Experimental and Theoretical Study of the Effects of Rare Earth Elements on Growth and Chlorophyll of Alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) Seedling

Kexiao Song, Jinzhu Gao, Shuo Li, Yunfu Sun, Haoyang Sun, Baiyu An, Tianming Hu, Xueqing HeFrontiers in Plant Science 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Rare earth elements (REEs) such as lanthanum (La), cerium (Ce), and terbium (Tb) are known to influence plant growth in a concentration-dependent manner. This study investigates their effects on alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) seedlings, revealing that while low concentrations can accelerate germination and stimulate root growth, they simultaneously lead to a significant reduction in chlorophyll content. Through a combination of seedling assays, spectroscopic analysis, and quantum chemical modeling, we demonstrate that REE ions physically replace magnesium in chlorophyll molecules. This substitution creates stable lanthanide-chlorophyll complexes with diminished light-absorption capabilities, explaining the observed physiological decline in photosynthetic pigments.

Introduction

Rare earth elements (REEs) have been employed as agricultural growth stimulants for decades, particularly in China. However, their impact on plant physiology is complex, often characterized by a "hormesis effect"—where low doses stimulate growth while higher doses induce toxicity. A persistent concern in REE application is the observed decline in chlorophyll content. This research seeks to determine whether this decline results from inhibited synthesis or direct molecular interference, bridging the gap between macro-scale growth observations and micro-scale quantum chemistry.

Methodology

The study utilized a multi-scale experimental design:

  • In Vivo Seedling Assays: Alfalfa seeds were treated with 10 and 20 μM concentrations of La, Ce, and Tb. Growth parameters, including germination rate, shoot/root length, and total chlorophyll content, were monitored.
  • In Vitro Spectroscopy: Pure chlorophyll was mixed with REE nitrates in ethanol to observe changes in light absorbance over 120 hours using UV-VIS spectrophotometry.
  • Quantum Chemical Calculations: Density Functional Theory (DFT) was used to model the molecular geometries and electronic absorption spectra of potential REE-chlorophyll complexes, determining the thermodynamic favorability of magnesium replacement.

Results and Discussion

Impact on Germination and Growth

The application of REEs significantly altered early seedling development. All REE treatments were found to accelerate the speed of germination compared to the control group, as observed in the early stages of growth.

Germination rate at 4 days showing accelerated growth under REE treatment.

Furthermore, root development exhibited a clear hormesis effect. At 10 μM concentrations, REEs generally stimulated root elongation. However, increasing the concentration to 20 μM often led to inhibitory effects or reduced stimulation, particularly in the case of Lanthanum, where shoot length was also significantly reduced.

Root length measurements illustrating the hormesis effect of REEs.

Chlorophyll Degradation and Molecular Substitution

Despite the initial growth boost, chlorophyll content decreased significantly across all REE treatments. The degree of decline followed the order La < Ce < Tb at equivalent concentrations.

Quantum chemical modeling provided a structural explanation for this phenomenon. The calculations predicted that REE ions ($La^{3+}$, $Ce^{3+}$, $Tb^{3+}$) can spontaneously replace the central $Mg^{2+}$ ion in the chlorophyll's porphyrin ring. The resulting "lanthanide-chlorophyll" structures are thermodynamically stable but possess lower absorption intensities in the visible spectrum. The ease of this substitution follows the hierarchy $La < Ce < Tb$, directly correlating with the observed severity of chlorophyll loss in living seedlings.

Conclusion

This study confirms that while REEs can jumpstart alfalfa germination and root growth at specific low concentrations, they compromise the plant's photosynthetic machinery at a molecular level. The degradation of chlorophyll is driven by the physical replacement of magnesium by lanthanide ions, creating pigments that are less effective at harvesting light. These findings highlight the need for precise dosage control when using REEs in agricultural applications to avoid long-term photosynthetic impairment.

Summary updated

Abstract

Rare earth elements (REEs) of low concentration are usually beneficial to plant growth, while they are toxic at high concentrations. The effects of treatment with lanthanum (La) (10 and 20 μM), cerium (Ce) (10 and 20 μM), and terbium (Tb) (10 and 20 μM) on seedling growth of alfalfa (<i>Medicago sativa</i> L.), which is one of the most important perennial leguminous forages in the world, were studied. The results showed that all three REE treatments quickened the germination of seeds. The length of shoot under La (20 μM) treatment was significantly shortened (<i>P</i> < 0.05). In addition, treatment with La, Ce, and Tb had a "hormesis effect" on root length. There was a significant decrease in chlorophyll content on treatment with the three REEs, and the degree of decline was in the order of La < Ce < Tb, under the same concentration. <i>In vitro</i> experiments and quantum chemical calculations were further performed to explain why the treatments with REEs reduced the chlorophyll content. <i>In vitro</i> experiments showed that La, Ce, and Tb treatments reduced the absorbance of chlorophyll, and the decrease followed in the order of La > Ce > Tb. Quantum chemical calculations predicted that the decrease in absorption intensity was caused by the reactions between La, Ce, Tb, and chlorophyll, which formed lanthanides-chlorophyll; and there were five types of stable lanthanides-chlorophyll. In conclusion, the decrease in chlorophyll content on treatment with REEs was caused by the change in chlorophyll structure.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{song2021experimental,
  author = {Kexiao Song and Jinzhu Gao and Shuo Li and Yunfu Sun and Haoyang Sun and Baiyu An and Tianming Hu and Xueqing He},
  title = {{Experimental and Theoretical Study of the Effects of Rare Earth Elements on Growth and Chlorophyll of Alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) Seedling}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2021.731838},
}
Figure