Expected geoneutrino signal at JUNO using local integrated 3-D refined crustal model

Ran Han, Zhiwei Li, Ruohan Gao, Yao Sun, Xu Ya, Yaping Cheng, Guangzheng Jiang, Jie Pang, Feng‐Cheng Liu, Andong Wang, Yufei Xi, Liangjian Wen, Jun Cao, Yufeng Li, Li, Yu-FengarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Geoneutrinos serve as a potent tool for comprehending the radiogenic power and composition of Earth. Although geoneutrinos have been observed in prior experiments, the forthcoming generation of experiments, such as JUNO, will be necessary for fully harnessing their potential. Precise prediction of the crustal contribution is vital for interpreting particle physics measurements in the context of geo-scientific inquiries. Nonetheless, existing models such as JULOC and GIGJ have limitations in accurately forecasting the crustal contribution. This paper introduces JULOC-I, the novel 3-D integrated crustal model of JUNO, which employs seismic, gravity, rock sample, and heat flow data to precisely estimate the geoneutrino signal of the lithosphere. The model indicates elevated concentrations of uranium and thorium in southern China, resulting in unexpectedly strong geoneutrino signals. The accuracy of JULOC-I, coupled with a decade of experimental data, affords JUNO the opportunity to test multiple mantle models. Once operational, JUNO can validate the model predictions and enhance the precision of mantle measurements. All in all, the improved accuracy of JULOC-I represents a substantial stride towards comprehending the geochemical distribution of the South China crust, offering a valuable tool for investigating the composition and evolution of the Earth through geoneutrinos.

Introduction: The Geoneutrino Challenge

Geoneutrinos—antineutrinos produced by the radioactive decay of Uranium-238 ($^{238}$U) and Thorium-232 ($^{232}$Th) within the Earth—provide a direct window into the planet's internal radiogenic heat. This heat is a fundamental driver of plate tectonics, the geodynamo, and Earth's thermal evolution. However, detecting the faint signal from the deep mantle is a significant challenge because detectors are typically located within the continental crust, which is itself a major source of geoneutrinos.

For the Jiangmen Underground Neutrino Observatory (JUNO) in China, the crust within a 500 km radius accounts for over 50% of the total expected signal. Previous global models (e.g., CRUST 2.0) lack the necessary resolution, and earlier local models (JULOC, GIGJ) suffered from significant geochemical uncertainties. To isolate the mantle's contribution, a high-precision map of the local crustal chemistry is required.

Methodology: The JULOC-I Integrated Framework

The authors present the JULOC-I (JUNO LOCal - Integrated) model, which utilizes several technical advancements to refine signal predictions:

  • Joint Tomographic Inversion: The model integrates seismic surface wave dispersion with Bouguer gravity anomaly data to create a reliable 3-D structure of shear-wave velocities ($V_s$) and density across the South China Block.
  • Probabilistic Lithology Mapping: A 3-D grid ($0.4^\circ \times 0.4^\circ \times 1$ km cells) was established. Seismic velocities were converted to likely rock types using empirical relationships, determining the proportions of granite, sedimentary, and other lithologies.
  • Heat Flow Validation: The model's geochemical predictions were cross-referenced against 209 terrestrial heat flow measurements. By ensuring the calculated crustal heat aligned with observed surface heat flow (after accounting for the Moho flux), the authors validated the physical consistency of their chemical model.
  • Three-Flavor Oscillation Physics: Unlike simpler models, JULOC-I incorporates precise neutrino oscillation effects to calculate the final detectable flux at the JUNO site.
Methodological flowcharts for the JULOC-I model, illustrating the integration of seismic, gravity, and geochemical data to calculate geoneutrino flux.

Data Integration and Regional Characterization

The JULOC-I model is built upon a massive integration of local and global datasets, including seismic data from 600 stations and satellite gravity data (WGM2012). A cornerstone of the model is the geochemical database derived from 1,002 new rock samples collected from fresh outcrops within 500 km of JUNO. These samples were analyzed for U/Th concentrations using High-Resolution ICP-MS, providing an unprecedented level of detail for the upper crust.

Regional Moho depth map (left) and geological map (right) showing the distribution of rock samples and the JUNO detector location.

Key Results: A 'Radioactively Hot' South China

The integration of high-resolution geophysical and geochemical data led to several critical insights:

  • Enriched Local Signal: The model reveals that the South China crust is significantly more radioactive than global averages, primarily due to widespread granite intrusions. Consequently, the expected geoneutrino signal at JUNO is approximately 49.9 TNU (Terrestrial Neutrino Units), significantly higher than the ~30 TNU predicted by coarser global models.
  • Uncertainty Reduction: The cell-by-cell approach and dense sampling reduced the total signal uncertainty from 14% (in the original JULOC) to 11%.
  • Crustal Dominance: The local continental crust (within 500 km) contributes $29.25^{+3.10}_{-2.52}$ TNU, or nearly 75% of the total crustal signal. Within this local crust, the upper crust (UC) is responsible for 81.4% of the signal, justifying the intensive surface sampling campaign.

Discussion and Future Outlook

The precision of JULOC-I is high enough that JUNO will eventually be able to distinguish between competing models of Earth's mantle composition (e.g., Cosmochemical vs. Geodynamical models). While uncertainties remain regarding the deep crust (middle and lower layers) and oceanic regions due to sampling difficulties, JULOC-I provides the most accurate baseline to date.

Once JUNO begins operations, the observed geoneutrino flux will serve as the ultimate validation for this model. Discrepancies between the model and experimental data will likely drive further refinements in our understanding of the South China crustal structure and the Earth's deep interior.

Summary updated

Abstract

Geoneutrinos serve as a potent tool for comprehending the radiogenic power and composition of Earth. Although geoneutrinos have been observed in prior experiments, the forthcoming generation of experiments,such as JUNO, will be necessary for fully harnessing their potential. Precise prediction of the crustal contribution is vital for interpreting particlephysics measurements in the context of geo-scientific inquiries. Nonetheless, existing models such as JULOC and GIGJ have limitations in accurately forecasting the crustal contribution. This paper introduces JULOCI, the novel 3-D integrated crustal model of JUNO, which employs seismic, gravity, rock sample, and heat flow data to precisely estimate the geoneutrino signal of the lithosphere. The model indicates elevated concentrations of uranium and thorium in southern China, resulting in unexpectedly strong geoneutrino signals.The accuracy of JULOC-I, coupled with a decade of experimental data, affords JUNO the opportunity to test multiple mantle models. Once operational, JUNO can validate the model predictions and enhance the precision of mantle measurements. All in all, the improved accuracy ofJULOC-I represents a substantial stride towards comprehending the geochemical distribution of the South China crust, offering a valuable tool for investigating the composition and evolution of the Earth through geoneutrinos.
BibTeX
@misc{han2022expected,
  author = {Ran Han and Zhiwei Li and Ruohan Gao and Yao Sun and XU Ya and Yaping Cheng and Guangzheng Jiang and Jie Pang and Feng‐Cheng Liu and Andong Wang and Yufei Xi and Liangjian Wen and Jun Cao and Yufeng Li and Li, Yu-Feng},
  title = {{Expected geoneutrino signal at JUNO using local integrated 3-D refined crustal model}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2210.09165},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2210.09165},
}
Figure