Experimental Constraints on Exotic Spin-Dependent Interactions by a Magnetometer with Ensembles of Nitrogen-Vacancy Centers in Diamond

Hang Liang, Man Jiao, Yue Huang, Pei Yu, Xiangyu Ye, Ya Wang, Yijin Xie, Yi-Fu Cai, Xing Rong, Jiangfeng DuarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Improved constraints on exotic spin-dependent interactions are established at the micrometer scale by a magnetometer with ensembles of nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centers in diamond. A thin layer of NV electronic spin ensembles is utilized as the sensor, and a lead sphere is taken as the source of the nucleons. The exotic spin-dependent interactions are explored by detecting the possible effective magnetic fields by the sensor. Stringent bounds on an exotic parity-odd spin- and velocity-dependent interaction are set within the force range from 5 to 500 $\mu$m. The upper limit of the corresponding coupling constant, $g_A^eg_V^N$, is improved by more than three orders of magnitude at 330 $\mu$m. Improved constraints of $P, T$-violating scalar-pseudoscalar nucleon-electron interactions, are established within the force range from 6 to 45 $\mu$m. The limit of the corresponding coupling constant, $g_S^Ng_P^e$, is improved by more than one order of magnitude at 30 $\mu$m. Our result shows that a magnetometer with a NV ensemble can be a powerful platform for probing exotic spin-dependent interactions.

Introduction

While the Standard Model of particle physics has been exceptionally successful, it fails to account for several fundamental phenomena, most notably the nature of dark matter. Many theoretical frameworks, such as string theory, predict the existence of new, light bosons like axions. These hypothetical particles could mediate "exotic" short-range interactions between fermions—such as electrons and nucleons—that are not described by gravity or electromagnetism.

These forces are predicted to be extremely weak and often depend on the spin or velocity of the interacting particles. Detecting them requires high-precision instruments capable of operating at the micrometer scale, where these forces are expected to manifest. Traditional tools like torsion pendulums and SQUIDs face challenges in spatial resolution or sensitivity at sub-millimeter ranges. This study utilizes a high-sensitivity magnetometer based on ensembles of nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centers in diamond to probe these interactions with unprecedented precision.

Experimental Methodology

The researchers developed a specialized experimental setup centered on an ensemble-NV-diamond magnetometer. Unlike single NV center sensors, this approach utilizes a 23-$\mu$m-thick layer of diamond doped with a high concentration (14 ppm) of NV centers. This ensemble significantly enhances magnetic field sensitivity, achieving a level of $1.4 \text{ nT/Hz}^{1/2}$.

Schematic of the experimental setup for detecting exotic spin-dependent interactions.

A high-purity lead sphere (approximately 1 mm in radius) serves as the nucleon source. This sphere is mounted on a piezoelectric bender and vibrated at a specific modulation frequency ($f_M \approx 1.95$ kHz) at micrometer distances from the diamond surface. If exotic interactions exist, this vibration would induce a tiny, oscillating "effective magnetic field" ($B_{eff}$) detectable by the NV centers. The detection system employs a dual lock-in amplifier (LIA) setup to extract these faint signals from the background noise over an extensive measurement period.

Data Acquisition and Analysis

The experiment relied on 291.9 hours of continuous magnetic field measurements. To establish theoretical bounds, the team performed Monte Carlo simulations to model the expected effective magnetic fields for two specific exotic interactions: axial-vector/vector ($V_{AV}$) and scalar-pseudoscalar ($V_{SP}$).

A key technical advantage of this setup is the ability to perform simultaneous probing. By analyzing the "in-phase" and "quadrature" components of the demodulated signal, the researchers could search for both velocity-dependent and velocity-independent interactions in a single experimental run. This dual-component analysis is critical for distinguishing between different types of hypothetical boson-mediated forces.

Results and Discussion

The experimental data showed no evidence of exotic forces, allowing the researchers to establish new, more stringent upper limits on the coupling constants of these hypothetical interactions. The sensitivity and stability of the measurement over the 292-hour period were verified through statistical analysis of the noise distribution.

Long-term magnetic field measurements and statistical distribution of noise.

Key results include:

  • $V_{AV}$ Interaction: For the axial-vector/vector coupling ($g_A^e g_V^N$), the experimental bound was improved by more than three orders of magnitude at a force range of 330 $\mu$m.
  • $V_{SP}$ Interaction: For the scalar-pseudoscalar coupling ($g_S^N g_P^e$), the bound was improved by more than one order of magnitude at a force range of 30 $\mu$m.
  • Force Range: These constraints represent the most stringent laboratory limits for the force ranges of 5–500 $\mu$m ($V_{AV}$) and 6–45 $\mu$m ($V_{SP}$).

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This work demonstrates that NV ensemble magnetometry is a powerful platform for exploring physics beyond the Standard Model. While the current results set record-breaking constraints, the primary limitation remains the magnetic sensitivity of the NV ensemble. Future improvements may involve optimizing NV concentration to enhance coherence times, utilizing advanced quantum techniques like double resonance, and implementing engineering upgrades such as silicon carbide heatsinks to improve signal contrast. These advancements could allow for even deeper probes into the parameter space of exotic spin-dependent interactions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Improved constraints on exotic spin-dependent interactions are established at the micrometer scale by a magnetometer with ensembles of nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centers in diamond. A thin layer of NV electronic spin ensembles is utilized as the sensor, and a lead sphere is taken as the source of the nucleons. The exotic spin-dependent interactions are explored by detecting the possible effective magnetic fields by the sensor. Stringent bounds on an exotic parity-odd spin- and velocity-dependent interaction are set within the force range from 5 to 500 $μ$m. The upper limit of the corresponding coupling constant, $g_A^eg_V^N$, is improved by more than three orders of magnitude at 330 $μ$m. Improved constraints of $P, T$-violating scalar-pseudoscalar nucleon-electron interactions, are established within the force range from 6 to 45 $μ$m. The limit of the corresponding coupling constant, $g_S^Ng_P^e$, is improved by more than one order of magnitude at 30 $μ$m. Our result shows that a magnetometer with a NV ensemble can be a powerful platform for probing exotic spin-dependent interactions.
BibTeX
@misc{liang2022experimental,
  author = {Hang Liang and Man Jiao and Yue Huang and Pei Yu and Xiangyu Ye and Ya Wang and Yijin Xie and Yi-Fu Cai and Xing Rong and Jiangfeng Du},
  title = {{Experimental Constraints on Exotic Spin-Dependent Interactions by a Magnetometer with Ensembles of Nitrogen-Vacancy Centers in Diamond}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2201.04408},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2201.04408},
}
Figure