Experimental Evaluation of Flexural Strength and Ductility of One-Way Concrete Slab Panels Reinforced with Welded Wires and Deformed Bars

Mofid Mahdi, Faez Ahmed, Ifty Ahmed, N. Islam2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the structural trade-offs of using Welded Wire Reinforcement (WWR) versus traditional deformed steel bars in concrete slabs. While WWR offers significant construction speed and cost benefits, the research highlights a critical safety warning: locally produced 6 mm "Class A" WWR exhibits dangerously low ductility and catastrophic failure modes, whereas 8 mm "Class D" WWR performs comparably to standard rebar and is safe for structural use.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In rapidly developing regions like Bangladesh, engineers are looking for ways to reduce construction time and labor costs. Welded Wire Reinforcement (WWR)—pre-manufactured grids of high-strength steel—is an attractive alternative to traditional rebar because it eliminates the need for manual cutting and tying.

However, WWR comes with a "ductility tax." The cold-drawing process used to manufacture the wires, combined with the heat from the welding process (which creates "metallurgical notches"), can make the steel brittle. This leads to a phenomenon called strain localization, where plastic deformation is confined to a tiny area near a crack rather than being distributed along the bar. If the reinforcement isn't ductile enough, a slab might fail suddenly and catastrophically without the warning signs (like large deflections) that engineers rely on. This paper specifically evaluates whether locally available WWR in Bangladesh meets international safety standards (ASTM A1064) for flexural strength and ductility.

Methods

The researchers conducted a "head-to-head" experimental trial using nine simply supported one-way concrete slabs (762 mm x 2286 mm x 114 mm). They divided the specimens into three groups based on reinforcement type:

  1. 6 mm WWR (Class A): Locally produced, cold-drawn.
  2. 8 mm WWR (Class D): High-ductility grade.
  3. 10 mm Deformed Bars: Traditional rebar used as a control.

The slabs were subjected to two-point loading (pure bending) until failure. The team used a Universal Testing Machine (UTM) and a series of sensors—including load cells, dial gauges for vertical deflection, and extensometers for the steel itself—to capture high-resolution data on how the slabs deformed under stress.

Datasets

As an experimental engineering paper, the "dataset" consists of the primary data generated from the nine slab specimens. This includes:

  • Material properties: Yield strength, tensile strength, and elongation percentages for each steel type.
  • Load-Deflection Curves: Real-time data showing how much the slab bent before failing.
  • Ductility Factors: Calculated ratios ($\mu_\Delta$) comparing ultimate deflection to deflection at the yield point.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Class" Matters: The most striking finding was the divide between Class A and Class D steel. The 6 mm Class A WWR failed to meet ASTM A1064 specifications. Its elongation was only 4%, compared to 13% for the Class D materials.
  • Uniform Cracking vs. Ductility: Interestingly, WWR-reinforced slabs showed more uniformly distributed crack propagation than traditional rebar. This is generally a positive trait for durability, as it prevents single, massive cracks from forming.
  • Catastrophic Failure: The 6 mm WWR slabs failed via "rupture"—the wires literally snapped. In contrast, the 10 mm rebar slabs failed via "yielding," where the steel stretched significantly before the concrete eventually gave way, providing a much safer failure mode.
  • The Welding Notch: The paper reinforces the theory that the heat of welding reduces the plastic range of the steel, making the choice of base material (hot-rolled vs. cold-drawn) even more critical for WWR.

Key Results

  • Ductility Factor ($\mu_\Delta$): The 6 mm WWR was significantly less ductile, with factors ranging from 1.15 to 1.28. The 8 mm WWR (2.95–5.12) and 10 mm rebar (2.41–4.98) showed much higher energy absorption capacity.
  • Maximum Deflection: The 6 mm WWR slabs fractured at a vertical deflection of only ~20 mm. The 8 mm WWR and 10 mm rebar slabs were able to deflect up to 76 mm and 80 mm respectively before failure.
  • Flexural Strength: The 8 mm WWR exhibited higher flexural strength than the 6 mm version, satisfying both design loads and safety margins, whereas the 6 mm version's early failure makes it unsuitable for suspended structural slabs.

Limitations and Future Work

The study is limited by its sample size (nine slabs) and focuses specifically on one-way slabs under pure bending. The authors note that while 8 mm WWR is suitable for general structural use per ACI 318, the 6 mm Class A variety should be avoided in RC slabs.

Future research could expand this to two-way slabs or investigate the performance of these materials under seismic (cyclic) loading, where ductility is even more critical. Additionally, exploring the effects of "annealing" (heat treatment) to see if it can recover some of the lost ductility in cold-drawn WWR could be a valuable next step for manufacturers.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study evaluates the flexural strength and ductility of one-way concrete slab panels reinforced with deformed bar and welded wire under the application of pure bending. An experimental database of flexural strength and ductility for a set of three slab panels reinforced with 10 mm deformed bar, three panels with 6 mm welded wire reinforcement (WWR), and three panels with 8 mm WWR has been developed, with each slab panel having a dimension of 762 mm by 2286 mm. The deflection and ductility factors of the specimens are investigated. The results show that the slab panels reinforced with 6 mm WWR exhibit less vertical deflection at fracture in comparison to those with 8 mm WWR. Welded wire reinforced slab panels demonstrated uniformly distributed crack propagation in comparison to deformed bars. In addition, the slab panels with 8 mm WWR exhibit higher flexural strength than the 6 mm WWR reinforced panels. The 10 mm deformed bar-reinforced slab panels exhibited greater deflection at fracture compared to WWR specimens. The reason for the lower ductile behavior of slab panels with 6 mm WWR is due to the fact that 6 mm WWR, produced locally in Bangladesh, is manufactured by the cold-drawn method and has a lower ductility in compliance with BDS ISO 6935 Class A, which does not conform to ASTM A1064. Both 8 mm WWR and 10 mm deformed bars conform to BDS ISO 6935 Class D and ASTM A1064. Hence, the 6 mm WWR with Class A ductility is not recommended for reinforced concrete (RC) slab panels based on the experimental results conducted in this study, whereas the 8 mm WWR and the 10 mm deformed bar with Class D ductility are suitable for structural use as recommended in ACI 318.
BibTeX
@misc{mahdi2023experimental,
  author = {Mofid Mahdi and Faez Ahmed and Ifty Ahmed and N. Islam},
  title = {{Experimental Evaluation of Flexural Strength and Ductility of One-Way Concrete Slab Panels Reinforced with Welded Wires and Deformed Bars}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.23967/c.dbmc.2023.035},
}
Figure