Experimental and Numerical Study of a UAV Propeller Printed in Clear Resin

Mingtai Chen, Jacob Wimsatt, Tianming Liu, Tiegang FangAerospace 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates a 3D-printed resin propeller for UAVs, comparing its performance and noise against commercial alternatives both experimentally and through CFD simulations. They introduce a novel "propeller trade-off index" to better balance efficiency and noise, finding the resin propeller offers a compelling combination of low noise and good performance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) become more prevalent, especially in urban air mobility (UAM) concepts, their noise footprint is a significant concern. Propellers are a primary source of this noise. While optimizing propellers for thrust and efficiency is crucial for battery life and performance, doing so without increasing noise is a complex challenge. Existing research often focuses on one aspect (performance or noise) in isolation, neglecting the critical need to balance both. This paper aims to bridge this gap by evaluating a novel 3D-printed propeller and proposing a new metric to assess this performance-noise trade-off.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Experimental Setup: A 254 mm diameter resin-printed propeller was tested alongside two commercial propellers (APC and JZ Zinger) in an anechoic chamber. Thrust and torque were measured using a six-degree-of-freedom load cell, and acoustic data was captured by a microphone positioned at a distance of 6R from the propeller center.
  • Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD): ANSYS Fluent was used to simulate the propeller's behavior. They utilized a Detached Eddy Simulation (DES) model for turbulence, coupled with the Ffowcs-Williams and Hawkings (FW-H) model for aeroacoustic predictions and a transient flow solver. This combination was chosen to improve upon previous RANS-based simulations that struggled with broadband noise prediction.
  • Aeroacoustic Analysis: Standard Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) was applied to pressure data to analyze primary tonal noise, broadband noise, and Overall Sound Pressure Level (OASPL). A novel "propeller trade-off index" ($\chi$) was developed, weighting propeller performance (Figure of Merit, FM) and primary tonal noise.
  • Aerodynamic Analysis: Vorticity iso-surfaces (using the Q-criterion) and the RMS of the time rate of static pressure were analyzed to identify aerodynamic phenomena contributing to noise.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental measurements and CFD simulations of the tested propellers.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • 3D-Printed Propellers are Viable: The resin-printed propeller demonstrates competitive performance and superior noise characteristics compared to commercial alternatives, suggesting 3D printing is a viable manufacturing method for UAV propellers.
  • A New Metric is Needed: Traditional metrics like Figure of Merit (FM) or Thrust-Noise Ratio (TNR) don't fully capture the complex balance between propeller performance and noise. The proposed "propeller trade-off index" ($\chi$) offers a more holistic evaluation.
  • Flow Separation is Key to Noise: The study visually identifies specific areas of flow separation on the propeller blade (leading edge near the tip for tonal noise, trailing edge for broadband noise) that are direct contributors to noise generation.
  • CFD Accuracy Varies: While ANSYS Fluent with DES and FW-H models accurately predicts primary tonal noise, it shows larger discrepancies for broadband noise and OASPL, highlighting areas for further CFD model development.

Key Results

  • Performance: The resin propeller achieved an average Figure of Merit (FM) of 0.64, slightly outperforming the APC (0.61) and wooden (0.63) propellers. CFD simulations predicted thrust and torque coefficients within a 10% error margin.
  • Aeroacoustics: The resin propeller exhibited the lowest primary tonal noise, broadband noise, and OASPL across the tested rotational speeds (3000-9000 RPM).
  • Trade-off Index: The proposed trade-off index ($\chi$) consistently ranked the resin propeller highest, indicating a better balance between performance and noise compared to the APC and wooden propellers.
  • CFD vs. Experiment: ANSYS Fluent showed good agreement with experimental data for primary tonal noise, with the largest discrepancy around 6600 RPM.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Motor Noise: The experimental acoustic data includes electric motor noise, which is difficult to fully separate from propeller noise, potentially affecting the accuracy of broadband noise and OASPL comparisons.
  • CFD Broadband Noise: The FW-H model's limitations in accurately predicting broadband noise were noted, suggesting that alternative approaches like Lighthill's analogy might be necessary for more precise results.
  • Weight and Cost: While performance and noise are good, the resin propeller is heavier than the lightest wooden propeller and incurs higher printing costs and production time.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring different propeller designs, optimizing the trade-off index weights for specific applications, and further refining CFD models for more accurate broadband noise prediction. Investigating the impact of flow separation on propeller torque and noise in more detail is also a promising avenue.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper presents an experimental and numerical investigation of a 254 mm resin-printed propeller operating at rotational speeds between 3000 and 9000 RPM. Propeller thrust and torque were measured using a six-degree-of-freedom load cell, while acoustic data were captured with a microphone positioned three times the propeller diameter from the center. To complement the experimental analysis, computational simulations were conducted using ANSYS Fluent with the detached eddy simulation (DES) model, the Ffowcs-Williams and Hawkings (FW-H) model, and a transient flow solver. The figure of merit (FM) results show that the resin propeller slightly outperforms two commercial counterparts with a marginal difference between the wood and resin propellers. Additionally, the resin propeller demonstrates better noise performance, exhibiting the lowest primary tonal noise, broadband noise, and overall sound pressure level (OASPL), with minimal differences between the two commercial counterparts. ANSYS Fluent simulations predict thrust and torque within a 10% error margin, showing particularly accurate results for primary tonal noise. A new trade-off index is proposed to assess the balance between propeller performance and aeroacoustics, revealing distinct trends compared to traditional metrics. Furthermore, aerodynamic phenomena such as flow separation on the leading edge near the tip, flow separation behind the middle trailing edge, and vortex interactions at the root are identified as key contributors to tonal and broadband noise. These findings provide valuable insights into propeller design and aeroacoustic optimization.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2025experimental,
  author = {Mingtai Chen and Jacob Wimsatt and Tianming Liu and Tiegang Fang},
  title = {{Experimental and Numerical Study of a UAV Propeller Printed in Clear Resin}},
  booktitle = {Aerospace},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/aerospace12050362},
}
Figure