Experimental Investigation for the Phase Change Material Barrier Area Effect on the Thermal Runaway Propagation Prevention of Cell-to-Pack Batteries

Kai Shen, Jieyu Sun, Chengshan Xu, Shaw Kang Wong, Yuejiu Zheng, Changyong Jin, Huaibin Wang, Siqi Chen, Xuning FengBatteries 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the effectiveness of hydrogel-based thermal barriers in preventing thermal runaway propagation (TRP) in lithium-ion battery modules. By experimentally varying the area of the thermal barrier between cells, the researchers found that complete coverage is crucial for preventing TRP, while partial coverage only delays it.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) are ubiquitous in modern technology, but their high energy density also presents a significant safety risk: thermal runaway (TR). When one cell experiences TR, the intense heat and ejected materials can trigger a chain reaction, leading to thermal runaway propagation (TRP) throughout the battery pack. This cascading failure can result in fires and explosions. While thermal barriers are a promising solution, their optimal design, especially concerning their coverage area in complex operating environments, remains an open question. This study aims to address this by experimentally evaluating how different areas of a hydrogel-based thermal barrier affect TRP in a cell-to-pack battery configuration.

Methods

The researchers synthesized a hydrogel using sodium polyacrylate as the base material, combined with aramid fiber for structural support and an aluminum-plastic film for encapsulation. They then conducted a series of thermal runaway propagation tests on 153 Ah prismatic LIBs. The experimental setup involved triggering TR in the first cell using a ceramic heater and then observing the propagation to adjacent cells. Four experimental groups were established:

  • Test 1 (Control): No thermal barrier.
  • Test 2: Thermal barrier with an area of 108 × 78 mm (58.1% coverage).
  • Test 3: Thermal barrier with an area of 128 × 88 mm (77.2% coverage).
  • Test 4: Thermal barrier with an area of 148 × 98 mm (100% coverage).

Key parameters monitored included cell temperature (front and back surfaces), voltage, TR initiation time, propagation time, and TR behavior. They also performed DSC tests to characterize the hydrogel's phase change properties and a flame gun test to assess its thermal resistance.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments were conducted using custom-built experimental setups and commercial LIBs.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Area is Paramount: The most critical finding is that the area coverage of the thermal barrier is the deciding factor in preventing TRP. Even a small gap can allow propagation, albeit delayed.
  • Hydrogel's Dual Role: The hydrogel not only absorbs heat through its phase change but also appears to reduce the battery's temperature during normal charging/discharging cycles, suggesting a broader application beyond just TRP prevention.
  • Delayed but Not Prevented: Partial coverage thermal barriers (Tests 2 and 3) significantly prolonged the time to TRP and reduced the peak temperatures of the affected cells compared to the no-barrier case. However, they did not prevent TRP entirely.
  • TR Behavior Changes: The presence of a thermal barrier, even partial, altered the TR behavior, making it less violent and changing the propagation pattern from outward expansion to inward.

Key Results

  • No Barrier (Test 1): TRP occurred rapidly, with the second cell reaching TR at 484 seconds and a peak temperature of 812.3 °C.
  • Partial Barriers (Tests 2 & 3): TRP was significantly delayed. In Test 2, the second cell's triggered temperature was reduced by 207.6 °C compared to Test 1, and in Test 3, it was reduced by 295.2 °C. The propagation time was prolonged by hundreds of seconds.
  • Full Coverage Barrier (Test 4): The complete area coverage thermal barrier successfully prevented TRP. The temperature of the second cell only reached 145.4 °C due to the phase change of the hydrogel, and no propagation was observed.
  • Charging/Discharging: The thermal barrier also reduced the maximum battery temperature during a 100 A charging cycle from 41.3 °C (without barrier) to 36.1 °C (with barrier).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Battery Types: The study focused on prismatic LIBs. Further research could explore the effectiveness of these barriers on other battery form factors (e.g., cylindrical cells).
  • Operating Conditions: While the study mentions complex operating conditions, the experiments primarily focused on triggered TR. Investigating the barrier's performance under various abuse scenarios (e.g., overcharging, mechanical abuse) would be valuable.
  • Long-Term Durability: The long-term durability and performance degradation of the hydrogel barrier under repeated thermal cycling and aging were not assessed.
  • Scalability and Cost: The paper doesn't delve into the scalability and cost-effectiveness of producing and implementing these hydrogel barriers in large-scale battery packs.

Future work could involve optimizing the hydrogel composition for enhanced thermal properties, exploring different integration methods within battery modules, and conducting more extensive testing under realistic operating conditions and various abuse scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

Thermal runaway propagation (TRP) is a primary safety issue in lithium-ion battery (LIB) applications, and the use of a thermal barrier is considered to be a promising solution for TRP prevention. However, the operating conditions of the battery are extremely complicated, such as fast charging, low-temperature heating and thermal runaway. To date, there is no consistent answer as to how to choose the appropriate thermal barrier for such a complicated working environment. In this study, the characteristics of hydrogel based on sodium polyacrylate are explored, and the impact of thermal barrier area on TRP is investigated through experiments. Due to the prismatic battery structure, thermal barriers placed between cells are designed with different areas (148 × 98 mm, 128 × 88 mm, and 108 × 78 mm). The results indicate that test 1 without a placed thermal barrier quickly completes the TRP process, and the thermal runaway (TR) behavior is more violent. With a thermal barrier that does not have full area coverage placed between cells (test 2 and test 3), the propagation time is prolonged, but TRP still occurs. Compared with test 1, the triggered temperature of T2 F (the front surface of cell 2) is reduced by 207.6 °C and 295.2 °C, respectively. The complete area coverage thermal barrier successfully prevents TRP, and the T2 F of cell 2 only reaches 145.4 °C under the phase change by the hydrogel. This study may suggest a safety design for battery modules and prevent propagation among batteries.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shen2023experimental,
  author = {Kai Shen and Jieyu Sun and Chengshan Xu and Shaw Kang WONG and Yuejiu Zheng and Changyong Jin and Huaibin Wang and Siqi Chen and Xuning Feng},
  title = {{Experimental Investigation for the Phase Change Material Barrier Area Effect on the Thermal Runaway Propagation Prevention of Cell-to-Pack Batteries}},
  booktitle = {Batteries},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/batteries9040206},
}
Figure