Existence and uniqueness for anisotropic and crystalline mean curvature flows

Antonin Chambolle, Massimiliano Morini, Matteo Novaga, Marcello PonsiglioneJournal of the American Mathematical Society 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This research establishes a definitive existence and uniqueness result, up to the phenomenon of "fattening," for crystalline mean curvature flows involving forcing terms and arbitrary convex mobilities. By introducing a novel distributional formulation for the corresponding level set equations, the authors provide a framework that satisfies a comparison principle and exhibits stability under approximation. A primary achievement of this work is proving the convergence of the Almgren-Taylor-Wang (1993) minimizing movement scheme to a unique "flat flow" for general anisotropies, resolving a long-standing open question in geometric analysis.

Introduction

Mean Curvature Flow (MCF) is a fundamental process in geometry and physics, describing how a surface evolves with a velocity proportional to its local curvature. While the theory for smooth, isotropic surfaces is well-developed, many physical systems—particularly in metallurgy and crystal growth—exhibit anisotropy, where surface energy depends heavily on orientation.

The "crystalline" case represents the most singular form of anisotropy. In this regime, surface energy is non-smooth, causing surfaces to prefer flat facets over smooth curves. Analyzing these flows in dimensions $N \ge 3$ has historically been difficult because curvature becomes a non-local property of the facets, and topological singularities, such as "fattening" (where a surface suddenly develops a non-zero volume), can occur. This paper provides a rigorous mathematical foundation for these complex evolutions.

A Novel Distributional Framework

To address the singularities inherent in crystalline flows, the authors move away from tracking the surface directly. Instead, they utilize a level set approach, representing the surface as the boundary of a region defined by a function $u(x, t)$.

The core innovation is a new distributional formulation. Traditional viscosity solutions often struggle with the non-local and singular nature of crystalline curvature. The authors introduce a definition of a solution based on a distributional differential inequality involving distance functions. This formulation is robust enough to handle the "faceted" nature of the flow while still satisfying a comparison principle—the critical geometric property ensuring that if one shape starts inside another, it remains inside throughout the evolution.

Resolving the ATW Scheme Convergence

Since 1993, the Almgren-Taylor-Wang (ATW) minimizing movements scheme has been a standard variational tool for approximating mean curvature flows. It works by solving a sequence of discrete minimization problems over small time steps. However, its convergence to a unique continuous flow in the crystalline case remained unproven for higher dimensions.

This paper settles the debate by proving that the ATW scheme converges to a unique "flat flow" (up to fattening) for any convex mobility and dimension. This result bridges the gap between discrete numerical approximations and continuous geometric theory, providing a solid theoretical basis for simulations used in materials science.

Key Results and Stability

  • Existence and Uniqueness: The paper proves that for any initial closed set (even unbounded ones) and a Lipschitz forcing term, a unique crystalline flow exists, provided we account for potential fattening.
  • Stability Properties: The solutions are shown to be stable with respect to changes in initial data and anisotropy norms. This implies that small perturbations in the physical parameters of a crystal will not lead to radically different predicted shapes, a crucial requirement for physical relevance.
  • Theoretical Unification: The authors demonstrate that their distributional solutions coincide with classical viscosity solutions in smooth cases and with Giga-Požár solutions in specific 3D contexts, unifying several disparate branches of the theory.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

By providing a general existence and uniqueness theorem for crystalline mean curvature flows, this work resolves a major bottleneck in geometric analysis. While the mathematical treatment of "fattening" is now rigorous, the physical interpretation of this phenomenon remains an area for further study. Additionally, while the paper focuses on convex mobilities, extending these results to non-convex cases—where surfaces may develop complex microstructures—remains a significant challenge for future research. Nonetheless, the convergence of the ATW scheme provides immediate confidence in the numerical methods currently used to model crystal growth and phase transitions.

Summary updated

Abstract

An existence and uniqueness result, up to fattening, for crystalline mean curvature flows with forcing and arbitrary (convex) mobilities, is proven. This is achieved by introducing a new notion of solution to the corresponding level set formulation. Such solutions satisfy a comparison principle and stability properties with respect to the approximation by suitably regularized problems. The results are valid in any dimension and for arbitrary, possibly unbounded, initial closed sets. The approach accounts for the possible presence of a time-dependent bounded forcing term, with spatial Lipschitz continuity. As a result of our analysis, we deduce the convergence of a minimizing movement scheme proposed by Almgren, Taylor, and Wang (1993) to a unique (up to fattening) “flat flow” in the case of general, including crystalline, anisotropies, solving a long-standing open question.
BibTeX
@article{chambolle2019existence,
  author = {Antonin Chambolle and Massimiliano Morini and Matteo Novaga and Marcello Ponsiglione},
  title = {{Existence and uniqueness for anisotropic and crystalline mean curvature flows}},
  journal = {Journal of the American Mathematical Society},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1090/jams/919},
}
Figure