Experimental Evidence of Momentum Transport Induced by an Up-Down Asymmetric Magnetic Equilibrium in Toroidal Plasmas

Y. Camenen, A. Bortolon, B.p. Duval, L. Federspiel, A. G. Peeters, F. J. Casson, W. A. Hornsby, A. Karpushov, Francesco Piras, O. Sauter, A. P. Snodin, G. SzepesiPhysical 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have experimentally demonstrated for the first time that the shape of a plasma's magnetic field, specifically its up-down asymmetry, can directly influence how momentum is transported within the plasma. This finding aligns with theoretical predictions and is crucial for understanding and controlling plasma rotation, a key factor in achieving stable fusion reactions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In magnetic fusion devices like tokamaks, controlling plasma rotation is vital. Sheared flows, driven by electric and magnetic fields, can stabilize the turbulent eddies that lead to energy and particle loss. This stabilization mechanism relies heavily on the transport of momentum. While it's understood that turbulent processes are responsible for much of this momentum transport, exceeding simple collisional (neoclassical) predictions, the precise mechanisms driving it, especially "spontaneous" or "intrinsic" rotation, have remained an active area of research. A significant challenge has been explaining how momentum can be transported across magnetic flux surfaces even in the absence of external forces. Theoretical work suggested that breaking the up-down symmetry of the magnetic equilibrium could create a "residual stress" – a turbulent momentum flux not directly proportional to the rotation gradient – that could drive intrinsic rotation. This paper addresses the critical need to experimentally verify this theoretical prediction.

Methods

The experiments were conducted in the Tokamak à Configuration Variable (TCV), a device capable of creating highly shaped plasmas. The researchers systematically varied the plasma's magnetic equilibrium by altering its shape (specifically, introducing up-down asymmetry), the direction of the toroidal magnetic field, and the direction of the plasma current. They then measured the resulting toroidal rotation profiles of carbon impurities using Charge Exchange Recombination Spectroscopy (CXRS). To isolate the effect of the up-down asymmetry, they compared configurations that were identical in all other respects. The experimental results were then compared against theoretical predictions derived from a gyrokinetic flux-tube code (GKW), which simulates turbulent transport.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on experimental measurements from the TCV tokamak and theoretical simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shape Matters: The up-down asymmetry of the magnetic equilibrium is a direct driver of parallel momentum transport. This is a significant finding, moving beyond simple symmetry assumptions.
  • Residual Stress Confirmed: The experiments provide the first direct evidence for the theoretically predicted "residual stress" mechanism, where turbulent momentum flux is generated even without a direct driving gradient.
  • Predictive Power: The observed changes in toroidal rotation gradient are in quantitative agreement with theoretical predictions across various combinations of plasma shape, magnetic field, and current directions.
  • Intrinsic Rotation Link: The findings strongly support the idea that turbulent momentum transport, particularly off-diagonal components like the residual stress, plays a crucial role in generating intrinsic plasma rotation.
  • Directionality is Key: The direction of the momentum flux (and thus its effect on rotation) is sensitive to the specific configuration of asymmetry, magnetic field, and current, as predicted by theory.

Key Results

The experiments showed that changing the up-down asymmetry of the magnetic equilibrium led to a variation in the central toroidal rotation by a factor of 1.5-2. Specifically, the toroidal rotation gradient in the outer part of the plasma was observed to depend on this asymmetry. The direction of this effect and its magnitude were found to be in agreement with theoretical predictions for all eight possible combinations of plasma asymmetry, current, and magnetic field direction. Linear simulations using the GKW code, while not capturing all nonlinear effects, reproduced the correct order of magnitude for the observed changes in rotation profiles.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the linear simulations do not fully capture nonlinear interactions and the effects of collisions and E×B shearing. They suggest that future work should address these aspects for a more complete quantitative comparison. While the experiments provide strong evidence for the up-down asymmetry effect, they also note that other mechanisms might contribute to the overall intrinsic rotation profile. Further nonlinear simulations are planned to investigate these complex interactions and provide a more comprehensive understanding of turbulent momentum transport in fusion plasmas.

Summary updated

Abstract

The first experimental evidence of parallel momentum transport generated by the up-down asymmetry of a toroidal plasma is reported. The experiments, conducted in the Tokamak à Configuration Variable, were motivated by the recent theoretical discovery of ion-scale turbulent momentum transport induced by an up-down asymmetry in the magnetic equilibrium. The toroidal rotation gradient is observed to depend on the asymmetry in the outer part of the plasma leading to a variation of the central rotation by a factor of 1.5-2. The direction of the effect and its magnitude are in agreement with theoretical predictions for the eight possible combinations of plasma asymmetry, current, and magnetic field.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{camenen2010experimental,
  author = {Y. Camenen and A. Bortolon and B.P. Duval and L. Federspiel and A. G. Peeters and F. J. Casson and W. A. Hornsby and A. Karpushov and Francesco Piras and O. Sauter and A. P. Snodin and G. Szepesi},
  title = {{Experimental Evidence of Momentum Transport Induced by an Up-Down Asymmetric Magnetic Equilibrium in Toroidal Plasmas}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.105.135003},
}
Figure