at the damage stress (Kcd) can be used as an early warning indicator for rock failure.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2025experimental,
  author = {Yu Li and Shengnan Li and Xianglong Liu and Aiguo Jiang and Dongge Cui},
  title = {{Experimental Investigation on the Characteristic Stress and Energy Evolution Law of Carbonaceous Shale: Effects of Dry–Wet Cycles, Confining Pressure, and Fissure Angle}},
  booktitle = {Processes},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/pr13113399},
}
Figure