Experiential analysis of Integration of Two Industries to Promote New Services of New Quality Productivity

Xi Peng, Hongyan Liu, Zheng YongsenJournal of Management and Social Development 2024 · DOI

Abstract

The integration of the modern service industry and the manufacturing sector is a critical pathway for establishing a modern economic system. This evolution is essential for adapting to the shifting international industrial division of labor, overcoming manufacturing development constraints, and accelerating the transformation of the service industry. By analyzing the industrial models of Tokyo, Singapore, Shanghai, and Hangzhou, this paper explores how the "integration of two industries" cultivates new productive forces. These models range from Tokyo's IT-connected industrial systems and Singapore's smart factory initiatives to Hangzhou's digital-led "service derivative manufacturing," providing a roadmap for the development of "new services."

Introduction: The Imperative of Industrial Fusion

In the current global economic landscape, the traditional boundaries between manufacturing and services are rapidly dissolving. This paper addresses the concept of "New Quality Productive Forces"—a strategic framework introduced to transition economies from traditional production-heavy models to high-value-added, integrated systems. The core challenge lies in the disparity between China’s producer services sector and those of developed nations. While producer services (R&D, logistics, IT, etc.) account for approximately 56% of GDP in the United States and 40-50% in G20 countries, they represent only 17-18% of China's GDP. To bridge this gap, industries must move beyond simple production and embrace the "integration of two industries."

Methodology

This research employs a comparative experiential analysis, performing a qualitative deep dive into the policy frameworks and industrial strategies of four global hubs:

  • Tokyo, Japan: Focuses on IT-connected industrial models and industry-university-research cooperation.
  • Singapore: Emphasizes "Industry 4.0," smart factories, and global supply chain management.
  • Shanghai, China: Concentrates on policy-driven producer services and integrated general contracting.
  • Hangzhou, China: Leverages a robust digital economy to promote "service derivative manufacturing."

The "Three News" Framework

The study deconstructs "New Quality Productivity" into three essential pillars:

  1. New Manufacturing: Focusing on strategic emerging industries and high-tech production.
  2. New Services: Developing high-value-added producer services that act as intermediate inputs for production.
  3. New Forms: Embracing globalization and digitalization to create novel business models.

Global Models of Integration

Tokyo: The IT-Connected Model

Tokyo’s strategy centers on the "e-F@ctory" benchmark, exemplified by Mitsubishi Electric. This model integrates Artificial Intelligence with Factory Automation IT (FA-IT). By creating a digital service network within the factory, this approach has demonstrated a 96% reduction in power consumption and a 70% increase in sales. Furthermore, the proportion of companies collecting real-time factory data in Tokyo rose from 40% to 88% following the implementation of these "IT-connected" strategies.

Singapore: Smart Factories and 7PL Logistics

Singapore has positioned itself as a global supply chain neural center through "Industry 4.0" initiatives. A key innovation is the transition to "7PL" (Seventh Party Logistics). By utilizing trade management platforms like TradeNet, Singapore provides one-stop customs and supply chain services, effectively merging logistics with high-level data management.

Hangzhou: Service Derivative Manufacturing

Hangzhou offers a unique model where the service sector "pulls" the manufacturing sector. By leveraging big data from e-commerce platforms, companies can dictate manufacturing designs based on real-time consumer trends. This "service derivative manufacturing" ensures that production is tightly coupled with market demand, reducing waste and increasing relevance.

Key Results and Policy Momentum

The integration of these industries has yielded significant measurable outcomes:

  • Efficiency: Integrated IT solutions in Tokyo-based factories have led to cost reductions of up to 30%.
  • Institutional Support: There has been a massive surge in policy support in China, with over 115 national and provincial policies issued between 2019 and 2024 to facilitate industrial merger.
  • Digital Transformation: The shift from traditional manufacturing to data-driven production nodes has enabled more resilient and flexible supply chains.

Limitations and Future Outlook

While the experiential analysis provides a clear high-level summary of regional success stories, it remains primarily descriptive. Future research should aim for more granular quantitative analysis to correlate specific policy implementations with local GDP growth. Additionally, the high upfront costs of "Industry 4.0" integration remain a barrier for small-to-medium enterprises (SMEs).

To sustain this momentum, the authors suggest focusing on cultivating "manufacturing + service" suppliers with strong independent innovation capabilities. Expanding these models to "Belt and Road" countries could further extend the reach of these new quality productive forces, creating a more integrated and efficient global industrial order.

Summary updated

Abstract

Integration of modern service industry and manufacturing industry is an important way to constitute a modern economic system, which is of great significance to adapting to the new international industrial division of labor environment and order, breaking the development constraints of manufacturing industry, and promoting the transformation and upgrading of the service industry. In Tokyo's IT technology and connected industrial model, Singapore focuses on smart factories, industrial Internet, shared production, supply chain management and full life cycle management. Hangzhou gradually explore form "digital + service + derivative manufacturing, service manufacturing, supply chain management, system overall solution" of the two industries fusion path. Development experience of "integration of two industries" will cultivate new productive forces for "new service".
BibTeX
@article{peng2024experiential,
  author = {Xi Peng and Hongyan Liu and Zheng Yongsen},
  title = {{Experiential analysis of Integration of Two Industries to Promote New Services of New Quality Productivity}},
  journal = {Journal of management and social development.},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.62517/jmsd.202412412},
}
Figure