Experiences of current vital signs monitoring practices and views of wearable monitoring: A qualitative study in patients and nurses

Carlos Areia, Elizabeth King, Jody Ede, Louise Young, Lionel Tarassenko, Peter Watkinson, Sarah VollamJournal of Advanced Nursing 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This qualitative study explores current vital signs monitoring practices and patient/nurse perspectives on wearable monitoring in a surgical ward. Findings suggest a need for ambulatory monitoring systems to improve patient mobility and efficiency, but with careful consideration to avoid increased noise and to ensure they augment, rather than replace, direct nursing care.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Hospitals routinely monitor patients' vital signs to detect deterioration, often using intermittent measurements or wired, static continuous monitoring systems. While effective, these methods have limitations: intermittent monitoring can lead to delayed detection, and wired systems restrict patient mobility and comfort. The paper investigates the current experiences and challenges with these methods and explores the potential of wearable, ambulatory monitoring systems as a solution, aiming to understand how such technology could be integrated into the general ward environment.

Methods

The study employed a qualitative design using semi-structured interviews with 15 patients and 15 nurses on a surgical ward. A topic guide was used to explore current monitoring practices, and the concept of ambulatory wearable devices was introduced towards the end of each interview. Thematic analysis, following Braun and Clarke's six-phase approach, was used to analyze the interview transcripts. Rigor was maintained through team discussions, a reflective account of each interview, and adherence to COREQ guidelines.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Vital Signs as Evidence for Escalation: Nurses rely heavily on vital sign data to justify escalating care, especially when a patient's condition is deteriorating but hasn't met formal "trigger" thresholds. This highlights the importance of objective data in clinical decision-making, but also the challenge of convincing others when intuition suggests a problem.
  • Trust in the Data: Nurses often manually recheck automated vital sign readings, particularly for heart rate and blood pressure, if they suspect inaccuracies. This "trustworthiness" is crucial, and nurses have developed strategies to reconcile automated data with their clinical judgment, especially when factors like cold peripheries might affect device readings.
  • The Balancing Act of Continuous Monitoring: While continuous monitoring offers reassurance and potential for earlier detection, it comes with significant drawbacks. Patients and nurses alike noted issues with restricted mobility due to wires, noise pollution from alarms, and the potential for alarm fatigue.
  • Wearables as a Promising, but Not Perfect, Solution: Both patients and nurses viewed ambulatory wearable devices positively, seeing them as a way to improve mobility and patient comfort compared to wired systems. However, there was a strong consensus that these devices should support clinical decision-making and not replace direct nurse-patient interaction.

Key Results

  • Themes Identified: Three interconnected themes emerged: "Vital sign data as evidence for escalation," "Trustworthiness of vital sign data," and "Finding a balance between continuous and intermittent monitoring."
  • Patient and Nurse Agreement: Both groups agreed that continuous monitoring can improve patient safety but needs careful consideration due to limitations. They also agreed that ambulatory wearable devices could offer solutions but should not replace direct nursing contact or add to ward noise.
  • Manual Checks are Common: Nurses frequently perform manual checks of vital signs (heart rate, blood pressure, respiratory rate) when automated readings are suspected to be inaccurate.
  • Mobility and Comfort Concerns: Patients and staff highlighted that continuous monitoring, especially with wired systems, significantly impacts patient mobility and comfort.
  • Alarm Fatigue is Real: Both groups acknowledged that the constant noise from alarms can be frustrating for patients and may lead to nurses becoming desensitized to them.

Limitations and Future Work

The study acknowledges limitations including a relatively small sample size from a single surgical ward, which may limit the transferability of findings. The suboptimal setting for some interviews also posed a challenge. Future work could explore the perspectives of other healthcare professionals (doctors, healthcare assistants) and investigate the integration of ambulatory monitoring data into existing hospital systems. The authors emphasize the need for future developments in wearable technology to balance increased surveillance with patient comfort and reassurance, ensuring they augment rather than replace essential human interaction in healthcare.

Summary updated

Abstract

Feedback from nurses and patients suggests there is scope for ambulatory monitoring systems to be integrated into the hospital environment; however, both groups emphasized these should not add more noise to the ward nor replace direct nursing contact.
BibTeX
@article{areia2021experiences,
  author = {Carlos Areia and Elizabeth King and Jody Ede and Louise Young and Lionel Tarassenko and Peter Watkinson and Sarah Vollam},
  title = {{Experiences of current vital signs monitoring practices and views of wearable monitoring: A qualitative study in patients and nurses}},
  journal = {Journal of Advanced Nursing},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1111/jan.15055},
}
Figure