Experimental and Numerical Investigation of Phase Separation due to Multi-Component Mixing at High-Pressure Conditions

Christoph Traxinger, Hagen Müller, Michael Pfitzner, Steffen Baab, Grazia Lamanna, Bernhard Weigand, Jan Matheis, Christian Stemmer, Nikolaus A. Adams, Stefan Hickel2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the complex phenomenon of phase separation when a supercritical fluid (n-hexane) is injected into a gaseous environment (nitrogen) at high pressures. By combining advanced experimental techniques with large-eddy simulations, the researchers successfully captured the transition from a dense-gas jet to a spray-like jet, validating the predictive capabilities of their numerical model. This work is crucial for improving the design and efficiency of energy conversion systems that operate under such extreme conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern energy conversion machines, like aircraft and car engines, are increasingly operating at pressures that exceed the critical point of the fluids involved. This push for higher efficiency leads to supercritical conditions where fluids exhibit highly non-linear thermodynamic properties. A key challenge in these systems is understanding and predicting phase separation – the formation of distinct liquid and vapor phases – which can occur even when the initial state is supercritical. This phenomenon is particularly complex in multi-component mixtures and is not yet fully understood, lacking a universally accepted theoretical framework. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by providing detailed experimental data and validated numerical simulations of a relevant multi-component system (n-hexane injected into nitrogen) under supercritical conditions.

Methods

The researchers employed a dual approach:

  • Experimental Setup: They utilized a specialized high-pressure chamber with optical access. N-hexane was injected into a chamber filled with nitrogen at 5 MPa and 293 K. To visualize the process, they combined:
  • Simultaneous Shadowgraphy: This technique captures the overall flow structure and density gradients.
  • Elastic Light Scattering (ELS): This method is sensitive to the presence of small particles or droplets, allowing for the detection of phase separation. By using a single laser source for both techniques and spectral filtering, they ensured instantaneous and simultaneous data acquisition.
  • Numerical Simulations: Large-Eddy Simulations (LES) were performed using two different solvers (INCA and OpenFOAM), both incorporating an identical vapor-liquid equilibrium (VLE) model. The core of their numerical approach lies in:
  • Peng-Robinson Equation of State (PR-EoS): This cubic equation of state is used to accurately model the thermodynamic properties of non-ideal fluids at high pressures, which is crucial for predicting phase behavior.
  • Vapor-Liquid Equilibrium (VLE) Model: This model, inspired by Qiu and Reitz, determines if a mixture is thermodynamically unstable and will separate into vapor and liquid phases by calculating the Gibbs energy and using the tangent plane distance (TPD) method.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets for training. Instead, it uses:

  • Experimental Data: The study generates novel experimental data from their high-pressure injection setup, capturing simultaneous shadowgraphy and ELS images for three distinct test cases.
  • Reference Data: They compare their numerical results against experimental data from literature (e.g., for vapor-liquid equilibria) and thermodynamic property databases like CoolProp [17] and Dortmund Data Bank Software & Separation Technology (DDBST).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Predictive Power of VLE Models: The study demonstrates that incorporating a VLE model into LES simulations is essential for accurately predicting phase separation in supercritical injection scenarios. The model successfully identified regimes where phase separation was expected.
  • Transition from Dense-Gas to Spray-Like Jets: The experiments and simulations clearly show a transition in jet behavior as injection temperature changes. At higher temperatures, the jet behaves like a dense gas, while at lower temperatures, it exhibits distinct droplet formation characteristic of a spray.
  • Sensitivity to Thermodynamic Conditions: The phase separation behavior is highly sensitive to the initial thermodynamic conditions, particularly the injection temperature, which dictates whether the mixture enters a thermodynamically unstable region.
  • Importance of Accurate EoS: The use of a non-ideal gas equation of state (PR-EoS) is critical, as ideal gas assumptions lead to significant deviations in predicting fluid properties at supercritical pressures.
  • Experimental Validation is Key: The good agreement between experimental shadowgraphy/ELS data and the LES results with VLE provides strong validation for the numerical approach and highlights the importance of experimental data for understanding these complex phenomena.

Key Results

  • Three Test Cases: The study investigated three test cases (T480, T560, T600) with varying n-hexane injection temperatures.
  • Case T600 (Dense-Gas): This case, at the highest injection temperature, showed no significant phase separation. Both experiments and simulations indicated a single-phase, dense-gas jet.
  • Case T560 (Minor Phase Separation): At an intermediate temperature, minor phase separation was observed, particularly in the shear layer, which was well captured by the LES.
  • Case T480 (Spray-Like Jet): The lowest injection temperature resulted in significant phase separation, leading to a spray-like jet with droplet formation, which was accurately reproduced by the simulations.
  • Qualitative Agreement: The qualitative characteristics of the phase formation process, including the location and development of two-phase regions, showed excellent agreement between experimental observations and numerical predictions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • LES Eulerian Approach: The LES, being Eulerian, does not resolve individual droplets. The spray-like character is represented by the vapor volume fraction. This means that direct droplet size and number density information is not obtained from the LES.
  • Near-Injector Region: While the study provides good insights into the developed jet, a more detailed examination of the near-injector region is suggested for future work.
  • Transient vs. Averaged Data: Future investigations will involve a comparison of transient and averaged data from experiments and simulations to further refine understanding.
  • Heat Conduction: The authors mention that local violations of the adiabatic mixture assumption, potentially due to heat conduction, could contribute to observed scattering signals in the T600 case. Further investigation into these effects might be warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Experiments and numerical simulations were carried out in order to contribute to a better understanding and predic-tion of high-pressure injection into a gaseous environment. Specifically, the focus was put on the phase separation processes of an initially supercritical fluid due to the interaction with its surrounding. N-hexane was injected into a chamber filled with pure nitrogen at 5 MPa and 293 K and three different test cases were selected such that they cover regimes in which the thermodynamic non-idealities, in particular the effects that stem from the potential phase separation, are significant. Simultaneous shadowgraphy and elastic light scattering experiments were conducted to capture both the flow structure as well as the phase separation. In addition, large-eddy simulations with a vapor- liquid equilibrium model were performed. Both experimental and numerical results show phase formation for the cases, where the a-priori calculation predicts two-phase flow. Moreover, qualitative characteristics of the formation process agree well between experiments and numerical simulations and the transition behaviour from a dense-gasto a spray-like jet was captured by both.DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.4995/ILASS2017.2017.4756
BibTeX
@misc{traxinger2017experimental,
  author = {Christoph Traxinger and Hagen Müller and Michael Pfitzner and Steffen Baab and Grazia Lamanna and Bernhard Weigand and Jan Matheis and Christian Stemmer and Nikolaus A. Adams and Stefan Hickel},
  title = {{Experimental and Numerical Investigation of Phase Separation due to Multi-Component Mixing at High-Pressure Conditions}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.4995/ilass2017.2017.4756},
}
Figure